Title History
- FTW tag team titles w Jim Sullivan defeating Maifu and Saifu (April 15, 2012);
- ISW tag team titles w Dan Barry defeating Bastian Snow and Pasquale The Italian Chef (October 25, 2014);
- NYWC tag team titles w Dan Barry defeating Randy Summers and Brandon Watts (December 27, 2014);
- ISW tag team titles w Dan Barry winning a 4-way tag match (March 28, 2015);
- CZW tag team titles w Dan Barry winning a 4-way tag match (July 11, 2015);
- PWR tag team titles w Dan Barry winning a tag team gauntlet match (April 6, 2019);
- ROH World 6 man tag team titles w Bateman & Vincent defeating Kaun, Moses and O’Shay Edwards (December 11, 2021);
Career Highlights
Northeast based independent wrestler / NYWC:
- May 29, 2010–FTW Pro Wrestling: Jim Sullivan defeated Bill Carr in Ronkonkoma, New York..
Florida Championship Wrestling:
- 2010: Bill Carr signed a developmental contract with World Wrestling Entertainment..
- July 1, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Wes Brisco defeated Bill Carr in a dark match.
- July 29, 2010–FCW: Titus O’Neill & Rudy Parker defeated Rhys Ali & Bill Carr in a dark match.
- July 29, 2010–FCW: Lucky Cannon & Devin Allen & Bill Carr defeated Eli Cottonwood & Jinder Mahal & Jackson Andrews.
- August 5, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Eli Cottonwood defeated Bill Carr.
Florida Championship Wrestling – Bobby Dutch:
- August 18, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Bobby Dutch & Rudy Parker defeated Dr. Cable Jones & Jinder Mahal.
- August 19, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Aksana & Bobby Dutch defeated Rudy Parker & AJ Lee when Dutch pinned Parker.
- September 2, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Eli Cottonwood & Jackson Andrews defeated Xavier Woods & Bobby Dutch.
- September 9, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Bobby Dutch & Xavier Woods defeated Rhys Ali & Devin Allen.
- September 15, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Xavier Woods & Bobby Dutch defeated Jacob Novak & Jinder Mahal.
- September 15, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Jackson Andrews & Brodus Clay & Eli Cottonwood & Shad Gaspard defeated Big E. Langston & Titus O’Neil & Xavier Woods & Bobby Dutch.
- September 21, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Bobby Dutch & Conrad Tanner & Titus O’Neil & James Bronson defeated Ron Myers & Kenny Li & Cable Jones & Buck Dixon in Tampa, Florida..
- September 23, 2010–FCW: Big E Langston & Conrad Tanner & Bobby Dutch defeated Roman Leakee & Fahd Rakman & Cable Jones.
- November 11, 2010–FCW: Damien Sandow defeated Bobby Dutch & Big E Langston & Marcus Owens & Roman Leakee in a Rumble.
- December 2, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Donny Marlow defeated Bobby Dutch.
- December 17, 2010–Florida Championship Wrestling: Seth Rollins defeated Bobby Dutch.
- January 6, 2011–Florida Championship Wrestling: Xavier Woods defeated Bobby Dutch.
- January 30, 2011 – FCW: Johnny Curtis, Percy Watson & Tito Colon defeated Bobby Dutch, Byron Saxton & Conor O’Brian.
- February 20, 2011 – FCW: Seth Rollins defeated Bobby Dutch.
- March 20, 2011 – FCW: Richie Steamboat defeated Bobby Dutch.
- May 1, 2011 – FCW TV: Bo Rotundo defeated Bobby Dutch.
- May 15, 2011 – FCW: Bo Rotundo defeated Bobby Dutch and Brett DiBiase and Jacob Novak and Jinder Mahal and Lucky Cannon in a Gauntlet match.
- May 22, 2011 – FCW TV: Leakee defeated Bobby Dutch.
- June 12, 2011 – FCW TV: Percy Watson defeated Bobby Dutch.
- August 5, 2011 – Bobby Dutch was released from WWE.
2011-2013:
- December 3, 2011–FTW: Jim Sullivan, Maifu and Saifu defeated Bill Carr, Kurt Varis and Thorson Creed.
- December 10, 2011–ACW: Bill Carr defeated Tony Fatu.
- January 7, 2012–ACE: Bill Carr defeated Nathan Banner.
- January 27, 2012–FTW: Bill Carr and Ken Scampi defeated Frankie Starz and Juggalo Myers & Jim Sullivan and Lenn Oddity in a 3-way tag team match.
- January 28, 2012–FTW: Jim Sullivan defeated Bill Carr and DJ Hyde in a 3-way match.
- February 18, 2012–Beyond Wrestling: Bill Carr defeated Mark Shurman by disqualification.
