Title History
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) World Heavyweight title defeating ????? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) World Heavyweight title defeating ????? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Interpromotional Hardcore title defeating ???? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Zandig defeating ???? & ???? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Nate Hatred defeating ???? & ???? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Nate Hatred defeating ???? & ???? ();
- IPW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Justice Pain defeating ???? & ???? ();
- Big Japan Tag Team titles w/Zandig defeating ???? & ???? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Iron Man title defeating ???? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Iron Man title defeating ???? ();
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Tag Team titles w/Justin Pain defeating Nate Webb & Chri$ Ca$h (February 5, 2005);
- CZW UltraViolent Underground title defeating Necro Butcher and JC Bailey (January 14, 2005);
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) World Heavyweight title defeating Ruckus and The Messiah in a 3-WAY (December 8, 2007);
- CZW (Combat Zone Wrestling) Heavyweight title defeating Nick Gage (c) and Drake Younger (August 7, 2010);
- JAPW tag team titles w/Necro Butcher defeating Mafia and Monsta Mack (December 11, 2010);
- AIW Absolute title defeating Tim Donst (November 24, 2017);
- IWA Mid-South heavyweight title winning a 3-way match in a 2nd round match of a tournament (May 19, 2018);
- ICW heavyweight title defeating Orin Veidt (June 9, 2019);
- OPW title defeating Kit Osbourne (September 7, 2019);
- GCW World title defeating Rickey Shane Page (April 9, 2021);
- GCW tag team titles w Matt Tremont defeating The Briscoes (March 31, 2022);
- GCW World title defeating Jon Moxley in a title vs career match (October 8, 2022);
Career Highlights
- Nick Gage was the first ever CZW World Champion..
- Nick Gage was one half of the H8 Club with Nate Hatred, the most dominant tag team in CZW history..
1999-2000:
- February 13, 1999 – CZW: Justice Pain defeated Nick Gage, Derek Domino and TCK in a 4-way match.
- March 27, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage won a 20 man battle royal to win the vacant heavyweight title. CZW heavyweight champion Nick Gage defeated Lobo to retain the title.
- April 3, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Ric Blade.
- April 24, 1999 – CZW: Lobo and Zandig defeated Nick Gage and Justice Pain.
- May 15, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Justice Pain to win the vacant interpromotional hardcore title.
- May 22, 1999 – CZW: Zandig defeated John Kronus, Justice Pain and Nick Gage in a 4-way match to win the heavyweight title.
- May 29, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Billy Baja.
- June 19, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Zandig to win the heavyweight title.
- July 19, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage vs. Zandig ended in a no contest.
- July 24, 1999 – CZW: Nick Gage and Zandig defeated John Dahmer and Lobo to win the tag team titles.
- August 21, 1999 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Zandig defeated Lobo and Ric Blade to retain the titles.
- September 18, 1999 – CZW: Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage to win the heavyweight title.
- September 25, 1999 – CZW: Ric Blade defeated Nick Gage.
- October 9, 1999 – CZW: Lobo and TCK defeated Nick Gage and Justice Pain, Johnny Kashmere and Robby Mireno & Diablos Macabre and Middknight in a 4-way tag match to win the tag team titles.
- October 16, 1999 – CZW: Lobo vs. Nick Gage ended in a no contest.
- January 8, 2000 – CZW: Justice Pain, Diablos Macabre and Middknight defeated Nick Gage, Lobo and TCK.
- February 5, 2000 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Justice Pain defeated Nick Gage to retain the title.
- February 11, 2000 – CZW: Justice Pain and Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage and TCK.
- March 11, 2000 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Justice Pain.
- April 1, 2000 – CZW: Justice Pain and Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage and Ric Blade.
- April 5, 2000 – BJW: Justice Pain, Nick Gage and Wifebeater defeated Jun Kasai, Ryuji Yamakawa and Tomoaki Honma in a CZW vs. BJW tag team match.
- April 8, 2000 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated TCK in a anything goes match.
- May 6, 2000 – CZW: CZW Interpromotional hardcore champion Lobo defeated Nick Gage to retain the title.
- June 10, 2000 – CZW: Justice Pain and Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage and Zandig to win the BJW tag team titles. Nick Gage defeated Nick Berk in a tables match.
- June 25, 2000 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Wifebeater.
- July 22, 2000 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Wifebeater to win the CZW Iron Man title.
