Title History:
- NWA Bluegrass Heavyweight title;
- NWA Tri-State Heavyweight title;
- HCW World title;
- MPW MX title defeating Matt Mason and Flash Fury in a 3-way match (October 13, 2006);
- NWA National title defeating Kory Williams (May 5, 2007);
- NWA National heavyweight title defeating Phil Shatter (February 19, 2011);
- IWA East Coast tag team titles w/The Juggulator defeating TJ Phillips and Trik Nasty (March 3, 2012);
- NWA Ring Warrior Bahamian title defeating The Giant Titan (May 30, 2012);
- Remix Pro heavyweight title defeating Facade (August 5, 2012);
- HWA heavyweight title defeating Ron Mathis (July 26, 2013);
- VOW heavyweight title defeating Jimmy Nutts (November 30, 2013);
- IWA East Coast heavyweight title defeating BJ Whitmer and Ron Mathis in a 3-way match (April 16, 2016);
- Remix Pro heavyweight title defeating Ron Mathis (October 1, 2016);
Career Highlights:
- September 9th 2000 – HCW Anarchy 2000: Chance Prophet defeated James Stephens to become the 1st HCW World Champion.
- August 5, 2003 – NWA Bluegrass: AJ Styles defeated Chance Prophet to retain the NWA World Title.
- November 5, 2003 – NWA TNA: Christopher Daniels defeated Chance Prophet in a match taped for Xplosion.
- April 17, 2004 – NWA TNA XPLOSION: Three Live Crew defeated Scotty Matthews and Chance Prophet and Ryan Boz.
- April 24, 2004 – NWA TNA XPLOSION: Three Live Crew defeated Ryan Boz and Scotty Matthews and Chance Prophet.
- August 7, 2004 – NWA TNA XPLOSION: Monty Brown defeated Chance Prophet.
- September 18, 2004 – Championship Wrestling: Eric Darkstorm defeated Chance Prophet.
- October 8, 2004 – NWA Bluegrass: Chance Prophet won three-way over Chad Collyer and Eric Darkstorm.
- October 16, 2004 – Supreme Championship Wrestling: Brad Lamen defeated Chance Prophet to win Supreme title.
- January 8, 2005 – Wrestlers of West Virginia: Chance Prophet defeated Jason Kincaid.
- January 14, 2005 – Wrestlers of West Virginia: Chance Prophet won Battle Royal.
- February 19, 2005 – NWA Wildside: Caprice Coleman defeated Chance Prophet.
- March 3, 2005 – C-Pro Entertainment Wrestling: Chance Phrophet defeated Chris King.
- April 6, 2005 – Powerslam Pro Wrestling: James Gibson (who is from Bailysville legit) defeated Chance Prophet.
- April 7, 2005 – Powerslam Pro Wrestling: James Storm defeated Chance Prophet.
- April 14, 2005 – Mountain State Wrestling: Chance Prophet vs Chris Gilbert ended in a Double Count out.
- May 21, 2005 – Mad Pro Wrestling: Chance Prophet defeated Carlton Kaz and Nigel McGuiness in a 3-WAY.
- July 2, 2005 – XMCW: TNA’s Abyss defeated Chance Prophet at the Saint Albans Riverfest.
- July 23, 2005 – SCW: Chance Prophet defeated Krazy K.
- December 17, 2005 – XMCW: Chance Prophet won a 12-MAN Extremes Stakes II Ladder Match to win the XIC Title.
- January 21, 2006 – XMCW: Chance Prophet defeated Flash Fury to retain XIC title with a thunderus powerbomb.
- February 4, 2006 – NWA Bluegrass: Chance Prophet defeated Jade Justice | Chance Prophet defeated Thunder.
- February 21, 2006 – XMCW: “Awsome” Allen defeated Chance Prophet and Noah Lott and Flash Fury in a #1 Contenders match.
- ~~~Chance Prophet first eliminated both Noah Lott and Flash Fury but was then eliminated by “Awesome” Allen.
- March 2, 2006 – Mad-Pro Wrestling (Tournament): Chance Prophet beat Crazy J | Matt Stryker beat Chance Prophet.
- March 18, 2006 – New Blood Wrestling: Ace Prime defeated Chance Prophet.
- May 25, 2006 – Mad Pro Wrestling: Chance Prophet vs Shigroth ended in a No Contest in a no disqualification match.
- June 16, 2006 – NWA-Bluegrass: Nigel McGuiness defeated Chance Prophet.