- February 19, 2012–Beyond Wrestling: Sugar Dunkerton and Taka Suzuki defeated Bill Carr and Ken Scampi.
- February 25, 2012–ACE: Jack Gallow defeated Bill Carr.
- March 9, 2012–PWS: The Big O defeated Bill Carr, Justin Corino and Nick Brubaker in a dark gauntlet.
- March 10, 2012–ACE: Bill Carr defeated Chris Raze, Giovanni Marranca, Josh Starks, Rob Fury, Thomas Rodriguez and William Wyeth in a 7-way match.
- March 16, 2012–FTW: FTW heavyweight champion Jay Lover vs. Bill Carr ended in a no contest to retain the title.
- March 17, 2012–FTW: FTW heavyweight champion Jay Lover defeated Bill Carr, Dan Barry, Jim Sullivan and Juggalo Myers in a 5-way to retain the title.
- April 15, 2012–FTW: Bill Carr and Jim Sullivan defeated Maifu and Saifu to win the tag team titles.
- May 5, 2012–ACE: Bill Carr defeated William Wyeth.
- May 12, 2012–ACE: Dan Maff, Jack Gallow and William Wyeth defeated Bill Carr, Smith James and Vince Steele.
- June 1, 2012–NEW: Bill Carr defeated Jay Freddie.
- June 2, 2012–NEW: Bill Carr and QT Marshall defeated Nocturne and Hale Collins.
- June 9, 2012–SCW: Danny Demanto, Dave Greco and Justin Corino defeated Bill Carr, Judas Young and Mo Sexton.
- July 7, 2012–FTW: FTW tag team champions Bill Carr and Jim Sullivan defeated Jimmy Cash and Ken Scampi to retain the titles.
- July 27, 2012–Beyond Wrestling: Johnny Cockstrong, Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Ken Scampi defeated RD Evans, Evan Gelistico, Gary Jay and Pierre Abernathy.
- August 18, 2012–ACE: William Wyeth defeated Bill Carr.
- September 15, 2012–FTW: FTW tag team champions Bill Carr and Jim Sullivan defeated Demolition (Ax and Smash) & Jimmy Cash and Kurt Varis & Ken Scampi and Nightmare in a 4-way tag match to retain the titles.
- September 22, 2012–NEW: Bill Carr and Jim Duggan defeated Jake Manning and Mr. TA.
- October 13, 2012–Beyond Wrestling: Bill Carr, Dan Barry, Ken Scampi) and Tim Hughes defeated JT Dunn, Leon St. Giovanni, Mark Shurman and Max St. Giovanni in a tag team elimination match.
- October 20, 2012–NYWC: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Braydon Knight and JT Kasin.
- November 17, 2012–NYWC: Bill Carr and Smith James defeated DJ Phat Pat and Francis Kipland Stevens, Mike Donovan and Rob Vegas & Braydon Knight and JT Kasin in a 4-way tag team match.
- December 8, 2012–NYWC: Bill Carr and Smith James defeated AC Anderson and CJ Antonino.
- January 18, 2013–NWA LSW: Bill Carr vs. Afa Jr. ended in a no contest. Afa Jr. and Shane Helms defeated Bill Carr and Smith James.
- January 19, 2013–NYWC: Bill Carr and Smith James defeated Nikki Addams and Steve Forge. Bill Carr and Smith James defeated Braydon Knight and JT Kasin.
- February 8, 2013–AIW: Bill Carr, Doc Colonel and Jock Samson defeated Evan Gelistico, Gary Jay and Pierre Abernathy.
- February 23, 2013–NYWC: Bill Carr and Smith James defeated DJ Phat Pat and Francis Kipland Stevens & Braydon Knight and JT Kasin in a 3-way tag match to become #1 contender for the tag titles. Bill Carr and Smith James defeated Alex Reynolds and John Silver to win the tag team titles.
- March 9, 2013–CTWE: William King and Zachary Pierre Beaulieu defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- March 16, 2013–ISW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Leon St. Giovanni and Mighty Mo.
- March 23, 2013–NWA LSW: Apolo defeated Bill Carr.
- April 13, 2013–ACE: Andrew Johnson defeated Bill Carr.
- April 27, 2013–NYWC: Tag team champions Bill Carr and Smith James defeated Mikey Whipwreck and Stockade by disqualification to retain the titles.
- May 18, 2013–NYWC: Mikey Whipwreck and Stockade defeated tag team champions Bill Carr and Smith James by disqualification.
- June 14, 2013–Beyond Wrestling: Aaron Epic and Sugar Dunkerton defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- June 15, 2013–NYWC: Mikey Whipwreck and Stockade defeated Bill Carr and Smith James to win the tag team titles.
- June 22, 2013–CTWE: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Anthony Battle and The Mac.
