Title History
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Necro Butcher defeating Nick Gage & Justice Pain (July 9, 2005);
- IWA Mid South World Heavyweight title defeating Trik Davis (June 17, 2006);
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Iron Man title defeating D.J. Hyde (May 12, 2007);
- ASWA heavyweight title defeating Charles Ghannicus (December 5, 2015);
Career Highlights
- June 25, 2004–IWA Mid South King of the Death Match: Toby Klein beat Necro Butcher in a “fans bring the weapons” match..
- July 31, 2004–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Mad Man Pondo in a Barbed Wire Tables match..
- August 21, 2004–IWA Mid South: Mad Man Pondo beat Toby Klein in a Death Match including a $1 bill stapled to Pondo’s nose..
- March 12, 2005 – CZW: Toby Klein defeated Necro Butcher in a “Falls Count Anywhere” match..
- April 9, 2005–SCCW: Toby Klein defeated Homeless Jimmy in death match..
- May 14, 2005 – CZW: The H8 Club (Nick Gage & Justice Pain) defeated DJ Hyde & Toby Klein to retain the Tag Team titles..
- June 11, 2005–IWA Mid South: Axl & Ian Rotten & Nate Webb defeated JC Bailey & Mad Man Pondo & Toby Klein..
- June 11, 2005 – CZW: H8 Club (Justice Pain & Nick Gage) defeated Toby Klein & Necro Butcher in a Falls Count Anywhere match..
- July 9, 2005 – CZW: Necro Butcher & Toby Klein defeated Justice Pain & Nick Gage to win the Tag Team titles!
- July 26, 2005–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein participated in the King of the Death Match Tournament..
- ~~~ROUND #1: Toby Klein defeated J.C. Bailey (sub for Mad Man Pondo) in an “Electrified Lighttubes” match..
- ~~~SEMIFINALS: Toby Klein defeated Tank (from NWA Anarchy) in a “Fans Bring the Weapons” match..
- ~~~FINALS: Corporal Robinson defeated Toby Klein in a “House of Pain Glass Deathmatch” to win the Tournament!
- July 30, 2005 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Toby Klein participated in the 2005 CZW Tournament of Death..
- ~~~Toby Klein beat Mad Man Pondo (Light Tubes Match) | John Zandig beat Toby Klein (2/3 Falls Light Tube Log Cabin Match)..
- Summer 2005: Toby Klein made his debut in Japan teaming with Mad Man Pondo..
- September 10, 2005 – CZW: Chris Hero & Claudio Castagnoli defeated Necro Butcher & Toby Klein to win the Tag Team titles!
- November 12, 2005 – CZW: Tough Crazy Bastards beat Nick Gage & J.C. Bailey (sub for Justice Pain) in a Shattered Dreams match..
- ~~~After the match, John Zandig turned on the Tough Crazy Bastards and joined the H8 Club (Nick Gage & Justice Pain)..
- November 15, 2005–IWA East Coast: Mad Man Pondo & Ian Rotten defeated Necro Butcher & Toby Klein..
- December 10, 2005 – CZW: The H8 Club & John Zandig defeated Necro Butcher & Toby Klein & Joker in a Cage of Death match!
- March 10, 2006–Insane Wrestling Federation: Necro Butcher defeated “Mr. Insanity” Toby Klein..
- March 18, 2006–IWA-Mid South: “Mr. Insanity” Toby Klein defeated Jigsaw..
- April 1, 2005–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Tank..
- June 2, 2006–IWA Mid South (King of the Death Match): Toby Klein defeated Jacob Ladder in a Taipei Death Match..
- June 3, 2006–IWA Mid South (King of the Death Match): Toby Klein beat Brandon Prophet in a 2/3 Falls Log Cabins Match
- ~~~~~~~Toby Klein defeated Corporal Robinson in a Barbed Wire Ropes/Fans Bring the Weapons Match in the 3rd Round..
- ~~~Mitch Page beat Toby Klein and Brain Damage and Dysfunction in a 4-WAY House of Pain Total Elimination Finals..
- June 16, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Brandon Thomaselli | Toby Klein won a #1 Contenders Battle Royal..
- June 17, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Trik Davis to win the IWA-MS World Heavyweight title!!