- August 8, 2000 – BJW: Nick Gage and Zandig defeated Jun Kasai and Mitsuhiro Matsunaga.
- August 12, 2000 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Nick Gage vs. Mad Man Pondo ended in a no contest to retain the title.
- September 9, 2000 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Nick Gage defeated Wifebeater and Mad Man Pondo in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- October 11, 2000 – CZW: Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage and Mad Man Pondo in a 3-way match to win the CZW Iron Man title.
- November 11, 2000 – CZW: Johnny Kashmere and Lobo defeated Nick Gage and Trent Acid. Nick Gage defeated Johnny Kashmere.
2001-2002:
- January 20, 2001 – CZW: Lobo and Nick Gage defeated Johnny Kashmere and Z-Barr.
- February 17, 2001 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Lobo defeated Nick Gage to retain the title.
- February 28, 2001 – CZW: Lobo and Ric Blade defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred.
- March 10, 2001 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Lobo defeated Nick Gage to retain the title.
- March 17, 2001 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Ric Blade and Ruckus.
- April 4, 2001 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Justice Pain and Wifebeater to win the tag team titles.
- April 7, 2001 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Justice Pain and Wifebeater to retain the titles.
- April 14, 2001 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Eddie Valentine and John Dahmer to retain the titles.
- May 19, 2001 – CZW: Justice Pain, Lobo and Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage, Nate Hatred and Nick Mondo.
- June 8, 2001 – CZW: Justice Pain defeated Nick Gage, Lobo and Ric Blade in a 4-way #1 contenders match for the world heavyweight title.
- June 9, 2001 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated The Briscoe Brothers to retain the titles.
- July 7, 2001 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated The Briscoe Brothers to retain the titles.
- July 14, 2001 – CZW: The Briscoe Brothers defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred to win the tag team titles.
- July 28, 2001 – CZW: Reckless Youth defeated Hurricane Kid, Minoru Fujita, Nick Gage and Towel Boy in a 5-way match. Nick Gage defeated Nick Mondo to win the Iron Man title.
- August 11, 2001 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Nick Gage defeated Nick Mondo to retain the title.
- August 18, 2001 – CZW: CZW Iron Man champion Nick Gage defeated Nick Berk and Nick Mondo in a 3-way tag match to retain the titles.
- September 8, 2001 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Nick Mondo and Zandig.
- September 29, 2001 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred vs. Nick Mondo and Z-Barr ended in a no contest.
- October 27, 2001 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Jay Briscoe.
- November 10, 2001 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Johnny Kashmere and Trent Acid defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred & Mark Briscoe and The Amazing Red in a 3-way tag team match.
- December 15, 2001 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred Kenny and Keno Murdoch.
- January 12, 2002 – CZW: Eddie Valentine and John Dahmer defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred & The Briscoe Brothers in a 3-way tag match.
- February 9, 2002 – CZW: CZW world heavyweight champion Justice Pain defeated Nick Gage to retain the title.
- April 13, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Johnny Kashmere and Trent Acid.
- April 27, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Johnny Kashmere and Steve Rivez.
- May 11, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Eddie Valentine and John Dahmer to retain the titles.
- June 8, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage participated in a battle royal to become #1 contender for the CZW Iron Man title won by Justice Pain.
- July 13, 2002 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Chris Cash and GQ to retain the titles.
- August 10, 2002 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Adam Flash and Bunny Rose to retain the titles.
- August 31, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Toby Klein in the 1st round. Wifebeater defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- September 6, 2002 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Rockin Rebel’ and Justice Pain to retain the titles.
- September 14, 2002 – CZW: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred vs. Azrael and Gabriel ended in a no contest to retain the titles.
- September 27, 2002 – Hardway Wrestling TV: CZW tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Nick Berk and Ruckus & Chris Cash and GQ in a 3-way tag match to retain the titles.
- September 28, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Justice Pain.
- October 12, 2002 – CZW: CZW world heavyweight champion Justice Pain vs. Nick Gage ended in a no contest to retain the title.
- October 26, 2002 – CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Johnny Kashmere and Trent Acid.
- November 9, 2002 – CZW: Justice Pain and The Messiah defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred.
- December 14, 2002 – CZW: CZW world tag team champions Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated B-Boy and Chris Hero to retain the titles.
- December 28, 2002 – CZW: CZW world heavyweight champion The Messiah defeated Nick Gage and Justice Pain in a 3-way match to retain the title.
