Title History
- NYWC Starlet title defeating Aria Cadenza (February 27, 2016);
- NYWC Starlet title defeating J-Redd (February 25, 2017);
- CHIKARA Campeonatos de Parejas title w Solo Darling defeating Tony Deppen & Travis Huckabee (November 9, 2019);
- NYWC Starlet title defeating Tina San Antonio (January 25, 2020);
- EAW women’s title defeating Tina San Antonio (November 20, 2021);
- NYWC Fusion title winning a 4-way match (February 26, 2022);
- NJPW STRONG women’s title defeating Mercedes Mone in a tournament (May 21, 2023);
- AEW TBS title defeating Julia Hart (April 21, 2024);
- CMLL World women’s title winning a 3-way match (July 13, 2024);
Career Highlights
- March 6, 2015 – Five Borough Wrestling: Sammy Pickles defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 28, 2015 – NYWC: Chrissy Rivera, Sammy Pickles and Willow Nightingale defeated J-Redd, Rick Cataldo and Ultimo Maya.
- April 18, 2015 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Brooke Danielle and Chrissy Rivera in a 3-way match.
- May 23, 2015 – FSW: Sumie Sakai defeated Willow Nightingale.
- July 30, 2015 – NYWC: Brooke Danielle, Sammy Pickles and Willow Nightingale defeated Aria Cadenza, Monique and Rick Cataldo.
- August 9, 2015 – MPUSA/NYWC: Davienne and Renee Michelle defeated Sumie Sakai and Willow Nightingale.
- August 12, 2015 – CZW Dojo Wars: Buckaroo Billy, David John Willard, Ken Phoenix and Mike McCallister defeated Eddy Blackwater, Jeff Cannonball, Josh Adams and Willow Nightingale.
- August 15, 2015 – DCW: Aria Cadenza defeated Willow Nightingale in the quarter-finals.
- August 27, 2015 – NYWC: Aria Cadenza defeated Willow Nightingale.
- October 4, 2015 – MPUSA/NYWC: Veda Scott and Willow Nightingale defeated Brittany Blake and Deonna Purrazzo.
- October 24, 2015 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Marti Belle.
- December 18, 2015 – FBW: Brooke Danielle defeated Willow Nightingale in a dark match.
- December 19, 2015 – NYWC: Brooke Danielle defeated Willow Nightingale.
- January 9, 2016 – ACE: Brooke Danielle defeated Willow Nightingale.
- January 30, 2016 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Brooke Danielle.
- February 6, 2016 – National Pro Wrestling Day: The Estonian ThunderFrog defeated Mike Verna, Rock Lobster and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way, elimination, 1st round match.
- February 13, 2016 – MPUSA/NYWC: Bam Sullivan, Boo Sullivan, Mouse and Stockade defeated Blake Morris, Rex Lawless, Brad Benson and Willow Nightingale.
- February 27, 2016 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Aria Cadenza to win the NYWC Starlet title.
- February 28, 2016 – NYWC vs. SWA: Willow Nightingale defeated Chrissy Rivera to retain the NYWC Starlet title.
- March 5, 2016 – ACE: Jamal Jackson and Willow Nightingale defeated Anthony Ramirez and Brooke Danielle.
- March 20, 2016 – BCW: Devil Doll defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 26, 2016 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Solo Darling to retain the NYWC Starlet title.
- April 3, 2016 – ACE: Terra Calaway defeated Brooke Danielle and Willow Nightingale in a 3-way match to retain the PWM women’s title.
- April 8, 2016 – GCW: Deonna Purrazzo defeated Karen Yu, Miranda Vionette and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way elimination match to become #1 contender for the women’s title.
- April 10, 2016 – WWR: Sonya Strong defeated Davienne, Miranda Vionette and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way match.
- April 30, 2016 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Deonna Purrazzo to retain the Starlet title.
- May 6, 2016 – VOW: Willow Nightingale defeated Britt Baker in the 1st round. Terra Calaway defeated Devyn Nicole and Willow Nightingale in a 3-way elimination, semi-finals match.
- May 14, 2016 – ACE: Willow Nightingale defeated Damaris.
- May 21, 2016 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Sammy Pickles to retain the Starlet title.
- May 28, 2016 – KPW: Vanity defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 4, 2016 – ACE: Damaris defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 18, 2016 – NYWC: NYWC Starlet champion Willow Nightingale defeated Chrissy Rivera to retain the title.
- June 25, 2016 – BCW: Sonya Strong vs. Willow Nightingale ended in a time limit draw.
- February 25, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated J-Redd to win the Starlet title.
- March 3, 2017 – ACE: Willow Nightingale defeated Jayel Cotto.
- March 4, 2017 – WWR: Willow Nightingale defeated Skylar.
- March 25, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Rick Cataldo to retain the Starlet title.
- March 30, 2017 – OCW/FTPW: Veda Scott and Willow Nightingale defeated Eddy McQueen and Layne Rosario in a dark match. Lindsay Snow defeated Brandi Lauren and Angel Rose and Brooke Danielle and Chrissy Rivera and Lacy Lane and Trish Adora and Willow Nightingale and Aria Blake in a gauntlet match to win the FTPW Ladies title.
- April 8, 2017 – WOW: Sonya Strong defeated Hellen Vale, Terra Callaway and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way, 1st round match.
- April 22, 2017 – HOG: Sonya Strong and Willow Nightingale defeated Sumie Sakai and Violette.
- April 23, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale vs. Sumie Sakai ended in a draw. Willow retains the Starlet title.
- May 13, 2017 – WSU: LuFisto defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 20, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Brittney Savage and Victoria Von Black in a 3-way match to retain the Starlet title.
- May 26, 2017 – BCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Nikki Addams.
- June 3, 2017 – ACE: Nadi defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 9, 2017 – WOW: C-Bunny and Willow Nightingale defeated Hellen Vale and Katred.
- June 17, 2017 – A Matter Of Pride: Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio to retain the Starlet title.
- June 17, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Brittney Savage to retain the Starlet title.
- June 23, 2017 – BCW: Katred and Nikki Addams defeated Faye Jackson and Willow Nightingale.
- June 24, 2017 – ECWA: Willow Nightingale defeated Gemma Cross and Tasha Steelz in a 3-way match.
- July 1, 2017 – JAPW: Katred defeated Terra Calaway, Allie Recks and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way match.
- July 2, 2017 – Beyond Wrestling: Terra Calaway defeated Willow Nightingale.
- July 27, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Karen Q to retain the Starlet title.
- July 29, 2017 – BCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Tasha Steelz.