- July 13, 2013–NYWC: Bill Carr defeated Nickie Valentino.
- July 21, 2013–Beyond Wrestling: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Angel Ortiz and Mike Draztik, Davey Cash and Kris Pyro & Tommy Trainwreck and Devin Blaze in a 4-way tag match.
- August 25, 2013–CTWE: CTWE tag team champions Mark Shurman and Scotty Slade defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry, Anthony Battle and The Mac & William King and Zachary Pierre Beaulieu in a 4-way tag match to retain the titles.
- October 19, 2013–NYWC: Apollyon and Bill Carr defeated Alvin Alvarez and Mega.
- October 19, 2013–HOH III: Bill Carr was in a hardcore rules battle royal won by Vik Dalishus.
- November 16, 2013–ISW: Kitsune and Shynron defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry in the 1st round.
- November 17, 2013–Beyond Wrestling: Bill Carr and Dan Barry won the tag team gauntlet.
- December 21, 2013–NYWC: Apollyon and Bill Carr defeated Brandon Watts and Randy Summers.
2014:
- January 11, 2014–CZW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Brandon Watts and Randy Summers in a dark match.
- February 15, 2014–NYWC: Dickie Rodz and Nikki Starr defeated Bill Carr and Apollyon by count-out to become #1 contenders for the tag titles.
- February 16, 2014–Beyond Wrestling: CZW tag team champions Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain.
- March 23, 2014–Beyond Wrestling: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Bobby Fish and Kyle O’Reilly.
- April 19, 2014–ISW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Mathieu St-Jacques and Thomas Dubois.
- April 26, 2014–NYWC: Brandon Watts and Randy Summers defeated Bill Carr and Apollyon.
- April 27, 2014–CZW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Sozio and Stockade.
- May 3, 2014–C4: C4 tag team champions Mathieu St-Jacques and Thomas Dubois defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
- May 9, 2014–WSU: Candice LeRae and Joey Ryan defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- May 18, 2014–Beyond Wrestling Unbreakable: The Young Bucks and Kevin Steen defeated Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Biff Busick.
- June 7, 2014–HOH V: Joe Caldo, Hurricane Helms and Gangrel defeated Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Vik Dalishus.
- June 22, 2014–Beyond Wrestling Uncomfortable: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Colt Cabana and Dick Justice.
- June 28, 2014–NYWC: Brandon Watts and Randy Summers defeated Team Elite, Bill Carr and Dan Barry and Braydon Knight and JT Kasin in a 4-way tag team match to become #1 contenders for the tag titles.
- July 12, 2014–CZW: CZW tag team champions David Starr and JT Dunn defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry, Alex Reynolds and John Silver & Dave and Jake Crist in a 4-way tag team match to retain the tag titles.
- July 24, 2014–NYWC: Blake Morris and DJ Hyde defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- July 27, 2014–Beyond Americanrana: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Trent and Chuck Taylor.
- August 21, 2014–NYWC: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Mike Justice and Jesse Vane.
- August 23, 2014–IWS: Mathieu St.Jacques and Thomas Dubois defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- August 31, 2014–Beyond Battle of New England: Chris Dickinson and Jaka defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- September 13, 2014–CZW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Buxx Belmar and Mike Bailey.
- September 27, 2014–NYWC: Apollyon and Stockade defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- October 18, 2014–CZW: CZW tag team champions Jake and Dave Crist defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
- October 25, 2014–ISW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Bastian Snow and Pasquale The Italian Chef to win the tag team titles.
- November 1, 2014–CZW: Randy Summers and Brandon Watts defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- November 14, 2014–FBW: Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry, Blake Morris and Rex Lawless & The Spirit Squad (Kenny and Mikey) in a 4-way semi-finals elimination tag team match.
- November 15, 2014–HOH VII: Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Little Guido defeated Anthony Greene, Ben Ortiz and Vik Dalishus.
- November 21, 2014–XWA: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Donovan Dijack and Hanson.
- November 30, 2014–Beyond Tournament for Tomorrow: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Chuck Taylor and Orange Cassidy in the 1st round. Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated David Starr and JT Dunn in the semi-finals. Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated The Young Bucks to win the Tournament for Tomorrow.
- December 13, 2014–CZW: Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- December 27, 2014–NYWC: Bill Carr and Dan Barry vs. JT Dunn and David Starr ended in a no contest. Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Brandon Watts and Randy Summers to win the tag team titles.
- December 28, 2014–Beyond Ends Meet: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Kris Pyro and Davey Cash.
2015:
- January 10, 2015–CZW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Alex Reynolds and John Silver by disqualification.
- January 17, 2015–XWA: Bill Carr was in a 30 man royal rumble match.
- January 31, 2015–NYWC: NYWC tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Randy Summer and Brandon Watts to retain the titles.