- November 2, 2006 – Mad-Pro Wrestling: Chance Prophet defeated Dave Crist to retain the MX Title.
- January 2007: Chance Prophet was accepted into the Intermediate Division at Ohio Valley Wrestling.
- March 4, 2007 – Empire Wrestling Federation: Chance Prophet defeated Bobby Jo Marshall.
- April 21, 2007 – Disciple Championship Wrestling: Chance Prophet defeated The Original Sinn.
- May 5, 2007 – NWA Bluegrass: Chance Prophet defeated Kory Williams to win the NWA National title.
- June 2, 2007 – NWA Bluegrass: Chance Prophet defeated Jimmy Rave to retain the NWA National Heavyweight title.
- June 9, 2007 – Gen-X Wrestling: Chance Prophet beat “The Driller” Eddie Browning to retain the NWA National title.
- June 16, 2007 – Gen-X Wrestling: NWA National Champion Chance Prophet vs. The Juggulator ended in a No Contest.
- July 6, 2007 – AWC: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Scottie Gash to retain the title.
- July 13, 2007 – Supreme Wrestling Alliance: Chance Prophet defeated Eric Darkstorm in Huntington, West Virginia.
- July 15, 2007 – Pro Wrestling Element: Chance Prophet defeated Steve Corino in a 2/3 Falls match for the National title.
- August 12, 2007 – NWA: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Chris Escobar to retain the title.
- August 25, 2007 – AWC: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Brandon K and Scottie Gash in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- April 5, 2008 – EPW: Chance Prophet defeated Dusty Dillinger.
- June 15, 2008 – NWA MSW: NWA Mountan State Wrestling Heavyweight The Maestro defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- August 3, 2008 – NWA MSW: NWA Mountain State TV champion The Spoiler defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- August 10, 2008 – NWA Mountain State: Billy Lit and Chance Prophet defeated Bruiser Graham and TR Superstar.
- October 4, 2008 – OCW: Chance Prophet defeated Sigmon by disqualification.
- November 15, 2008 – OCW: NWA All-Star champion Stan Lee defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- January 8, 2009 – MPW: MPW heavyweight champion Jon Moxley defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- March 7, 2009 – OCW: OCW tag team champions Shane Andrews and Sigmon defeated Chance Prophet and Kris Kannon to retain the titles.
- April 11, 2009 – OCW: OCW tag team champions Andy Douglas and Sigmon defeated Chance Prophet and Kris Kannon to retain the titles. Team Matthews (Chance Prophet, David Runyon, Johnny Punch, Kris Kannon and Shane Matthews) defeated Team Ace (Killer Kurt, Ryan Dookie, Scotty Ace, Sigmon and Stan Lee) in a tag team war games match.
- April 25, 2009 – NWA Charlotte: Derrick Driver and Steven Walters defeated Brandon Phoenix and Chance Prophet.
- May 9, 2009 – OCW: Chance Prophet defeated Daredevil and The Juggulator in a 3-way match.
- June 4, 2009 – OCW: Chance Prophet defeated The Juggulator.
- June 5, 2009 – OCW: The Juggulator defeated Chance Prophet.
- June 19, 2009 – MPW: Chance Prophet defeated Brian Beech, Kaden Assad, Matt Taylor and Tommy Chill in a gauntlet match to win the heavyweight title.
- July 31, 2009 – HWA: HWA American Luchacore champion Aaron Williams defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- October 10, 2009 – OCW: Ben Woods defeated Chance Prophet.
- October 29, 2009 – MPW: Kaden Assad defeated Chance Prophet and Eric Darkstorm in a 3-way match to win the heavyweight title.
- April 24, 2010 – NWA DAWG: Chance Prophet beat Ricky Reyes and Nick Gage and Nunzio (4-WAY) to win the NWA DAWG title.
- July 17, 2010 – NWA DAWG: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Sonjay Dutt to retain the title.
- August 1, 2010 – NWA Ohio State: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Corey Hollis to retain the title.
- August 8, 2010 – NWA Fanfest: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Caleb Konley to retain the title.
- September 4, 2010 – NWA Mountain State: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet vs. Frank Parker ended in a draw.
- September 11, 2010 – NWA Mountain State: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Jason Kincaid to retain the title.
- September 12, 2010 – NWA Vintage: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated JT Roberts, Problem Child and Tommy Force in a 4-way match to retain the title.
- September 24, 2010 – NWA: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Brandon Day to retain the title.