- July 14, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein beat Bull Pain & Ian Rotten & Mitch Page & Brandon Prophet & Insane Lane in a 6-WAY!
- July 15, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Deranged to retain the IWA-MS World title..
- July 29, 2006 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Toby Klein participated in the 9th Annual Tournament of Death in Smyrna, Delaware..
- ~~~Brain Damage defeated Necro Butcher and Toby Klein (eliminated) in a Fans Bring The Weapons Death Match..
- August 11, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein vs Arik Cannon ended in a Double Countout for the IWA-MS World title..
- August 12, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein vs Bull Pain ended in a No Contest in a Street Fight to retain the IWA-MS title..
- September 1, 2006–IWA Mid South Wrestling: Toby Klein & Drake Younger defeated Mickie Knuckles & Ryan Ash..
- September 9, 2006 – CZW: Toby Klein beat Necro Butcher & Deranged & Danny Havoc & Drake Younger in a 5-WAY Tables match..
- September 15, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein & Deranged & Corporal Robinson defeated Bull Pain & Cash Flo & Mitch Page..
- September 30, 2006–IWA Mid South: Chuck Taylor defeated Toby Klein to win the IWA-Mid South World Heavyweight title..
- October 14, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Mitch Page (substituting for Bull Pain) in a Steel Cage Match..
- October 21, 2006–IWA MS: Tough Crazy Bastards (Toby Klein/Necro Butcher) beat Bad Mother F*ckers (Bull Pain/Mitch Page)..
- November 4, 2006–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein & Necro Butcher entered the IWA-MS Tag Team Death Match Tournament..
- ~~~The Tough Crazy Bastards (Toby Klein & Necro Butcher) defeated Hugh Rouge & Chewie Martinez in a Death Match..
- ~~~The Tough Crazy Bastards (Toby Klein & Necro Butcher) beat Ian Rotten & Drake Younger to advance to the Finals..
- ~~~Mad Man Pondo & 2 Tuff Tony defeated Toby Klein & Necro Butcher to win the 2006 Tag Team Death Match Tournament..
- January 13, 2007 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Toby Klein defeated Necro Butcher in a match ordered by Commissioner Maven Bentley..
- January 27, 2007–IWA Mid South: Ian Rotten & Mickie Knuckles beat Two Crazy Bastards (Toby Klein & Necro Butcher)..
- February 10, 2007–Combat Zone Wrestling: Toby Klein defeated Maven Bentley & Mitch Ryder to win back Necro Butcher’s job..
- March 10, 2007–CZW: John Zandig & Toby Klein defeated Mitch Ryder & D.J. Hyde in a No Rope Barbed Wire match..
- April 7, 2007–CZW: D.J. Hyde w/Maven Bentley defeated Toby Klein to retain the CZW Iron Man title..
- May 4, 2007–Mega Championship Wrestling: Killer Chris Kole defeated Toby Klein to retain the MCW United States title..
- May 12, 2007–Combat Zone Wrestling: Toby Klein defeated D.J. Hyde to win the CZW Iron Man title..
- June 9, 2007–CZW: Brain Damage defeated Toby Klein in a “Fans Bring the Weapons and Barbed Wire Boards” match..
- June 30, 2007–IWA Mid South Wrestling: The Strong Style Thugs (Homicide & Low-Ki) defeated Toby Klein & Necro Butcher..
- July 14, 2007–Combat Zone Wrestling: Mitch Ryder & Brain Damage & D.J. Hyde beat Necro Butcher & Toby Klein & Danny Havoc..
- August 4, 2007–IWA Mid South: Roderick Strong defeated Toby Klein in Plainfield, Indiana..
- August 5, 2007–IWA Mid South: Toby Klein defeated Deranged in Sellersburg, Indiana..
- August 11, 2007–CZW: Toby Klein beat Freakshow and Insane Lane in a 3-WAY 4-Corners of Pain match to retain the Iron Man title..
- September 8, 2007–Combat Zone Wrestling: D.J. Hyde defeated Toby Klein in a Dog Collar Match to win the CZW Iron Man Title..
- October 13, 2007–CZW: D.J. Hyde & Brain Damage defeated Necro Butcher & Toby Klein in a bloodbath..
- November 10, 2007–CZW: Brain Damage defeated Toby Klein to retain the CZW Ultraviolent Underground title..