- August 12, 2017 – H20 Wrestling: Maria Manic defeated Willow Nightingale.
- August 24, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Tasha Steelz to retain the Starlet title.
- September 9, 2017 – WSU: Blackwater and Su Yung defeated Anthony Bennett and Willow Nightingale in the 1st round of the Queen & King tournament.
- September 22, 2017 – Limitless: Skylar defeated Willow Nightingale.
- September 30, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Statlander to retain the Starlet title.
- October 8, 2017 – WWR: Willow Nightingale defeated Elena Pogosyan.
- October 20, 2017 – FBW: Willow Nightingale defeated Su Yung.
- October 21, 2017 – NYWC: Big O and Willow Nightingale defeated Randy Summers and Rick Cataldo.
- November 3, 2017 – Limitless: Terra Calaway defeated Ashley Vox, Davienne, Kennedi Copeland, Skylar and Willow Nightingale in a 6-way match.
- November 12, 2017 – Born To Fight Wrestling Event: Nyla Rose, Adira and Katred defeated Willow Nightingale, Kennedi Copeland and C-Bunny.
- November 25, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Terra Calaway to retain the Starlet title.
- November 26, 2017 – WWR: Karen Q defeated Willow Nightingale in the 1st round.
- December 1, 2017 – RISE 6: Hyannis and Maritza Janett defeated Trixie Tash and Willow Nightingale.
- December 2, 2017 – AWS: Aerial Monroe defeated Derby Doll and Hawlee Lane and Jewells Malone and Kikyo and Lacey Lane and Maritza Janett and Penelope Ford and Pizza Cat and Savannah Evans and Trixie Tash and Willow Nightingale in a battle royal.
- December 2, 2017 – RISE 6.5: Dust defeated Willow Nightingale.
- December 3, 2017 – CWFH: Shotzi Blackheart defeated Willow Nightingale.
- December 23, 2017 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Adria to retain the Starlet title.
- January 13, 2018 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Vanity to retain the Starlet title.
- January 20, 2018 – QOC 20: Savannah Evans defeated Willow Nightingale.
- January 21, 2018 – QOC 21: Priscilla Kelly defeated Willow Nightingale.
- January 28, 2018 – WWR: Solo Darling defeated Willow Nightingale. Willow Nightingale was also in the Revolutionary Rumble won by Jordynne Grace.
- February 10, 2018 – WOW: C-Bunny and Willow Nightingale defeated Thumper and Vanity.
- February 25, 2018 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Mike Mondo to retain the Starlet title.
- March 3, 2018 – BCP: Harlow O’Hara defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 17, 2018 – CWF Mid-Atlantic: Willow Nightingale defeated Aspyn Rose.
- March 24, 2018 – QOC 22: Ruthless Ambition (Maria Manic and Penelope Ford) defeated Thick And Juicy (Faye Jackson and Willow Nightingale) to retain the tag team titles.
- March 24, 2018 – QOC 23: Thick And Juicy (Faye Jackson & Willow Nightingale) and Jordynne Grace defeated The Riley Family (Maria Manic, Penelope Ford and Savannah Evans by disqualification.
- March 25, 2018 – WWR: Oceanea defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 31, 2018 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Terra Calaway to retain the Starlet title.
- April 3, 2018 – RISE 7: Deuce’s Alliance (Cheerleader Melissa, Shotzi Blackheart and Willow Nightingale) defeated Gokumon-To (Dynamite DiDi, Kikyo and Kris Wolf) in a tag team elimination match.
- April 13, 2018 – RISE 7: Deuce’s Alliance (Cheerleader Melissa, Shotzi Blackheart and Willow Nightingale) defeated Gokumon-To (Dynamite DiDi, Kikyo and Kris Wolf) in a tag team elimination match.
- April 14, 2018 – SHIMMER Volume 101: Mercedes Martinez defeated Willow Nightingale.
- April 15, 2018 – SHIMMER Volume 103: Willow Nightingale defeats Sierra.
- April 15, 2018 – SHIMMER Volume 104: Melanie Cruise defeated Willow Nightingale.
- April 21, 2018 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Stadtlander.
- April 28, 2018 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Maria Manic to retain the Starlet title.
- May 19, 2018 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Davienne, Gabby Ortiz and Terra Calaway in a 4-way match to retain the Starlet title.
- May 26, 2018 – BCP: Willow Nightingale defeated Kiera Hogan.
- May 27, 2018 – WWR: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Alisha Edwards and Gillian Leigh.
- June 9, 2018 – SHINE 51: Natalia Markova defeated Aja Perera and Willow Nightingale in a 3-way match.
- June 10, 2018 – A Matter Of Pride: Willow Nightingale defeated Ashley Vox to retain the NYWC Starlet title.
- June 16, 2018 – WSU: Leyla Hirsch defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 30, 2018 – AWS: Willow Nightingale defeated Dust in the 1st round. Aerial Monroe defeated Willow Nightingale in the semi-finals.
- July 20, 2018 – Let’s Hang Out! – A Collaborative Effort By LVAC & BWA: Dasher Hatfield, Kodama, UltraMantis Black and Willow Nightingale defeated Hallowicked, Kobald, Merlok and Oceanea.
- July 21, 2018 – Forza Lucha! 6: Corinne Mink defeated Willow Nightingale.
- July 21, 2018 – Synergy: Jeff Cannonball and Terra Calaway defeated Rex Lawless and Willow Nightingale.
- July 27, 2018 – QOC: Thick And Juicy (Faye Jackson and Willow Nightingale) defeated Ruthless Ambition (Maria Manic and Penelope Ford) to win the tag team titles.
- July 28, 2018 – QOC: Rachael Ellering vs. Willow Nightingale ended in a time limit draw.
- August 24, 2018 – Blackcraft: Harlow O’Hara and Vipress defeated Ashley Vox and Willow Nightingale in a dark match.
- August 25, 2018 – ACW/Rogue: Thunder Rosa defeated Willow Nightingale.
- August 26, 2018 – WWR: Willow Nightingale defeated Alisha Edwards.
- August 27, 2018 – NYWC: Rex Lawless and Willow Nightingale defeated Cajun Crawdad and Hermit Crab by count-out.
- September 8, 2018 – Dropkick Depression: Big Hair Bigger Dino (Terra Calaway and Willow Nightingale) defeated Frightmare and UltraMantis Black.
- September 16, 2018 – Beyond Somebody’s Farewell, Probably: Willow Nightingale defeated Penelope Ford.
- September 20, 2018 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Willow Nightingale defeated Penelope Ford.