2003:
- January 18, 2003 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Messiah defeats Nick Gage to retain the CZW title..
- March 8, 2003 – CZW: H8 Club (Gage/Hatred) defeats B-Boy & Messiah..
- April 12, 2003 – CZW: Messiah defeats Nick Gage to retain the CZW title..
- June 14, 2003 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Nate Hatred & The Messiah in a 3way Cage Match to win the Deathmatch title!
- July 20, 2003 – CZW: Nick Cage defeated Nate Hatred to retain the Big Japan Deathmatch title..
- August 1, 2003 – IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Dysfunction in the 1st round.
- August 2, 2003 – IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Mean Mitch Page in the quarter-finals. Mad Man Pondo defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- August 9, 2003 – CZW Aftermath: Nate Hatred defeated Nick Gage in a “Tables” match!
- August 23, 2003 – CZW: Nate Hatred beat Nick Cage in a “Light Tube” match to retain the BJPW Deathmatch title..
- September 13, 2003 – CZW Redesigned: Nick Cage beat Sonjay Dutt in the 1st round. Nick Gage defeated Greg Matthews in the 2nd round. Trent Acid defeated Nick Gage to win the tournament..
- September 19, 2003 – Zero-1: Hirotaka Yokoi & Kohei Sato vs. Nick Gage & Zandig ended in a double count-out.
- September 20, 2003 – Zero-1: Emblem (Masato Tanaka & Shinjiro Otani) & Hideki Hosaka defeated Homicide, Nick Gage & Zandig.
- September 21, 2003 – Zero-1: Nick Gage & Zandig defeated Jun Kasai & Kazuhiko Ogasawara.
- October 4, 2003 – CZW: Trent Acid (dressed as Triple H) defeated Nick Gage with help from Nate Hatred..
- October 11, 2003 – CZW: Nate Hatred defeated Nick Gage in a bloody “dog collar” match with help from The Messiah..
- ~~~Hi-V issued a beatdown onto Nick Gage until the CZW-legend Wifebeater made a return to make the big save!
- October 25, 2003 – CZW Italy: Nick Gage defeated Nate Hatred in a tables match..
- November 15, 2003 – CZW: Messiah & Nate Hatred vs Wifebeater & Nick Gage was a No Contest in a “Double Dog Collar” match..
- December 13, 2003 – CZW: Nick Gage & Team Ultraviolent defeated Team Hi-V in a vicious Cage of Death V elimination match!
- ~~~Nick Gage was the sole survivor when Nate Hatred turned on Hi-V and reformed the H8 Club with Nick Gage!!
- December 27, 2003 – ROH Afternoon Showcase: Hydro defeated Oman Turtuga, Slyk Wagner Brown & Nick Gage in a 4-way match..
2004:
- January 16, 2004 – CZW: Ian Knoxx & Nick Gage & Nate Hatred defeated The Messiah & B-Boy & Adam Flash..
- January 17, 2004 – CZW: The H8 Club (Nate Hatred & Nick Gage) defeated Adam Flash & The Messiah..
- February 7, 2004 – CZW: The H8 Club (Nate Hatred & Nick Gage) defeated Homicide & Dan Maff..
- March 6, 2004 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Roderick Strong in an “Xtreme Strong Style Tournament” match..
- March 27, 2004 – CZW Italy: The H8 Club defeated Poach & Red Devil and Beef Company and Long & Thick..
- April 3, 2004 – CZW: The H8 Club defeated Rebels Army (Rebel/Matthews) to capture the CZW Tag Team titles..
- May 1, 2004 – CZW: The Messiah & Sabu & Adam Flash defeated Nick Gage & Trent Acid & Wifebeater..
- June 12, 2004 – CZW: The Blackout (Ruckus & Sabian) defeated the H8 Club to capture the CZW Tag Team titles..
- July 10, 2004 – CZW BotB 4: Dan Maff defeated Nick Gage in a Xtreme Strong Style Tournament Match..
- July 24, 2004 – CZW ToD 3: Nick Gage defeated Ruckus (sub for Zandig) in a “Barbed Wire Board” match..
- ~~~Round #2: Necro Butcher defeated Nick Gage in a “Panes of Glass” match (Tournament of Death)..
- August 14, 2004 – CZW: The Blackout (Ruckus & Sabian & King) defeated Nate Hatred & Nick Gage & Chri$ Ca$h..