- October 2, 2010 – Remix Pro: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Flash Fury in a casket match to retain the title.
- October 23, 2010 – NWA Dawg Pound: Chance Prophet defeated Manu to retain the NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight title in Frankinville, New Jersey.
- November 19, 2010 – NWA Mountain State: NWA Mountain State Wrestling heavyweight champion The Maestro defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- December 11, 2010 – NWA Mountain State: NWA DAWG Pound heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Ricky Shane to retain the title.
- December 19, 2010 – NWA Mountain State: Chance Prophet vs. The Maestro ended in a no contest.
- January 15, 2011 – NWA Mountain State: Chance Prophet, Johnny Blast and The Maestro defeated Bryan Kyle, Derik Billings and Jason Kincaid.
- February 5, 2011 – WAR: Chance Prophet defeated Appollo Starr.
- February 19, 2011 – NWA Vintage: Chance Prophet defeated Phil Shatter to win the NWA National heavyweight title.
- April 1, 2011 – NWA Smokey Mountain: Chance Prophet defeated Nick Hammonds in the 1st round. Chase Owens defeated Alyx Winters, Chance Prophet, Jason Kincaid, Jeff Connelly and Menace in a 6-way elimination match to win the Smokey Mountain 2011 cup.
- April 2, 2011 – Remix Pro: Chance Prophet and TJ Phillips defeated Sam Hane and The Juggulator.
- May 14, 2011 – NWA: Damien Wayne defeated Chance Prophet to win the NWA DAWG heavyweight title.
- May 21, 2011 – NWA Premier: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet Onyx to retain the title.
- May 27, 2011 – NWA Coastal: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet Johnny Calzone in a dog collar tape fist match to retain the title.
- June 4, 2011 – WAR: WAR tag team champions Matt Mason and Robby Starr defeated Chance Prophet and Krimson by disqualification to retain the titles.
- July 9, 2011 – APWA: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet Jason Kincaid to retain the title.
- July 31, 2011 – NWA Ohio State: Adam Pearce defeated Chance Prophet, Jimmy Rave and Shaun Tempers in a 4-way match to win the NWA world heavyweight title.
- August 2, 2011 – NWA Bluegrass: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated NWA Bluegrass champion Al Snow by disqualification in a title vs. title match. Both champions retained their titles.
- August 6, 2011 – NWA Premier: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet Damien Wayne by disqualification to retain the title.
- August 20, 2011 – WAR: Joey V. and Mikey D. defeated Chance Prophet and Krimson. Appollo Starr, Brian Beech and Cody Hawk defeated Chance Prophet, Krimson and Gutter.
- September 10, 2011 – APWA: Chance Prophet and TJ Philllips vs. Toby Klein and Viper ended in a no contest.
- September 24, 2011 – APWA: Bildo and Cletus Cassidy defeated TJ Phillips and Chance Prophet.
- October 7, 2011 – NWA Revival: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet Damien Wayne in a Queen City street fight to retain the title.
- October 8, 2011 – Remix Pro: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Tommy Dreamer to retain the title.
- November 19, 2011 – NWA Premier: Psycho defeated Chance Prophet by disqualification.
- December 3, 2011 – APWA: Chance Prophet defeated Sherman Tank in the 1st round.
- December 14, 2011 – NWA Ring Warriors: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet vs. Kahagas ended in a double disqualification to retain the title.
- December 16, 2011 – APWA: Chance Prophet defeated Zac Vincent in the semi-finals.
- December 17, 2011 – APWA: Christian York defeated Chance Prophet and Jesse Sorensen in a 3-way match to become #1 contender for the heavyweight title.
- January 14, 2012 – APWA: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet Christian York to retain the title.
- January 18, 2012 – NWA Ring Warriors: NWA National heavyweight champion Chance Prophet vs. Kahagas ended in a double disqualification to retain the title.
- February 25, 2012 – APWA: Chance Prophet, Joey Vengeance, Onyx and Sherman Tank defeated Bobby Shields, Chase Stevens, Jock Samson and Matt Conard.
- March 3, 2012 – IWA East Coast: Chance Prophet and The Juggulator defeated TJ Phillips and Trik Nasty to win the tag team titles.
- March 29, 2012 – NWA Ring Warriors: Kahagas defeated Chance Prophet to win the National heavyweight title.
- April 6, 2012 – NWA Mountain State: Eric Darkstrom defeated Chance Prophet.
- April 7, 2012 – Remix Pro: Chance Prophet defeated Colt Cabana.