- September 21, 2018 – Limitless: Davienne and Kris Stadtlander defeated Ashley Vox and Willow Nightingale.
- September 29, 2018 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Kasey Catal and Terra Calaway in a 3-way match to retain the Starlet title.
- October 19, 2018 – NOVA: Breaux Keller and Willow Nightingale defeated Harlow O’Hara and Kevin Blackwood in the 1st round. Booty And The Ace (Arik Royal and Faye Jackson) defeated Pop Culture (Jason Cade and Veda Scott), The Aristokats (Allie Kat and Maxwell Jacob Friedman) & Breaux Keller and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way tag team elimination match to win the Sadie Hawkins Invitational Tournament.
- October 20, 2018 – SHIMMER Volume 106: Willow Nightingale defeated Dynamite DiDi.
- October 21, 2018 – SHIMMER Volume 107: Dust defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the Heart Of SHIMMER title.
- October 21, 2018 – SHIMMER Volume 108: Willow Nightingale defeated Zoe Lucas.
- October 28, 2018 – WWR vs. The World: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Undeniably Impressive (Indi Hartwell and Tessa Blanchard).
- November 1, 2018 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Willow Nightingale defeated Puf.
- November 10, 2018 – Angel Gate: Jenna Van Muscles defeated Willow Nightingale.
- November 17, 2018 – WH20: Willow Nightingale defeated Davienne and Katred in a 3-way match.
- November 23, 2018 – NYWC: Brandon Watts and Willow Nightingale defeated Bull James and Kimber Lee.
- November 25, 2018 – QOC: Thick And Juicy (Faye Jackson and Willow Nightingale) defeated The Sinister Sweethearts (Brittany Blake and Samantha Heights) & Team Sea Stars (Ashley Vox and Delmi Exo) in a 3-way tag team match to retain the tag team titles.
- December 6, 2018 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling/KBB: Willow Nightingale defeated Kimber Lee.
- December 7, 2018 – CW: Tasha Steelz defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the women’s title.
- December 15, 2018 – SHINE 55: Allie Recks and Willow Nightingale defeated Brandi Lauren and Jenna.
- December 28, 2018 – LVAC: Willow Nightingale defeated Rex Lawless.
- December 29, 2018 – NYWC: Bull James, Kris Stadtlander and Rex Lawless defeated Brandon Watts, King Mega and Willow Nightingale.
- December 30, 2018 – Beyond Tournament For Tomorrow: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Team Black And Blue (Davienne and Miranda Vionette) in the 1st round. The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Team Adams (Karen Q and Tasha Steelz) in the semi-finals. The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated The Twisted Sisters (Holidead and Thunder Rosa) to win the tournament.
- December 31, 2019 – Beyond Heavy Lies The Crown: The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale).
- January 11, 2019 – Limitless: Brandon Kirk defeated Ace Austin, Jordan Oliver, Ophidian, The Whisper and Willow Nightingale in a 6-way match.
- January 18, 2019 – WOW Women Of Wrestling #1 (Taped): Eye Candy defeated Khloe Hurtz.
- January 19, 2019 – QOC 29: Thick And Juicy (Faye Jackson and Willow Nightingale) defeated The Sinister Sweethearts (Brittany Blake and Samantha Heights) to retain the tag team titles.
- January 25, 2019 – Flying V Fights: Fight Or Flight: Brittany Blake defeated Willow Nightingale.
- January 26, 2019 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Stadtlander to win the best of 5 series 3-2 and taking advantage in the psycho circus match.
- February 8, 2019 – WOW Women Of Wrestling #4 (Taped): The Beverly Hills Babe defeated Eye Candy.
- February 10, 2019 – CHIKARA: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Los Ice Creams (El Hijo del Ice Cream and Ice Cream Jr.), The Colony (Green Ant and Thief Ant) & The Proteus Wheel (Frantik and Volgar) in a 4-way tag team elimination match.
- February 17, 2019 – FPW: Just Peachy (Kylie Rae and Laynie Luck) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale).
- February 21, 2019 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Maria Manic, Valentina and Willow Nightingale defeated Mike Verna, Pat Buck and Rex Lawless.
- February 22, 2019 – C4: Alexia Nicole and Willow Nightingale defeated KC Spinelli and Veda Scott.
- February 23, 2019 – WWR: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Allie Kat and Veda Scott.
- February 23, 2019 – NYWC: Team Bull James (Brad Benson, Bull James, CJ Benson, Kris Stadtlander, Mouse and Rex Lawless) defeated The Culture (King Mega (c), Brandon Watts (c), Dave McCall (c), Nate Carter (c), Chris Bishop and Willow Nightingale (c)) in a psycho circus match, where all titles changed hands.
- February 24, 2019 – Beyond Treasure Hunt: Chris Dickinson defeated Willow Nightingale in the 1st round.
- Willow Nightingale suffered a neck injury and will be out of action for a unknown amount of time.
- March 1, 2019 – WOW Women Of Wrestling #7 (Taped): Havok defeated Eye Candy.
- September 28, 2019 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio by count-out. San Antonio retains the Starlet title.
- October 3, 2019 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.01: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Alex Reynolds and Mark Sterling.
- October 5, 2019 – CHIKARA: The Crucible (Devantes, EM Demorest and Matt Makowski) defeated The Queens (Freddie Mercurio, Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) in the 1st round of the King Of Trios tournament.
- October 6, 2019 – CHIKARA: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling & Willow Nightingale) defeated Cornelius Crummels & Sonny Defarge and Der Wildebeest & Jakob Hammermeier and Jawbreaker Josue & Joshua Wells and Los Ice Creams (El Hijo del Ice Cream & Ice Cream Jr.) and The Closers (Rick Roland & Sloan Caprice) and The Creatures Of The Deep (Cajun Crawdad & Merlok) and The Crucible (Frey Nassar & Tunku Amir) and The Proteus Wheel (Callux The Castigator & Volgar) and The VeloCities (Jude London & Paris De Silva) in a tag team gauntlet match.
- October 17, 2019 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Kris Statlander and Still Life With Apricots And Pears.
- October 25, 2019 – LVAC: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Rex Lawless and The Proletariat Boar Of Moldova.
- October 26, 2019 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio by disqualification. San Antonio retains the Starlet title.
- October 31, 2019 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.05: Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale).
- November 2, 2019 – SHIMMER Volume 113: The Blue Nation (Charli Evans and Jessica Troy) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale).
- November 3, 2019 – SHIMMER Volume 116: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated The Top Dogs (Davienne and Skylar).