- September 11, 2004 – CZW Night Show: Blackout (Ruckus/Sabian) vs The H8 Club (Gage/Hatred) in a Cage was a no contest..
- September 25, 2014 – PWU: Greg Matthews and Rockin’ Rebel defeated Nick Gage and Ian Knoxxx.
- November 14, 2004 – CZW: Nick Gage (replacing Homicide) defeated Justice Pain..
- December 11, 2004 – CZW: Wifebeater & Justice Pain defeated Nate Hatred & Nick Gage in the CAGE OF DEATH..
- ~~~Nick Gage turned on Nate Hatred, and Justice Pain turned on Wifebeater, uniting REAL LIFE brothers Gage & Pain..
2005:
- January 8, 2005 – CZW: Nick Gage & Justice Pain defeated El Generico & Beef Wellington..
- February 5, 2005 – CZW: H8 Club (Nick Gage & Justice Pain) defeated Nate Webb & Chri$ Ca$h to win the Tag Team titles!
- March 12, 2005 – CZW: H8 Club (Justice Pain & Nick Gage) defeated 2 Tuff Tony & Madman Pondo to retain the Tag titles..
- April 2, 2005 – CZW: The H8 Club (Nick Gage & Justice Pain) defeated Jon Dahmer & DJ Hyde to retain the Tag Team titles..
- May 14, 2005 – CZW: The H8 Club (Nick Gage & Justice Pain) defeated DJ Hyde & Toby Klein to retain the Tag Team titles..
- June 11, 2005 – CZW: H8 Club (Justice Pain & Nick Gage) defeated Toby Klein & Necro Butcher in a Falls Count Anywhere match..
- July 9, 2005 – CZW: Necro Butcher & Toby Klein defeated Justice Pain & Nick Gage to win the Tag Team titles!
- July 30, 2005 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Nick Gage participated in the 2005 CZW Tournament of Death..
- ~~~Nick Gage beat Nate Webb (Light Tubes & Ladder match) | Nick Gage beat JC Bailey (Pain of Glass match)..
- ~~~FINALS: Necro Butcher defeated Zandig and Nick Gage in a 3-WAY to win the Tournament of Death Trophy!
- September 10, 2005 – CZW: Justice Pain & Nick Gage defeated Nate Hatred & The Messiah in a Fans Bring Weapons match..
- October 8, 2005 – CZW: Ruckus defeated Nick Gage to retain the CZW World title..
- November 12, 2005 – CZW: Tough Crazy Bastards beat Nick Gage & J.C. Bailey (sub for Justice Pain) in a Shattered Dreams match..
- ~~~After the match, John Zandig turned on the Tough Crazy Bastards and joined the H8 Club (Nick Gage & Justice Pain)..
- November 18, 2005 – CZW: Mad Man Pondo & Nick Gage defeated The Hellaware Assassin in a 3-way match.
- November 19, 2005 – CZW: Bull Pain defeated Nick Gage in the quarter-finals.
- December 10, 2005 – CZW: The H8 Club & John Zandig defeated Necro Butcher & Toby Klein & Joker in a Cage of Death match!
2006:
- January 14, 2006 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated J.C Bailey and Necro Butcher in a Barbed Wire match to win the Ultraviolent title!
- February 11, 2006 – CZW: The H8 Club & Larry Sweeney defeated Sexxxy Eddy & Viking & Excalibur..
- March 11, 2006 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Nick Gage beat D.J. Hyde and Danny Havoc in a “Panes of Glass” match..
- April 15, 2006 – CZW: Ruckus/Sabian/Joker/Kingston defeated Nick Gage/Justice Pain/Christopher Bishop/Lionel Knight.
- May 13, 2006 – CZW: H8 Club (Justice Pain & Nick Gage) defeated Christopher Bishop & Lionel Knight..
- June 10, 2006 – CZW: Zandig & Lobo & The H8 Club beat Ruckus & Sabian & Joker & Eddie Kingston in a blood bath..
- July 8, 2006 – CZW: Joker & Sabian defeated Nick Gage & Justice Pain and Kevin Steen & El Generico in a 3-WAY..
- July 29, 2006 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Nick Gage participated in the 9th Annual Tournament of Death in Smyrna, Delaware..