- April 27, 2012 – Clash of the Champions: IWA East Coast tag team champions Chance Prophet and The Juggulator defeated Sheepherder Luke and Viper to retain the titles.
- May 4, 2012 – IWA East Coast: IWA East Coast tag team champions Chance Prophet and The Juggulator defeated Facade and Jason Gory to retain the titles.
- May 18, 2012 – NWA Premier: Chance Prophet defeated Adam Pearce.
- May 30, 2012 – NWA Ring Warriors: Chance Prophet defeated The Giant Titan to win the vacant ring warriors Bahamian heavyweight title.
- June 2, 2012 – APWA: APWA heavyweight champion Onyx defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- June 30, 2012 – NWA Premier: NWA Premier heavyweight champion Onyx defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- July 7, 2012 – NWA Bluegrass: Chance Prophet defeated Davey Richards by disqualification.
- July 28, 2012 – APWA: Team Ring Ka King (Jason Wayne, Luke Gallows, Michael Elgin, Sonjay Dutt and The Conganese Nightmare) defeated Team APWA (Chance Prophet, Crimson, Gunner, ONYX and Viper).
- August 5, 2012 – Remix Pro: Chance Prophet defeated Facade to win the heavyweight title.
- August 11, 2012 – APWA: Team APWA (Crimson, ONYX and Viper) defeated Team Ring Ka King (Chance Prophet, Luke Gallows and Wes Fetty) in a tag team elimination match.
- August 18, 2012 – IWA East Coast: Jake and Dave Crist defeated Chance Prophet and The Juggulator to win the tag team titles.
- September 8, 2012 – NWA Ring Warriors: NWA Ring Warriors Grand champion Bruce Santee defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- September 29, 2012 – NWA Ring Warriors: NWA Ring Warriors Bahamian champion Chance Prophet defeated The Beast to retain the title.
- October 6, 2012 – Remix Pro: Remix Pro heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Facade to retain the title.
- October 27, 2012 – IWA East Coast: Goldust defeated Chance Prophet.
- November 2, 2012 – NWA DAWG: Kahagas defeated Anthony Nese, Biggie Biggs, Chance Prophet, Damien Wayne, Jason Kincaid, Lance Anoai, Lance Erikson and Papadon in a 9-way elimination to win the vacant world heavyweight title.
- December 1, 2012 – VOW: Ashton Amherst defeated Chance Prophet.
- January 5, 2013 – NWA Edge: Damien Wayne defeated Chance Prophet and Lance Erikson in a 3-way match to win the NWA National heavyweight title.
- March 8, 2013 – IWA East Coast: Chance Prophet vs. Mad Man Pondo ended in a double disqualification.
- April 26, 2013 – NWA Mid-Atlantic: Chance Prophet vs. Lance Erikson ended in a no contest.
- April 27, 2013 – Remix Pro: Facade and The Hurricane defeated Chance Prophet and Gory.
- May 4, 2013 – PWF: PWF heavyweight champion Kyle Matthews defeated Chance Prophet to retain the title.
- June 1, 2013 – Remix Pro: Bryan Cross, Gory and Matt Conard defeated Chance Prophet, Rocky Reynolds and Trik Nasty.
- July 7, 2013 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Ryan Mitchell.
- July 26, 2013 – HWA: Chance Prophet defeated Ron Mathis to win the heavyweight title.
- August 11, 2013 – Ring Warriors TV: Chance Prophet defeated Edward Malken.
- August 23, 2013 – D1W: Shane Mercer defeated Chance Prophet.
- September 29, 2013 – Ring Warriors TV: Alex Chamberlain defeated Chance Prophet to win the Bahamian title.
- October 5, 2013 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Aiden Veil.
- October 12, 2013 – Remix Pro: Remix Pro heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Gangrel to retain the title.
- October 20, 2013 – HWA: HWA heavyweight champion Chance Prophet vs. OVW heavyweight champion Jamin Olivencia in a title vs. title match ended in a no contest. Both champions retained their titles.
- November 30, 2013 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Jimmy Nutts to win the heavyweight title.
- January 17, 2014 – HWA: HWA heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Chris Carnage to retain the title.
- February 1, 2014 – VOW: VOW heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Jimmy Nutts to retain the title.
- February 8, 2014 – Remix Pro: Remix Pro heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Bryan Cross to retain the title.
- March 15, 2014 – IWA East Coast: Remix Pro heavyweight champion Chance Prophet vs. Jason Gory ended in a double disqualification.