- November 3, 2019 – SHIMMER Volume 117: Team Sea Stars (Ashley Vox and Delmi Exo) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) to retain the tag team titles.
- November 9, 2019 – CHIKARA: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated FIST (Tony Deppen and Travis Huckabee) in a best 2/3 falls match to win the CHIKARA Campeonatos de Parejas title.
- November 14, 2019 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.07: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Club Cam (Christian Casanova and Richard Holliday).
- November 16, 2019 – PTPW: The Nouveau Aesthetic (BLANK and Still Life With Apricots And Pears) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) in the semi-finals of the tag team titles tournament.
- November 21, 2019 – Save Hoa Binh Plaza! A Punk / Pro Wrestling Extravaganza!: Thief Ant and Willow Nightingale defeated Dan Champion and Rex Lawless.
- December 1, 2019 – QOC 39: Faye Jackson defeated Willow Nightingale.
- December 12, 2019 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: The Closers (Mike Verna & Rex Lawless) and Willow Nightingale defeated The Big Action (Dones, Eric Raymond and Tina San Antonio).
- December 14, 2019 – Dropkick Depression: Willow Nightingale defeated Adira, Corinne Mink, Gabby Ortiz, Katred and Molly McCoy in a 6-way match.
- December 27, 2019 – Flying V Fights: The Ugly Ducklings (Lance Lude and Rob Killjoy) defeated Pretty Proper (Lady Frost and Victor Benjamin), Salt The Earth (Matt Makowski and Travis Huckabee) & The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) in a 4-way tag team match.
- December 28, 2019 – NYWC: Tina San Antonio vs. Willow Nightingale ended in a no contest. San Antonio retains the Starlet title. Willow Nightingale defeated Debbie Kane and Marti Belle in a 3-way match.
- January 11, 2020 – PWF: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Jaden Valo and Jakob Hammermeier.
- January 18, 2020 – CHIKARA: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Los Ice Creams (El Hijo del Ice Cream and Ice Cream Jr.).
- January 25, 2020 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio in a steel cage match to win the Starlet title.
- January 25, 2020 – Beyond Please Come Back: Willow Nightingale defeated Jaden Valo.
- February 20, 2020 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Willow Nightingale defeated Tasha Steelz.
- February 22, 2020 – NYWC: Tina San Antonio defeated Willow Nightingale to win the Starlet title.
- February 29, 2020 – CHIKARA: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated The Colony (Green Ant and Thief Ant).
- March 7, 2020 – PTPW: The Kings Of The District (Eel O’Neal and Jordan Blade) defeated Ariela Nyx and Logan Black & The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) in a 3-way tag team elimination match to retain the tag team titles.
- July 26, 2020 – Beyond Two Weeks Notice: Willow Nightingale defeated Pinkie Sanchez.
- August 14, 2020 – LVAC: Willow Nightingale defeated Gabby Ortiz.
- August 15, 2020 – LVAC: Puf, Still Life With Apricots And Pears and Willow Nightingale defeated Dan Champion, The Proletariat Boar Of Moldova and Veda Scott.
- August 23, 2020 – Beyond Wear Sunscreen: Willow Nightingale defeated Max Caster.
- September 20, 2020 – Beyond Shangri-La Magistral: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Nouveau Aesthetic (BLANK and Still Life With Apricots And Pears).
- October 9, 2020 – GCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Devon Monroe, Faye Jackson and Marti Belle in a 4-way match.
- October 10, 2020 – GCW Joey Janela’s Spring Break 4: Willow Nightingale was in the clusterfuck battle royal won by Nate Webb.
- October 11, 2020 – SHIMMER Volume 118: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Kayla Kassidy and Sierra.
- December 12, 2020 – Synergy: Willow Nightingale defeated Gabby Ortiz in the 1st round. Holidead defeated Willow Nightingale in the semi-finals.
- December 31, 2020 – GCW/Hybrid: Holidead defeated Willow Nightingale in the 1st round.
- January 29, 2021 – GCW: The REP (Dave McCall and Nate Carter) defeated Thick And Juicy (Faye Jackson and Willow Nightingale).
- January 30, 2021 – GCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Allie Kat.
- February 25, 2021 – Enjoy Canned Heat #1: MV Young defeated Willow Nightingale in the 1st round of the Enjoy Cup title tournament.
- March 6, 2021 – Hybrid: Willow Nightingale defeated Faye Jackson.
- March 18, 2021 – Beyond The Signature Series #4: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Mike Verna and Rex Lawless in the 1st round.
- March 18, 2021 – Enjoy Canned Heat #4: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated Shawn Phoenix and Ziggy Haim.
- March 20, 2021 – Camp Leapfrog: Erica Leigh, Sonny Defarge, The Boar and Willow Nightingale defeated Killian And The Goons (Big Dust, Eel O’Neal, Killian McMurphy and Myles Millennium) in a looser eats dog food match.
- March 25, 2021 – Beyond The Signature Series #5: The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) defeated 40 Acres (PB Smooth and Tre Lamar) in the semi-finals.
- March 28, 2021 – H20/SHP: Conor Claxton vs. Willow Nightingale ended in a double count-out.
- April 1, 2021 – Beyond The Signature Series #6: Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts and Randy Summers) defeated The Bird And The Bee (Solo Darling and Willow Nightingale) to win the tournament.
- April 1, 2021 – Beyond Fool’s Paradise: Willow Nightingale defeated Aaron Rourke.
- April 8, 2021 – GCW: Fire ‘N Flava (Kiera Hogan and Tasha Steelz) defeated Thick And Juicy 2.0 (Brooke Valentine and Willow Nightingale) to retain the IMPACT Wrestling Knockouts tag team titles.
- April 8, 2021 – IWTV Family Reunion: Funny Bone, Nurse Ratchet and The Super Beast defeated D-Rogue, James C and Willow Nightingale.
- April 9, 2021 – GCW 18: Jennacide defeated Willow Nightingale.
- April 9, 2021 – GCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Brooke Valentine.
- May 3, 2021 – AEW Dark Elevation #8: Thunder Rosa defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 7, 2021 – Invictus Women’s Championship Tournament #1: Willow Nightingale defeated Gabby Ortiz in the 1st round.
- May 11, 2021 – AEW Dark #88: Diamante defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 16, 2021 – WWR+ Let’s Talk About Wrestling: Trish Adora defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 21, 2021 – Invictus Women’s Championship Tournament #4: Notorious Mimi defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 28, 2021 – Invictus Women’s Championship Tournament #4: Notorious Mimi defeated Willow Nightingale to win the tournament and vacant women’s title.