- December 8, 2007–Combat Zone Wrestling: Danny Havoc was the one and only Survivor in a spectacular Cage of Death match..
- ~~~Necro Butcher & Toby Klein & Drake Younger & Danny Havoc beat Brain Damage & DJ Hyde & Dustin Lee & Scotty Vortekz..
- August 2, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Insane Lane defeated Toby Klein.
- August 6, 2008–IWA East Coast: Viper defeated Toby Klein.
- September 13, 2008–CZW: Brain Damage defeated Toby Klein. Brain Damage & Danny Havoc defeat Two Hollywood Bastards (Necro Butcher & Toby Klein).
- September 27, 2008–IWF: Toby Klein defeated Sonny Scarboni.
- October 4, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Corporal Robinson & Ian Bloody defeated Cult Fiction (Deranged & Toby Klein).
- October 18, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Vulgar Display Of Power (Brain Damage & Deranged) defeated The Tough Crazy Bastards (Necro Butcher & Toby Klein) in the 1st round.
- October 19, 2008–XICW: XICW Xtreme champion Necro Butcher defeated Corporal Robinson, The DBA and Toby Klein in a 4-way match to retain.
- November 29, 2008–IWA East Coast: Danny Havoc defeated Toby Klein in the 1st round.
- February 22, 2009–XICW: XICW Xtreme champion Necro Butcher defeated Toby Klein in a street fight to retain the title.
- March 14, 2009–CZW: Mad Man Pondo & The H8 Club (Nate Hatred & Nick Gage) defeated Cult Fiction (Brain Damage, Deranged & Toby Klein).
- March 22, 2009–IWA East Coast: Toby Klein defeated Thumbtack Jack.
- March 27, 2009–CHIKARA: Team FIST (Chuck Taylor, Gran Akuma & Icarus) defeated The Death Match Kings (Brain Damage, Necro Butcher & Toby Klein) in the 1st round.
- April 11, 2009–CZW: John Dahmer defeated Toby Klein.
- May 16, 2009–MCW: Brain Damage & Shasta defeated Chris Cole & Toby Klein.
- June 6, 2009–CZW: WHACKS defeated Toby Klein in the 1st round.
- July 12, 2009–XICW: XICW midwest heavyweight champion Jaimy Coxxx defeated Toby Klein to retain the title.
- August 9, 2009–XICW: Toby Klein defeated Josh Raymond.
- August 29, 2009–MCPW: GQ Status & Jebediah defeated Christian Vaughn & Toby Klein.
- October 17, 2009–MCW: Brain Damage & Shasta vs. Christian Vaughn & Toby Klein ended in a no contest.
- October 19, 2009–XICW: Necro Butcher beat Toby Klein and DBA and Corporal Robinson in a 4-WAY in Warren, Michigan..
- October 18, 2009–XICW: Mo Dread defeated Toby Klein.
- November 21, 2009–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Elkview Adam in the 1st round. Toby Klein defeated The Juggulator in the semi-finals. Toby Klein defeated David Day to win the tournament.
- December 19, 2009–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Supa Lucha.
- January 2, 2010–MCW: Shasta and Wilbur Whitlock defeated Jebediah and Toby Klein.
- January 17, 2010–MCW: Christian Vaughn vs. Jebediah vs. Toby Klein vs. Wilbur Whitlock in a 4-way ladder match ended in a no contest.
- February 6, 2010–MCW: Christian Vaughn defeated Toby Klein.
- February 20, 2010–MCW: Christian Vaughn defeated Toby Klein to win the heavyweight title in a anything goes match.
- March 6, 2010–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Matt Cross.
- March 20, 2010–MCW: Chris Kole vs. Toby Klein ended in a no contest.
- April 3, 2010–MCW: Jebediah defeated Toby Klein.
- April 9, 2010–AIW: Team No Mercy (Chris Dickinson, Toby Klein and Tommy Mercer) defeated Team IWA EC (Jon Moxley, Mad Man Pondo and Zac Vincent) in the 1st round.
- April 10, 2010–AIW: The Young Studs (Bobby Beverly, Eric Ryan and TJ Dynamite) defeated Team No Mercy (Chris Dickinson, Toby Klein and Tommy Mercer).
- April 16, 2010–CAPW: CAPW heavyweight champion Mitch Ryder defeated Toby Klein to retain the title.