- February 7, 2015–BTW: Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Tyrus defeated Hale Collins, Vik Dalishus and Val Venis.
- February 21, 2015–CZW: Chuck Taylor, John Silver and Rex Lawless defeated Dick Justice, Bill Carr and Dan Barry in a tag team elimination match.
- February 28, 2015–NYWC: Brandon Watts and Randy Summers defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry, David Starr and JT Dunn & Tony Mamaluke and Little Guido in a 4-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- February 28, 2015–IWS: IWS tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Kitsune and Shynron to retain the titles.
- March 1, 2015–Beyond King of Arts: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Drew Gulak and Biff Busick.
- March 7, 2015–HOH VIII: Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Tony Nese defeated Ben Ortiz, Hale Collins and Vik Dalishus.
- March 8, 2015–EVOLVE 38: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Earl Cooter and Jody Kristofferson.
- March 14, 2015–CZW: Buxx Belmar defeated Bill Carr.
- March 27, 2015–Hoodslam: Rick Scott Stoner and Scott Rick Stoner defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to win the tag team titles.
- March 28, 2015–Hoodslam: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Rick Scott Stoner and Scott Rick Stoner, Manimal and Modern-Day Manimal & Brittany Wonder and The Cereal Man in a 4-way to win the tag team titles.
- April 19, 2015–2CW: Davey Richards and Roderick Strong defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- April 26, 2015–Beyond When Satan Ruled His World: Hanson and Ray Rowe defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- May 1, 2015–ICW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Randy Summers and Brandon Watts.
- May 9, 2015–CZW: Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Bill Carr and Buxx Belmar.
- May 22, 2015–PWG: Alex Reynolds and John Silver defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry in the 1st round.
- May 30, 2015–XWA: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Logan Black and Riley.
- May 31, 2015–Beyond The Real Thing: Chris Hero and JT Dunn defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- June 26, 2015–ICW: Matt Taven and Michael Bennett defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry & Brandon Watts and Randy Summers in a 3-way tag team match.
- June 27, 2015–ICW: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated EYFBO (Angel Ortiz and Mike Draztik).
- June 28, 2015–Beyond Life Sucks & The You Die: The Kingdom (Matt Taven and Michael Bennett) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- July 11, 2015–CZW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Dave and Jake Crist, The Young Bucks and Alex Reynolds and John Silver in a 4-way to win the tag titles.
- July 18, 2015–HOH IX: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry), Matt Striker & Scotty O’Shea defeated Ben Ortiz, Ethan Page, RJ City & Vik Dalishus.
- July 24, 2015–PWG: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The World’s Cutest Tag Team (Candice LeRae and Joey Ryan).
- September 20, 2015–XWA: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Team Friendship (Mark Shurman and Scotty Slade).
- September 25, 2015–FBW: Brandon Watts and Randy Summers defeated Blake Morris and Rex Lawless, Bill Carr and Dan Barry & Dave McCall and Nate Carter in a 4-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- September 26, 2015–Beyond Greatest Rivals Round Robin: Team Fuck Da Police (Andrew Everett and Trevor Lee) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- September 27, 2015–Beyond Powder Keg: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Minute Men (Devin Blaze and Tommy Trainwreck).
- October 10, 2015–CZW: CZW tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Alex Reynolds and John Silver to retain the titles.
- October 17, 2015–IWS vs CZW: CZW tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Mathieu St-Jacques and Thomas Dubois to retain the titles.
- October 25, 2015–Beyond Gratitude Era: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Crusade For Change (Darius Carter and TJ Marconi).
- October 31, 2015–ISW: ISW tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Angel Ortiz and Mike Draztik to retain the titles.
- November 1, 2015–XWA: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Matt Cross and Shane Strickland.
- November 6, 2015–AAW: AAW tag team champions Devin and Mason Cutter defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
- November 7, 2015–DREAMWAVE: DREAMWAVE tag team champions Matt Cage and Christian Rose defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
- November 13, 2015–HOH X: Colt Cabana, Bill Carr, Dan Barry, Little Guido and Tony Mamaluke defeated Afa Jr., Jade, Lance Anoai, LA Smooth & Vik Dalishus.
- November 14, 2015–HOH IX: Colt Cabana, Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Yusuke Kodama defeated Ben Ortiz, Eddie Kingston, Hale Collins and Vik Dalishus.
- November 20, 2015–NLW: Bill Carr, Dan Barry and Juba defeated Jeremy Leary, Logan Black and Rude Boy Riley.
- November 21, 2015–CZW: CZW tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Devin and Mason Cutter to retain the titles.
- November 21, 2015–CZW/WSU: CZW tag team champions Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Jade and Marti Belle to retain the titles.
- November 28, 2015–Beyond Tournament For Tomorrow 4: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Throwbacks (Dasher Hatfield and Mark Angelosetti).