- June 2, 2021 – ROH Women’s Division Wednesday #6: Willow defeated Alex Gracia.
- June 3, 2021 – Beyond Project Dolphin: Willow Nightingale defeated Alec Price.
- June 8, 2021 – AEW Dark #92: Abadon defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 15, 2021 – AEW Dark #93: Tay Conti defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 19, 2021 – Black Wrestlers Matter 2: Joseline Navarro defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 20, 2021 – WWR+ To Wrestle, Shoot Straight And Speak The Truth: Willow Nightingale defeated Masha Slamovich.
- June 26, 2021 – ProUnapologetic Presents Black Girl Magik: Jazz and Trish Adora defeated Thick And Juicy 2.0 (Brooke Valentine and Willow Nightingale).
- July 1, 2021 – Beyond Masterclass: Wheeler Yuta defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the IWTV Independent Wrestling title.
- July 7, 2021 – ROH Women’s Division Wednesday #11: Allie Recks and Gia Scott defeated Sumie Sakai and Willow.
- July 8, 2021 – Enjoy Canned Heat S2 #4: Effy defeated Willow Nightingale to retain FEST Wrestling title.
- July 18, 2021 – WWR+ Pain For Pleasure: Tina San Antonio defeated Willow Nightingale.
- August 4, 2021 – ROH Women’s Division Wednesday #15: Allysin Kay defeated Willow in the 1st round.
- August 5, 2021 – Beyond Dong Work For YUTA: Willow Nightingale defeated Davienne.
- August 14, 2021 – Hybrid: Kiera Hogan defeated Willow Nightingale.
- August 19, 2021 – IHPW: Delilah Doom defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the women’s title.
- August 20, 2021 – IHPW: Willow Nightingale defeated Gabby Ortiz.
- August 21, 2021 – ROH Glory by Honor: Miranda Alize and Rok-C defeated Chelsea Green and Willow.
- September 11, 2021 – CCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Queen Aminata.
- September 19, 2021 – Beyond/WWR+ Masha Slamovich Presents Borscht At The Beach: The Administration (Damian Adams, Pedro Dones and Tina San Antonio) defeated Ashley D’Amboise, Riley Shepard and Willow Nightingale.
- October 6, 2021 – MLW Fusion ALPHA #3 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Ashley Vox.
- October 8, 2021 – ROH TV: Willow defeated Angelina Love and Miranda Alize in a 3-way match to become #1 contender for the women’s world title.
- October 8, 2021 – Enjoy: Willow Nightingale defeated Derek Dillinger.
- October 13, 2021 – ROH Women’s Division Wednesday #25: Holidead and Willow defeated Alex Gracia and Laynie Luck.
- October 14, 2021 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #3.02: Willow Nightingale defeated Lady Frost.
- October 21, 2021 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #3.03: Megan Bayne defeated Willow Nightingale.
- October 22, 2021 – LVAC: Edith Surreal and Willow Nightingale defeated Bonesaw Brooks and Gabby Ortiz.
- October 23, 2021 – MPW: Willow Nightingale was in the battle royal won by Holidead. Vipress defeated Willow Nightingale.
- October 28, 2021 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #3.04: Chris Dickinson and Willow Nightingale defeated The Kirks (Brandon Kirk and Kasey Kirk).
- October 31, 2021 – SHIMMER Volume 119: Kimber Lee defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the SHIMMER title.
- October 31, 2021 – SHIMMER Volume 120: Willow Nightingale defeated Hyan.
- November 3, 2021 – MLW Fusion ALPHA #7 (Taped): The Sea Stars (Ashley Vox and Delmi Exo) defeated Willow Nightingale and Zoey Skye.
- November 4, 2021 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #3.05: Chris Dickinson and Willow Nightingale defeated YoKai (Janai Kai and Yoya).
- November 7, 2021 – Beyond/WWR+ Reverse The Curse: The Administration (Damian Adams, Pedro Dones and Tina San Antonio) defeated The Goodfellas (Mike Verna & Rex Muscarella) and Willow Nightingale.
- November 10, 2021 – ROH Women’s Division Wednesday #29: Trish Adora and Willow defeated Gia Scott and Vita VonStarr.
- November 18, 2021 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #3.07: Willow Nightingale defeated Becca.
- November 20, 2021 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio to win the vacant EAW women’s title.
- November 22, 2021 – AEW Dark Elevation #38: TayJay (Anna Jay and Tay Conti) defeated Erica Leigh and Willow Nightingale.
- November 27, 2021 – NEW: Willow Nightingale defeated Brett Ryan Gosselin.
- December 3, 2021 – ROH TV: Willow defeated Mandy Leon to become #1 contender for the women’s world title.
- December 4, 2022 – CCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Christina Marie in the 1st round. KiLynn King defeated Willow Nightingale to win the tournament and vacant CCW title.
- December 5, 2021 – Beyond Fete Forever: Willow Nightingale defeated Max The Impaler.
- December 11, 2021 – ROH Final Battle 2021 – End Of An Era: Rok-C defeated Willow to retain the women’s world title.
- December 15, 2021 – ROH Women’s Division Wednesday #34: Quinn McKay and Rok-C defeated Holidead and Willow.
- December 21, 2021 – AEW Dark #122: Penelope Ford defeated Willow Nightingale.
- December 31, 2021 – Beyond/WWR+ Heavy Lies The Crown: B3CCA defeated Willow Nightingale.
- January 24, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #47: Brandi Rhodes defeated Willow Nightingale.
- February 4, 2022 – Beyond Day 91: Rex Lawless and Willow Nightingale defeated The Shook Crew (Bobby Orlando and Bryce Donovan).
- February 13, 2022 – WWR+ Galentine’s Day Massacre: AR Fox defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the IWTV Independent Wrestling World title.
- February 19, 2022 – CCW: Christina Marie defeated Willow Nightingale to become #1 contender for the CCW title.
- February 26, 2022 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Johnny Radke, Dino Might and John Silver in a 4-way match to win the Fusion title.
- February 28, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #52: Leyla Hirsch defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 13, 2022 – Beyond Wrestling Munky Business: Willow Nightingale defeated Jordynne Grace.
- March 20, 2022 – WWR+ The (Littlest And) Meanest Of Times: Willow Nightingale defeated Jody Threat.
- March 25, 2022 – C4: Alexia Nicole defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the Femmes Fatale title.
- March 26, 2022 – CCW: Edith Surreal and Willow Nightingale defeated Gia Scott and Vita VonStarr.