- March 29, 2014 – D1W: Ron Mathis defeated Chance Prophet.
- April 5, 2014 – VOW: Jessie Kaye and Jimmy Nutts defeated VOW heavyweight champion Chance Prophet and VOW women’s champion Samantha Starr to the titles.
- April 26, 2014 – Remix Pro: Remix Pro heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Adam Pearce and Michael Elgin in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- April 27, 2014 – HWA: HWA heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Appollo Starr and Dru Skillz in a 3-way match by count-out to retain the title.
- June 7, 2014 – VOW: VOW heavyweight champion Jimmy Nutts defeated Chance Prophet in a kendo sticks match to retain the title.
- July 5, 2014 – HWA: Dustin Rayz defeated Chance Prophet to win the HWA heavyweight title.
- August 2, 2014 – VOW: Ryan Reign defeated Chance Prophet, David Starr and Napalm Bomb in a 4-way match.
- October 4, 2014 – VOW: Matt Justice defeated Chance Prophet.
- October 11, 2014 – Remix Pro: Remix Pro heavyweight champion Chance Prophet defeated Monstrous BC to retain the title.
- November 2, 2014 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Ganon Jones Jr. by count-out.
- December 5, 2014 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Matthew Jusitce.
- January 10, 2015 – VOW: Jimmy Nutts defeated Chance Prophet, Ganon Jones Jr. and Matthew Justice in a 4-way TLC match to win the vacant heavyweight title.
- April 4, 2015 – VOW: Facade defeated Chance Prophet.
- April 10, 2015 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Facade.
- April 25, 2015 – Remix Pro: The Headless Horsemen (Gory, Matt Conard & Ron Mathis) defeated Chance Prophet & The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson) in a no count-out, no disqualification match.
- June 28, 2015 – AML: Chance Prophet vs. Damien Wayne ended in a time limit draw.
- July 12, 2015 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Facade by disqualification. Facade retains the Hyper Sonic title.
- July 26, 2015 – AML: Chance Prophet defeated Damien Wayne in a submission match.
- August 15, 2015 – VOW: Chance Prophet defeated Patrick Hayes.
- August 29, 2015 – AML: Gunner defeated Chance Prophet in a street fight.
- August 30, 2015 – AML: Damien Wayne defeated Chance Prophet in a bar room brawl.
- September 5, 2015 – VOW: Facade defeated Chance Prophet to retain the Hyper Sonic title.
- October 2, 2015 – TNA Live Event: Chance Prophet defeated Shawn Schultz.
- October 17, 2015 – Remix Pro: Ron Mathis defeated Chance Prophet to retain the Remix Pro heavyweight title and to win the Remix Pro RIOT title.
- April 9, 2016 – Remix Pro: The Anti-Heroes (Chance Prophet, Cole Cash, TJ Phillips and Vance Desmond) defeated The Headless Horsemen (Gory, Matt Conard, Ron Mathis and Takoda Moon).
- April 16, 2016 – IWA East Coast: Chance Prophet defeated BJ Whitmer and Ron Mathis in a 3-way match to win the heavyweight title.
- May 21, 2016 – UCW: Chance Prophet, Gangrel and Krimson defeated Caleb Stills, Danny Shay and Idris Abraham.
- August 27, 2016 – AML: Jordan Kage defeated Brandon Scott, Caprice Coleman and Chance Prophet in a 4-way, semi-finals match.
- September 24, 2016 – AML: Caleb Konley defeated Chance Prophet.
- October 1, 2016 – Remix Pro: Chance Prophet defeated Ron Mathis in a casket match to win the heavyweight title.
- April 22, 2017 – Remix Pro: Chase Stevens defeated Chance Prophet to win the heavyweight title.
- April 29, 2017 – FTC: James Storm defeated Chance Prophet.
- September 2, 2017 – FTC: Chase Armstrong defeated Chance Prophet in a stretcher match.
- September 16, 2017 – Remix Pro: Matt Conard defeated Chance Prophet.
- October 28, 2017 – FTC: Chance Prophet and Shane Douglas defeated Casey King and Shark Boy.
- April 21, 2018 – Remix Pro: Matt Conard defeated Chance Prophet in a casket match.
- July 7, 2018 – IPW: Bad Bad Banks defeated Chance Prophet and Kris James in a 3-way match to win the vacant Delaware title.
- September 15, 2018 – Remix Pro: Chance Prophet and Glacier defeated The Curse (Matt Conard and Onyx).