- November 29, 2015–Beyond Tournament For Tomorrow 4: The Crusade For Change (Darius Carter, Devin Blaze, TJ Marconi & Tommy Trainwreck) defeats Dick Justice, Officer Colt Cabana & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry).
- December 5, 2015–DREAMWAVE: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Roppongi Vice (Beretta and Rocky Romero).
- December 18, 2015–FBW: FBW tag team champions Blake Morris and Rex Lawless defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
2016:
- January 22, 2016–EVOLVE 53: Roppongi Vice (Beretta and Rocky Romero) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) in the 1st round.
- January 23, 2016–EVOLVE 54: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Premier Athlete Brand (Anthony Nese and Caleb Konley) in the 1st round.
- January 24, 2016–EVOLVE 55: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Drew Gulak and TJ Perkins, Roppongi Vice (Beretta and Rocky Romero) and The Bravado Brothers in a 4-way 2nd chance, tag team elimination match to win the tournament and to become #1 contenders for the tag team titles.
- February 28, 2016–Beyond State of the Art: Da Hit Squad (Dan Maff and Monsta Mack) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- March 5, 2016–WrestlePro: WrestlePro tag team champions Craig Steele and Sandy Mann defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
- March 19, 2016–EVOLVE 56: Anthony Nese and Caleb Konley defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry.
- March 20, 2016–EVOLVE 57: EVOLVE tag team champions Drew Galloway and Johnny Gargano defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry to retain the titles.
- April 15, 2016–HOH XII: The Golden Boy, Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Ben Ortiz, Hale Collins and Vik Dalishus.
- April 16, 2016–HOH XIII: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Ben Ortiz and Eddie Kingston.
- June 10, 2016–FTW: Bill Carr and Dan Barry defeated Caleb Konley and Zane Riley.
- June 17, 2016–Beyond/HOG: Josh Glide and TJ Marconi defeated Bill Carr and Dan Barry, Chris Seaton and Smoothe Blackmon & Caveman and Mantequilla in a 4-way tag team match.
- July 28, 2016–NYWC: The Hounds Of Hatred (Bam Sullivan and Boo Sullivan) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- August 19, 2016–AAW: Andrew Everett and Trevor Lee defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- September 2, 2016-CHIKARA: The United Nations (Juan Francisco de Coronado, Prakash Sabar and Proletariat Boar Of Moldova) defeated Team Police Squad (Bill Carr, Dick Justice and Officer Warren Barksdale) in the 1st round of the King Of Trios tournament.
- September 16, 2016–HOH XVII: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) and Connor Braxton defeated CJ Mirror, TJ Marconi and Vik Dalishus.
- September 17, 2016–HOH XVIII: Eddie Kingston, TJ Marconi and Vik Dalishus defeated Connor Braxton & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- October 14, 2016–HOH XIX: Swoggle & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Matt Justice & The NOW (Hale Collins and Vik Dalishus).
- December 29, 2016–Beyond Party Animals: Chuck O’Neil and Matthew Riddle defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
2017-2018:
- April 1, 2017–Beyond Caffeine: Team Pazuzu (Angel Ortiz, Chris Dickinson, Jaka and Mike Draztik) defeated Chuck Taylor, Orange Cassidy & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- May 19, 2017–HOH 26: The Spirit Squad (Kenny and Mikey) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) & NOW (Hale Collins and Vik Dalishus) in a 3-way tag team match.
- May 25, 2017–AAW: Alex Daniels and Davey Vega defeated Stephen Wolf and Trey Miguel & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) in a 3-way tag tea match.
- May 26, 2017–NEW: Bill Carr defeated Brad Hollister.
- August 11, 2017–HOH 32: The Spirit Squad (Kenny and Mikey) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- August 24, 2017–NYWC: Bill Carr and Bull James defeated Alex Reynolds and Blake Morris.
- August 31, 2017–AAW: ACH & The Besties In The World (Davey Vega and Mat Fitchett) defeated Colt Cabana & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- December 8, 2017–H20: Bill Carr defeated Brute Van Slyke, Greg Excellent and Rex Lawless in a 4-way, 1st round match. Bill Carr defeated Bull James & Kyle The Beast and Stockade in a 4-way elimination match to win the 305 Hoss tournament.
- January 18, 2018–Bar Wrestling 8: The Killer Baes (Heather Monroe & Laura James) and Brody King defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) and Taya Valkyrie.
- January 27, 2018–Beyond Spirit Of 76: The Amityville Project (Dan Barry, Rex Lawless and Ryan Galeone) defeated Bill Carr, Brian Cage and Kyle The Beast.
- February 24, 2018–JAPW: Da Hit Squad (Dan Maff and Monsta Mack) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- February 24, 2018–Beyond I Want It All: Orange Cassidy defeated Bill Carr.