- April 1, 2022 – ROH Supercard of Honor: Mercedes Martinez defeated Willow Nightingale to win the vacant ROH Interim World Women’s Title.
- April 3, 2022 – New Texas Pro: Raychell Rose defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the women’s title.
- April 8, 2022 – AEW Rampage #36: Red Velvet defeats Willow Nightingale to qualify for the Owen Hart Foundation Women’s Tournament.
- April 9, 2022 – MAW: Sierra defeated Willow Nightingale in the semi-finals.
- April 16, 2022 – BSP: Mother Endless defeated Willow Nightingale.
- April 20, 2022 – BCP: Brooke Valentine and Willow Nightingale defeated Janai Kai and Jordan Blade.
- April 24, 2022 – Beyond Inertia: Alec Price defeated Willow Nightingale.
- April 29. 2022 – AEW Rampage #38: The Baddies (Jade Cargill, Kiera Hogan and Red Velvet) defeated Skye Blue, Trish Adora and Willow Nightingale.
- April 30, 2022 – NYWC: Joey Conway defeated Willow Nightingale to win the Fusion title.
- May 1, 2022 – WWA: The Hex (Allysin Kay and Marti Belle) defeated Holidead and Willow Nightingale to retain the NWA World women’s tag team titles.
- May 1, 2022 – WWR+ Hit Em Up Style: Willow Nightingale defeated Jordan Blade.
- May 2, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #61: Willow Nightingale defeated Gia Scott.
- May 6, 2022 – LVAC: Willow Nightingale defeated Tracy Williams.
- May 13, 2022 – Wrestler’s Lab: Ziggy Haim defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 14, 2022 – MPW: Willow Nightingale defeated Shazza McKenzie.
- May 27, 2022 – GRIND: Willow Nightingale defeated Brooke Valentine.
- May 28, 2022 – Prestige: Taya Valkyrie defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 4, 2022 – BLP: Billie Starkz defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 12, 2022 – Beyond Please Come Back III: Beyond Wrestling Vs. Wrestling Open: Willow Nightingale defeated Rex Lawless.
- June 17, 2022 – AEW Rampage #46: Jade Cargill w Stokely Hathaway defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the TBS title.
- June 18, 2022 – Prestige: Mia Yim defeated Willow Nightingale.
- June 24, 2022 – LPW 5: Willow Nightingale defeated Zoe Sager.
- June 26, 2022 – WWR+ Aces High: Willow Nightingale defeated Little Mean Kathleen.
- June 28, 2022 – AEW Dark #150: Willow Nightingale defeated Ashley D’Amboise.
- July 2, 2022 – Enjoy: Ephemeral Babes (Edith Surreal and Willow Nightingale) defeated Petty In Pink (Dillon McQueen and Kenzie Paige) in the 1st round. The Production (Derek Dillinger & Ziggy Haim) defeated Ephemeral Babes (Edith Surreal & Willow Nightingale) and The Runway (Calvin Couture & Tyler Klein) and Violence Is Forever (Dominic Garrini & Kevin Ku) to win the tournament and the vacant Enjoy tag team titles.
- July 12, 2022 – AEW Dark #152: Willow Nightingale defeated Mila Moore.
- July 20, 2022 – AEW Dynamite #146: The Baddies (Jade Cargill and Kiera Hogan) defeated Athena and Willow Nightingale.
- July 23, 2022 – ROH Death Before Dishonor – Zero Hour: Willow Nightingale defeated Allysin Kay.
- July 28, 2022 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Michael Mistretta by disqualification. Mistretta retains the heavyweight title.
- August 1, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #74: Hikaru Shida, Toni Storm and Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura, Marina Shafir and Nyla Rose.
- August 2, 2022 – AEW Dark #155: Willow Nightingale defeated Harley Cameron.
- August 6, 2022 – CCW: Willow Nightingale defeated Savannah Evans.
- August 16, 2022 – AEW Dark #157: Willow Nightingale defeated Robyn Renegade w Charlette.
- August 20, 2022 – BCP: The Mane Event (Jay Lyon and Midas Black) defeated Thick And Juicy 2.0 (Spice Spiegel and Willow Nightingale) to retain the tag team titles.
- August 20, 2022 – Black Girl Magik: Thick And Juicy 2.0 (Brooke Valentine and Willow Nightingale) defeated Estrella and Mazzerati.
- August 21, 2022 – Beyond Americanrana: Waves And Curls (Jaylen Brandyn & Traevon Jordan) and Willow Nightingale defeated The Righteous (Dutch, Vincent and Vita VonStarr).
- August 25, 2022 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Dolli.
- August 27, 2022 – LVAC: Davienne defeated Gabby Ortiz and Willow Nightingale in a 3-way match.
- September 10, 2022 – NYWC: Willow Nightingale defeated Mouse.
- September 16, 2022 – AEW Rampage #59: Penelope Ford defeated Willow Nightingale.
- September 25, 2022 – Beyond Wrestling Bish At The Beach: The Miracle Ones (Dustin Waller, Ichiban and Kylon King) defeated Waves And Curls (Jaylen Brandyn & Traevon Jordan) and Willow Nightingale.
- September 30, 2022 – AEW Rampage #61: Jamie Hayter defeated Willow Nightingale.
- October 5, 2022 – AEW Dynamite #157: Athena, Toni Storm and Willow Nightingale defeated Jamie Hayter, Penelope Ford and Serena Deeb.
- October 7, 2022 – AEW Battle Of The Belts IV: Jade Cargill w The Baddies defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the TBS title.
- October 15, 2022 – NEW: Willow Nightingale defeated Tasha Steelz.
- October 16, 2022 – NAP: Willow Nightingale defeated Chase Holliday.
- October 18, 2022 – AEW Dark #166: Willow Nightingale defeated Seleziya Sparx.
- October 21, 2022 – AEW Rampage #54: Willow Nightingale defeated Leila Grey w Kiera Hogan. Tony Khan announced that Willow is now officially signed with AEW.
- October 29, 2022 – TJPW: Willow Nightingale and Yuka Sakazaki defeated Maki Ito and Yuki Kamifuku.
- November 3, 2022 – DDT: Moeka Haruhi and Willow Nightingale defeated Yoshiko Hasegawa and Yuna Manase.
- November 6, 2022 – TJPW: Shoko Nakajima and Willow Nightingale defeated Miu Watanabe and Suzume.
- November 14, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #89: Riho and Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura and Mei Suruga.
- November 21, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #90: Hikaru Shida and Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura and Leva Bates.