- April 17, 2010–MCW: Krazy, Larry Lavender and Toby Klein defeated Big Hurt, Jebediah and Mike Hercum.
- May 1, 2010–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Chris Kole.
- May 2, 2010–Deaf Wrestlefest: UCW heavyweight champion Bulldozer defeated Toby Klein to retain the title.
- May 14, 2010–CAPW: Shawn Blaze defeated Ryker, Sheik Abdul Hassan and Toby Cline in a 4-way match to win the CAPW title.
- May 15, 2010–OHW: Elkview Adam defeated Super Oprah and Toby Klein in a 3-way match.
- May 24, 2010–JCW: Toby Klein won a #1 contenders battle royal for the heavyweight title. JCW heavyweight champion Mad Man Pondo defeated Toby Klein to retain the title.
- May 29, 2010–MCW: Toby Klein vs. Jebediah ended in a double count-out.
- June 5, 2010–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Big Hurt by disqualification.
- June 19, 2010–MCW: Jebediah vs. Toby Klein ended in a no contest.
- July 3, 2010–MCW: Krazy and Toby Klein defeated Christian Vaughn and Big Hurt.
- July 31, 2010–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Jebediah in a I Quit match.
- September 5, 2010–MCW: Scott Steiner defeated Toby Klein.
- September 18, 2010–B@M!! – A Tribute To JC Bailey: Sami Callihan defeated Toby Klein.
- January 11, 2011–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Bobby Beverly.
- March 19, 2011–MCW: Al Snow defeated Toby Klein.
- April 16, 2011–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Chiyudo Ropa.
- May 21, 2011–MCW: MCW Elite champion Larry Lavender defeated Toby Klein to retain the title.
- June 4, 2011–MCW: MCW Elite champion Larry Lavender defeated Toby Klein to retain the title.
- July 2, 2011–MCW: Jebediah defeated Toby Klein.
- July 16, 2011–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Ian Decay.
- August 28, 2011–MCW: Necro Butcher defeated Toby Klein.
- September 10, 2011–APWA: TJ Phillips and Chance Prophet vs. Toby Klein and Viper ended in a no contest.
- September 25, 2011–AIW/Firestorm Pro/MCW The JT Lightning Memorial Show: Ian Decay defeated Mr. Insanity in a hardcore as hell match.
- October 1, 2011–MCW: Big Hurt defeated Toby Klein.
- October 29, 2011–APWA: Viper defeated Bildo, Necro Butcher and Toby Klein in a 4-way match to win the vacant hardcore cup.
- November 5, 2011–MCW: Toby Klein defeated Bill Martel.
- November 18, 2011–MCW: Scott Steiner defeated Toby Klein.
- October 13, 2012–ASWA: Vladik Vornoff defeated Toby Cline.
- November 10, 2012–CZW: Toby Klein defeated Danny Havoc. CZW tag team champions Bandido Jr. and Azrieal defeated Toby Klein and Human Tornado & Ruckus and BLK Jeez in a 3-way tag team match to retain the titles.
- May 5, 2013–XICW: The DBA defeated Mr. Insanity and Sabu in a 3-way match, where the fans brings the weapons.
- June 9, 2013–XICW: The DBA defeated Chaz Montana and Dickie Bronson and Eddie Venom and Jaimy Coxxx and Josh Movado and Mr. Insanity and The BU F’N G to win the Malcolm Monroe Sr. Cup.
- July 21, 2013–XICW: XICW Midwest heavyweight champion Rhino defeated Jimmy Jacobs and Mr. Insanity in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- April 12, 2014–IWR: Brimstone, Jay The Cable Guy, Josh Movado & Mr. Insanity defeated Anthony Rivera, Breyer Wellington, N8 Mattson & Truth Martini. Brimstone defeated Jay The Cable Guy and Mr. Insanity in a 3-way match.
- August 8, 2015–ASWA: Toby Cline defeated Izzy Lambert.
- October 9, 2015–IWA Mid-South: Insane Lane defeated Toby Klein.
- October 10, 2015–ASWA: ASWA heavyweight champion Charles Ghannicus defeated Toby Cline to retain the title.
- December 5, 2015–ASWA: Toby Cline defeated Charles Ghannicus to win the ASWA heavyweight title in a extreme rules match.