- April 29, 2018–Beyond Welcome Home: Shockwave The Robot defeated Bill Carr.
- May 26, 2018–Beyond Solid Gold: Bill Carr defeated Ryan Galeone.
- June 24, 2018–Beyond Vitality: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Mike Verna and Rex Lawless.
- July 29, 2018–Beyond Americanrana: The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated Massage Force (Dorian Graves and VSK), Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) & The Gentleman’s Club (Chuck Taylor and Orange Cassidy) in a 4-way tag team match.
- September 14, 2018–Xcite/Impact Wrestling One Night Only: Night Of The Dummies (Taped): Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Heavenly Bodies (Desirable Dustin and Gigolo Justin).
- September 14, 2018–NEW: Bill Carr defeated Dylan Bostic.
- September 16, 2018–Beyond Somebody’s Farewell, Probably: Bill Carr defeated Jay Freddie.
- September 20, 2018–NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Bill Carr defeated Orange Cassidy.
- October 21, 2018–Wild Zero: False Flag (Cloudy and Krist Worthless) defeated Killer Instinct (Jacoby Riddick and Mike Skyros) & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) in a 3-way tag team match.
- November 26, 2018–PROGRESS Chapter 79: The Anti-Fun Police (Chief Deputy Dunne and Los Federales Santos Jr.) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- December 6, 2018–NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling/KBB: Bill Carr and Orange Cassidy defeated Mike Verna and Rex Lawless.
- December 15, 2018–Blackcraft: Team Pazuzu (Chris Dickinson and Pinkie Sanchez) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry), Ultra-Violence Unlimited (Rickey Shane Page and Tyler Bateman) & Cortez Castro and Sam Adonis in a 4-way tag team match.
- February 21, 2019–NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Bill Carr, Orange Cassidy and Swoggle defeated Alex Reynolds, Matt Striker and Rick Cataldo.
- April 3, 2019–WrestlePro: Allie and Rosemary defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- April 4, 2019–ISW: Gym Nasty Boyz (Timmy Lou Retton and White Mike) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- April 5, 2019–WrestleCon Joey Ryan’s Penis Party: Bill Carr defeated Dan Barry.
- April 6, 2019–REVOLVER: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) defeated The Rascalz (Dezmond Xavier & Zachary Wentz) and Lucha Brothers (Fenix & Pentagon Jr.) and Aussie Open (Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis) and The Besties In The World (Davey Vega & Mat Fitchett) and Latin American Exchange (Ortiz & Santana) in a tag team gauntlet match to win the PWR tag team titles.
- May 10, 2019–REVOLVER: The Besties In The World (Davey Vega and Mat Fitchett) defeated Arik Cannon and Jimmy Jacobs, oVe (Jake Crist and Madman Fulton) & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) in a 4-way tag team match to win the PWR tag team titles.
- May 11, 2019–AAW: The Lucha Brothers (Penta El Zero M and Rey Fenix) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- June 19, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #1.12: Bear Country (Bear Beefcake and Bear Bronson) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- September 13, 2019–NEW: Caz XL and Wrecking Ball Legursky defeated Bill Carr and Bull James.
- September 22, 2019–Beyond All Hands On Deck: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Bear Country (Bear Beefcake and Bear Bronson) in a tornado rules match.
- October 12, 2019–Beyond Sodom And Gomorrah: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Butcher And The Blade (Andy Williams and Pepper Parks).
- October 19, 2019–ISW: Gym Nasty Boyz (Timmy Lou Retton and White Mike) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) to retain the tag team titles.
- October 24, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.04: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Bear Country (Bear Beefcake and Bear Bronson), The Butcher And The Blade (Andy Williams and Pepper Parks) & Violence Is Forever (Dominic Garrini and Kevin Ku) in a 4-way tag team match.
- October 31, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.05: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale).
- November 21, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.08: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- December 14, 2019–TID: The North (Ethan Page and Josh Alexander) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry), The Shooting Gallery (Brandon Thurston and Daniel Garcia) & The Space Pirates (Shane Sabre and Space Monkey) in a 4-way tag team match.
- December 31, 2019–Beyond Heavy Lies The Crown: Bear Country (Bear Boulder and Bear Bronson) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) in a anything goes match.
2020-2022:
- February 1, 2020–Xcite: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Dying Breed (Axel Lennox and Robert Cook) by disqualification. The Dying Breed retains the tag team titles.
- February 20, 2020–NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: The Ascension (Konnor and Viktor) defeated Bill Carr and Bull James.
- March 7, 2020–Xcite: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) and Sean Carr defeated The Dying Breed (Axel Lennox & Robert Cook) and HC Loc.