- November 22, 2022 – AEW Dark #171: Willow Nightingale defeated Marina Shafir.
- November 23, 2022 – AEW Dynamite #164: Dr. Britt Baker DMD and Jamie Hayter defeated Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale & TayJay AS (Anna Jay AS and Tay Melo) in a 3-way tag team match.
- November 27, 2022 – Beyond Motherload: Willow Nightingale defeated Masha Slamovich.
- November 30, 2022 – AEW Dynamite #165: Willow Nightingale defeated Anna Jay AS.
- December 10, 2022 – ROH Final Battle – Zero Hour: Willow Nightingale defeated Trish Adora.
- December 12, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #93: Willow Nightingale defeated Vertvixen.
- December 26, 2022 – AEW Dark Elevation #95: Ruby Soho and Willow Nightingale defeated Madi Wrenkowski and Vertvixen.
- December 28, 2022 – AEW Dynamite #169: TayJay AS (Anna Jay AS and Tay Melo) defeated Ruby Soho and Willow Nightingale.
- December 30, 2022 – Prestige: Willow Nightingale defeated Jody Threat.
- December 31, 2022 – Beyond Heavy Lies The Crown: Willow Nightingale defeated LuFisto.
- January 10, 2023 – AEW Dark #178: Ruby Soho and Willow Nightingale defeated Diamante and Emi Sakura.
- January 13, 2023 – AEW Rampage #77: Ruby Soho and Willow Nightingale defeated TayJay AS (Anna Jay AS and Tay Melo) in a street fight.
- January 14, 2023 – NEW: Willow Nightingale was in the rumble match won by Kerr. Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio.
- January 18, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #172: Toni Storm defeated Willow Nightingale.
- February 2, 2023 – Jericho Cruise: Hikaru Shida defeated Willow Nightingale.
- February 5, 2023 – Jericho Cruise: Jade Cargill and Leila Grey defeated Ruby Soho and Willow Nightingale.
- February 20, 2023 – AEW Dark Elevation #103: Emi Sakura, Marina Shafir and Nyla Rose defeated Leva Bates, Madison Rayne and Willow Nightingale.
- February 24, 2023 – AEW Rampage #83: Toni Storm w Saraya defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 2, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #1 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Lady Frost.
- March 7, 2023 – AEW Dark #186: Willow Nightingale defeated Zoe Dubois.
- March 9, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #2 (Taped): Athena defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the women’s world title.
- March 26, 2023 – Beyond Test Of Time: Rex Lawless and Willow Nightingale defeated Little Mean Kathleen and Teddy Goodz.
- March 27, 2023 – AEW Dark Elevation #108: Willow Nightingale defeated Maggie Lee.
- March 29, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #189: Ruby Soho w Toni Storm & Saraya defeated Willow Nightingale.
- March 31, 2023 – ROH Supercard Of Honor – Zero Hour: Willow Nightingale defeated Miranda Alize.
- April 6, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #6 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Notorious Mimi.
- April 13, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #7 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Little Mean Kathleen.
- April 15, 2023 – NEW: Willow Nightingale defeated Megan Bayne.
- April 20, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #8 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Robyn Renegade.
- April 29, 2023 – NEW: Willow Nightingale defeated Tina San Antonio.
- April 30, 2023 – Beyond Thirty: Willow Nightingale defeated Anastasia Morningstar.
- May 3, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #187: Saraya w Ruby Soho & Toni Storm defeated Willow Nightingale.
- May 4, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #10 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Steph De Lander.
- May 10, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #188: Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated Marina Shafir and Nyla Rose in a dark match.
- May 17, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #189: Abadon, Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura, Marina Shafir and Nyla Rose in a dark match.
- May 18, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #12 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Madi Wrenkowski.
- May 21, 2023 – NJPW STRONG Resurgence: Willow Nightingale defeated Momo Kohgo in the 1st round. Willow Nightingale defeated Mercedes Mone to win the tournament to win the tournament and vacant STRONG women’s title. Mercedes Mone suffered a ankle injury in this match.
- May 25, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #13 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Hyan.
- June 2, 2023 – AEW Rampage #97 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura to retain the STRONG women’s title.
- June 8, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #15 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Rachael Ellering to retain the STRONG women’s title.
- June 9, 2023 – AEW Rampage #99 (Taped): Maki Itoh and Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura and Megan Bayne in a dark match.
- June 17, 2023 – AEW Collision #1 (Taped): Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated The Outcasts (Ruby Soho and Toni Storm).
- June 24, 2023 – AEW Collision #2 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Nyla Rose in the 1st round.
- June 25, 2023 – AEW/NJPW Forbidden Door: Toni Storm defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the AEW world women’s title.
- July 4, 2023 – NJPW STRONG Independence Day: Momo Kohgo and Willow Nightingale defeated Mafia Bella (Giulia and Thekla).
- July 5, 2023 – NJPW STRONG Independence Day: Giulia defeated Willow Nightingale to win the STRONG women’s title.
- July 14, 2023 – AEW Rampage #101 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Athena in the semi-finals.
- July 15, 2023 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Ruby Soho to win the Owen Hart women’s tournament.
- July 21, 2023 – ROH Death Before Dishonor: Athena defeated Willow Nightingale by referee’s decision to retain the women’s world title.
- August 12, 2023 – AEW Collision: Diamante and Mercedes Martinez defeated Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale.
- August 19, 2023 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Diamante.
- August 23, 2023 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Robyn Renegade.
- September 1, 2023 – AEW Rampage #108 (Taped): Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated Anna Jay and Taya Valkyrie.
- September 3, 2023 – AEW All Out – Zero Hour: Hikaru Shida, Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated Athena, Diamante and Mercedes Martinez.
- September 7, 2023 – ROH On HonorClub #28 (Taped): Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated The Renegades (Charlette Renegade and Robyn Renegade).
- September 14, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #29 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Lady Frost.
- September 21, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #30 (Taped): Kiera Hogan, Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated Charlette Renegade, Leyla Hirsch and Robyn Renegade.
- September 27, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #208: Julia Hart defeated Willow Nightingale.
- October 5, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #32 (Taped): Kiera Hogan, Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale defeated Lady Frost & The Renegades (Charlette Renegade and Robyn Renegade).
- October 12, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #33 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Leyla Hirsch.
- October 21, 2023 – AEW Battle of The Belts VIII: Kris Statlander defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the TBS title.
- October 22, 2023 – Kitsune: Konami and Willow Nightingale defeated Janai Kai and Mercedes Martinez.