- October 25, 2020–H20: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated Effy and Matt Tremont in a anything goes match.
- April 6, 2021–NEW Studio Wars #13 Dutch defeated Moshpit.
- April 13, 2021–NEW Studio Wars #14: Dutch defeated Zachariah Gibbs.
- April 20, 2021–NEW Studio Wars #15: Dutch vs. Wrecking Ball Legursky ended in a no contest.
- May 27, 2021–Free The Narative: Parrow defeated William.
- June 25, 2021–ROH TV: Matt Taven defeated Dutch by disqualification.
- June 27, 2021–NEW: Hale Collins defeated Dutch by disqualification.
- July 1, 2021–Beyond Masterclass: Faith In Nothing (Rickey Shane Page and Vincent Nothing) defeated Team Tremendous (Dan Barry and Dutch).
- August 3, 2021–ROH Week By Week: Mike Bennett defeated The Righteous (Bateman and Dutch) by disqualification in a handicap match.
- August 20, 2021–ROH Glory By Honor: Mark Briscoe defeated Bateman w Dutch.
- October 1, 2021–Free The Narative 2: William defeated Stanley. Matt Taven defeated William.
- November 12, 2021–ROH TV: The Righteous (Bateman, Dutch and Vincent) w Vita VonStarr defeated The Foundation (Jonathan Gresham, Rhett Titus and Tracy Williams).
- December 5, 2021–Beyond Fete Forever: Dutch defeated Dan Barry in a no disqualification match.
- December 7, 2021–ROH Week by Week: The Righteous (Bateman, Dutch and Vincent) w Vita VonStarr defeated Primal Fear (Adrien Soriano, Gabriel Hodder and Matthew Omen).
- December 11, 2021–ROH Final Battle 2021 – Hour One: The Righteous (Bateman, Dutch and Vincent) w Vita VonStarr defeated Shane Taylor Promotions (Kaun, Moses and O’Shay Edwards [Replacement for Shane Taylor]) to win the World 6 man tag team titles.
- January 21, 2022–NEW: Adam Scherr and EC3 defeated The Righteous (Bateman and Dutch).
- January 22, 2022–NEW: The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe and Mark Briscoe) defeated The Righteous (Bateman and Dutch).
- February 4, 2022–Beyond Day 91: The Righteous (Bateman, Dutch and Vincent) defeated Teddy Goodz & Waves And Curls (Jaylen Brandyn and Traevon Jordan).
- February 25, 2022–Outlaw Wrestling: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Administration (Damian Adams and Pedro Dones).
- February 26, 2022–NYWC: Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts and Randy Summers) defeated The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- March 5, 2022–CYN: Adam Scherr and EC3 defeated The Righteous (Bateman and William).
- March 26, 2022–WAW Vs FFW: Dutch [FFW] vs. PJ Knight [WAW] ended in a double count-out.
- March 31, 2022–CYN: The Righteous (Bateman and William) defeated ??? and Fodder.
- April 15, 2022–CW: The Unit (Danny Miles, Mike Verna and Trigga The OG) defeated Dutch, Matt Taven and Vincent to retain the tag team titles.
- May 7, 2022–NEW: Wrecking Ball Legursky defeated Dutch.
- May 13, 2022–West Coast Pro: The West Coast Wrecking Crew (Jorel Nelson and Royce Isaacs) defeated The Righteous (Bateman and Dutch).
- July 23, 2022–ROH Death Before Dishonor: Dalton Castle & The Boys (Brandon and Brent) defeated The Righteous (Bateman, Dutch and Vincent) w Vita VonStarr to win the World 6 man tag team titles.
- July 24, 2022–NEW: Jay Lethal and Wrecking Ball Legursky defeated The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- July 30, 2022–Outlaw Wrestling: Homicide defeated Bill Carr to retain the Outlaw Wrestling title.
- August 20, 2022–Outlaw Wrestling: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Administration (Damian Adams and Pedro Dones).
- August 21, 2022–Beyond Americanrana: Waves And Curls (Jaylen Brandyn & Traevon Jordan) and Willow Nightingale defeated The Righteous (Dutch, Vincent and Vita VonStarr).
- January 14, 2023–NEW: Dutch was in the rumble match won by Kerr.
- April 6, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #6 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Stephen Azure and Steve Somerset.
- April 29, 2023–NEW: The Acclaimed (Anthony Bowens and Max Caster) defeated The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- May 11, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #11 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Infantry (Carlie Bravo and Shawn Dean).
- May 25, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #13 (Taped): Stu Grayson & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated LSG, Marcus Kross and Vary Morales.
- June 1, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #14 (Taped): Stu Grayson & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Dark Order (Alex Reynolds, Evil Uno and John Silver).
- June 9, 2023–CW: Dutch defeated JT Dunn to become #1 contender for the heavyweight title.
- June 15, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #16 (Taped): Stu Grayson & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Dalton Castle & The Boys (Brandon and Brent).
- June 29, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #18 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) w Stu Grayson defeated The Dark Order (Alex Reynolds and John Silver).
- July 6, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #19 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch & Vincent) and Stu Grayson defeated Macrae Martin, Rip Impact and Zak Patterson.
- July 13, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #20 (Taped): Stu Grayson & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Evan Rivers, Levi Night and Michael Allen Richard Clark.
- July 20, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #21 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) w Stu Grayson defeated The Boys (Brandon and Brent).
- July 21, 2023–ROH Death Before Dishonor: The Dark Order (Alex Reynolds, Evil Uno and John Silver) defeated Stu Grayson & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- August 30, 2023–AEW Rampage #108 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch & Vincent) were in the #1 contenders battle royal for the World tag team titles won the Alex Reynolds & John Silver.
- September 16, 2023–AEW Collision: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Hardys (Jeff Hardy and Matt Hardy).
- September 22, 2023–AEW Rampage #111: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Best Friends (Chuck Taylor and Trent Beretta), The Hardys (Jeff Hardy and Matt Hardy) & The Kingdom (Matt Taven and Mike Bennett) in a 4-way tag team match to become #1 contenders for the ROH World tag team titles.
- September 29, 2023–AEW Rampage #112: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Caleb Crush and Gunnar.
- September 30, 2023–AEW Collision: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Judas Icarus and Travis Williams.
- October 1, 2023 – AEW WrestleDream – Zero Hour: MJF defeated The Righteous (Dutch & Vincent) in a handicap match to retain the ROH World tag team titles.
- October 19, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #34 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Kevin Matthews and Rod Lee.
- November 2, 2023–ROH on HonorClub #36 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal.
- November 11, 2023–AEW Collision: Adam Copeland, Darby Allin and Sting defeated Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) w Jake Roberts.
- November 15, 2023–AEW Dynamite #215: The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) w Jake Roberts defeated Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal in a dark match.
- November 25, 2023 – AEW Collision: FTR (Cash Wheeler and Dax Harwood) defeated The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- December 7, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #41 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Outrunners (Truth Magnum and Turbo Floyd).
- December 14, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #42 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Australian Takeover (Julian Ward and Kaz Jordan).
- December 21, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #43 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Iron Savages (Boulder & Bronson) and Jacked Jameson.
- January 11, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #46 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Dawsons (Dave Dawson and Zane Dawson).
- January 13, 2024 – AEW Collision: The Mogul Embassy (Bishop Kaun, Brian Cage and Toa Liona) defeated Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) w Jake Roberts to retain the World 6 man tag team titles.
- January 25, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #48 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Anaya and Camaro Jackson.
- February 1, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #49 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated The Infantry (Carlie Bravo and Shawn Dean).
- February 15, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #51 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated James Blackheart, JC Valentine and Jon Cruz.
- March 1, 2024 – AEW Rampage #134 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Anaya, Luke Langley and Vaught.
- The Righteous are off AEW for 1 month.
- March 30, 2024 – AEW Collision: Blackpool Combat Club (Bryan Danielson & Claudio Castagnoli) and Katsuyori Shibata defeated Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- April 11, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #59 (Taped): The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Bryce Donovan and Chico Adams.
- April 18, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #60 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Damian Chambers, Jon Cruz and Savion Truitt.
- April 25, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #61 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated GPA, Jon Cruz and Ren Jones.
- May 9, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #63 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Nikki Eight, Parker Lee and Tommy Mars.
- May 18, 2024 – AEW Collision (Taped): Bryan Danielson & FTR (Cash Wheeler and Dax Harwood) defeated Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- May 25, 2024 – AEW Collision: Claudio Castagnoli, Daniel Garcia and Hiroshi Tanahashi defeated Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent).
- June 13, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #68 (Taped): Action Andretti & Top Flight (Dante Martin & Darius Martin) defeated Dalton Castle & The Infantry (Carlie Bravo & Shawn Dean) and Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch & Vincent) and The Dark Order (Alex Reynolds, Evil Uno & John Silver) in a 4 corners survival tag team match.
- June 27, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #70 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Duke Davis, Ganon Jones Jr. and Victor Benjamin.
- July 18, 2024 – ROH on HonorClub #74 (Taped): Lance Archer & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) defeated Dalton Castle & The Outrunners (Truth Magnum and Turbo Floyd).
- July 26, 2024 – AEW Rampage #155 (Taped): The Don Callis Family (Kyle Fletcher and Rush) defeated Private Party (Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen), The Outrunners (Truth Magnum and Turbo Floyd) & The Righteous (Dutch and Vincent) in a 4-way tag team match.