- October 27, 2023 – AEW Rampage #116 (Taped): Abadon defeated Anna Jay, Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale in a 4-way match to become #1 contender for the women’s world title.
- November 1, 2023 – AEW Dynamite #213: Hikaru Shida defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the women’s world title.
- November 4, 2023 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Emi Sakura.
- November 11, 2023 – AEW Collision: Julia Hart defeated Willow Nightingale in a eliminator match to retain the TBS title.
- November 23, 2023 – ROH on HonorClub #39 (Taped): Willow Nightingale defeated Diamante, Kiera Hogan and Trish Adora in a 4 corners survival match.
- December 5, 2023 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Mercedes Martinez w Diamante.
- December 16, 2023 – AEW Collision: Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale defeated Diamante and Mercedes Martinez.
- December 30, 2023 – AEW Worlds End – Zero Hour: Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Statlander. Stokely Hathaway was on commentary.
- January 5, 2024 – AEW Rampage #126 (Taped): Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale defeated Kennedi Hardcastle and Notorious Mimi.
- January 5, 2024 – Prestige: Willow Nightingale defeated Sandra Moone.
- January 10, 2024 – AEW Dynamite – Homecoming #223: Anna Jay, Kris Statlander, Thunder Rosa and Willow Nightingale defeated Julia Hart, The Outcasts (Ruby Soho & Saraya) and Skye Blue.
- February 2, 2024 – AEW Rampage #130 (Taped): Willow Nightingale w Kris Statlander & Stokely Hathaway defeated Queen Aminata.
- February 9, 2024 – AEW Rampage #131 (Taped): Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale defeated The Outcasts (Ruby Soho and Saraya).
- February 14, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #228: Willow Nightingale defeated Skye Blue.
- February 28, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #230: Skye Blue w Julia Hart defeated Kris Statlander w Stokely Hathaway & Willow Nightingale.
- March 3, 2024 – AEW Revolution – Zero Hour: Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale w Stokely Hathaway defeated Julia Hart and Skye Blue.
- March 8, 2024 – Beyond Shamrock Slam: Rex Lawless and Willow Nightingale defeated Bronson and Gabby Forza.
- March 13, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #232 – Big Business: Willow Nightingale defeated Riho.
- March 20, 2024 – AEW Rampage #137 (Taped): Julia Hart and Skye Blue defeated Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale in a street fight.
- March 27, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #234: Willow Nightingale defeated Anna Jay, Kris Statlander and Skye Blue in a 4-way match to become #1 contender for the TBS title.
- March 30, 2024 – CMLL: La Catalina, Lluvia and Marcela defeated Dark Silueta, Tessa Blanchard and Willow Nightingale.
- March 31, 2024 – CMLL: Persephone, Tessa Blanchard and Willow Nightingale defeated Andromeda, Marcela and Skadi.
- April 4, 2024 – Stardom – American Dream: SAKI and Willow Nightingale defeated Konami and Syuri.
- April 17, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #237: House Of Black (Brody King and Julia Hart) defeated Adam Copeland and Willow Nightingale by referee’s decision.
- April 21, 2024 – AEW Dynasty: Willow Nightingale defeated Julia Hart to win the TBS title.
- April 24, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #238: Willow Nightingale CELEBRATES becoming the NEW TBS Champion… Enter MONÉ!
- May 1, 2024 – AEW Rampage #143: Willow Nightingale defeated Skye Blue to retain the TBS title.
- May 15, 2024 – AEW Dynamite: Mercedes Moné and Willow signs their contracts.
- May 18, 2024 – Stardom: Willow Nightingale defeated Tam Nakano to retain the TBS title.
- May 24, 2024 – AEW Rampage #146: Kris Statlander and Willow Nightingale w Stokely Hathaway defeated Alex Windsor and Anna Jay.
- May 25, 2024 – AEW Collision: TBS Champion Willow Nightingale has something to prove at Double or Nothing.
- May 26, 2024 – AEW Double or Nothing: Mercedes Moné defeated Willow Nightingale to win the TBS title.
- June 16, 2024 – Enjoy: Willow Nightingale defeated Billy Dixon.
- June 21, 2024 – AEW Rampage #150: Willow Nightingale defeated Serena Deeb in the quarter-finals.
- June 30, 2024 – AEW/NJPW Forbidden Door – Zero Hour: Tam Nakano and Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Statlander and Momo Watanabe.
- July 3, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #248 – Beach Break: Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Statlander w Stokely in the semi-finals.
- July 10, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #249: Mariah May defeated Willow Nightingale to win the Owen Hart tournament and becoming #1 contender for the women’s world title.
- July 13, 2024 – NJPW/CMLL: Willow Nightingale defeated Lluvia and Viva Van in a 3-way match to win the vacant CMLL world women’s title.
- July 24, 2024 – AEW Dynamite: Kris Statlander attacks Willow backstage and says she is coming after her belt.
- July 25, 2024 – AEW x Adult Swim Battle For The Booty: Orange Cassidy and Willow Nightingale defeated Johnny TV and Taya Valkyrie
- July 26, 2024 – AEW x Adult Swim Battle For The Booty: Orange Cassidy and Willow Nightingale defeated Mr. Frog and Rachel (Sandra Moone).
- July 27, 2024 – AEW Battle of the Belts XI: Willow Nightingale defeated Deonna Purrazzo in a title eliminator match to retain the CMLL world women’s title.
- July 31, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #252: Kris Statlander w Stokely Hathaway defeated Willow Nightingale in a non-title eliminator match of the CMLL world women’s title.
- August 24, 2024 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Harley Cameron.
- August 25, 2024 – AEW All In – Zero Hour: Tomohiro Ishii and Willow Nightingale defeated Kris Statlander and Stokely Hathaway.
- September 6, 2024 – AEW Rampage: Before their Street Fight, Willow Nightingale & Kris Statlander sit down w/ Renee Paquette.
- September 7, 2024 – AEW All Out: Kris Statlander w Stokely Hathaway defeated Willow Nightingale in a street fight.
- September 13, 2024 – CMLL: Zeuxis defeated Willow Nightingale to win the world women’s title.
- September 27, 2024 – AEW Rampage #164: Willow Nightingale defeated Taya Valkyrie.
- October 5, 2024 – AEW Collision: Willow Nightingale defeated Trish Adora.
- October 8, 2024 – AEW Dynamite #262 – Title Tuesday: Willow Nightingale defeated Jamie Hayter, Nyla Rose and Saraya in a 4-way match to become #1 contender for the women’s world title.
- October 12, 2024 – AEW WrestleDream: Mariah May defeated Willow Nightingale to retain the women’s world title.