- ~~~Brandon Prophet defeated Nick Gage and Andy Sumner (eliminated) in a Light Tube & Barbed Wire Ropes Death Match..
- ~~~Brain Damage & Nick Gage advanced over Brandon Prophet & Necro Butcher in a Barbed Wire & Panes of Glass Death match..
- ~~~FINALS: Nick Gage beat Brain Damage and Drake Younger and JC Bailey in a Light Tube Ropes & Fans Bring Weapons match..
- August 12, 2006 – CZW: The Forefathers of CZW defeated Blackout and The Canadians in an All Out War Cage match..
- The Canadians = Kevin Steen & LuFisto & Frankie The Mobster & El Generico..
- The Forefathers of CZW = Justice Pain & Nick Gage & Eddie Kingston…
- Team Blackout = Ruckus & Sabian & Joker & Robbie Minero..
- September 9, 2006 – CZW: B-Boy defeated Claudio Castagnoli and Nick Gage in a #1 Contenders match (Iron Man title)..
- October 14, 2006 – Combat Zone Wrestling: The H8 Club participated in the “Last Team Standing” Tournament!
- ~~~ROUND #1: The H8 Club (Justice Pain & Nick Gage) defeated The Dead Presidents (Lo Lincoln & Boog Washington)..
- ~~~ROUND #2: The H8 Club (Justice Pain & Nick Gage) defeated Team Andrew (????? & ?????) to advance to the Finals..
- ~~~FINALS: The Kings of Wrestling defeated H8 Club (Justice Pain & Human Tornado [sub for Nick Gage]) in the Finals..
- November 11, 2006 – Combat Zone Wrestling: Necro Butcher defeated Nick Gage and DJ Hyde in a 3-WAY Ultraviolent match!
- December 9, 2006 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated John Zandig and Lobo and LuFisto in a vicious Cage of Death match..
2007:
- January 13, 2007 – CZW: Nick Gage defeated Jude and “Towel Boy” Eric Tuttle (subs for LuFisto)..
- February 10, 2007–CZW: Justice Pain defeated Nick Gage to retain the CZW World title (Nick Gage suffered a stinger)..
- December 8, 2007–CZW: Nick Gage beat Ruckus and The Messiah in a 3-WAY to win the CZW World Heavyweight title..
2008:
- January 12, 2008–CZW: Nick Gage won a 6-WAY Ultraviolent Rules Match to retain the CZW World Heavyweight Title..
- ~~~Nick Gage defeated Danny Havoc and Ruckus and Drake Younger and Devon Moore and Eddie Kingston in a 6-WAY..
- February 9, 2008–CZW: CZW heavyweight champion Nick Gage vs. Ruckus ended in a no contest to retain the title.
- March 8, 2008–CZW: CZW heavyweight champion Nick Gage defeated Drake Younger and Ruckus in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- April 5, 2008–CZW: CZW heavyweight champion Nick Gage defeated Drake Younger to retain the title.
- May 10, 2008–CZW: CZW heavyweight champion Nick Gage defeated DJ Hyde to retain the title.
- May 17, 2008–CZW: Drake Younger and Nick Gage defeated Devon Moore and Drew Blood in the 1st round. Danny Havoc and Nick Gage defeated Greg Excellent and Pinkie Sanchez in the semi-finals. Danny Havoc defeated Nick Gage, Scotty Vortekz and Drake Younger in a 4-way elimination match to win the tournament.
- June 14, 2008–CZW: Nick Gage defeated Trent Acid. Devon Moore and Drew Blood defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred.
- June 20, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Danny Havoc defeated Nick Gage and WHACKS in a 3-way 1st round match.
- June 21, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Freak Show in the 2nd round. Devon Moore defeated Nick Gage and Dustin Lee in a 3-way semi-finals match.
- July 12, 2008–CZW: Drake Younger defeated Nick Gage to win the world heavyweight title.
- August 2, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Freak Show.
- August 9, 2008–CZW: Devon Moore defeated Nick Gage.
- August 16, 2008–IWA Mid South “Put Up or Shut Up”: Trevor Murdock defeated Nick Gage.
- August 17, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Michael Elgin to win the IWA Mid-South strong style title.
- September 13, 2008–CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Devon Moore and Drew Blood. Nick Gage, Nate Webb, Derek Frazier and B-Boy defeated Eddie Kingston, Joker, Ruckus and Sabian.
- October 4, 2008–IWA Deep South: Nick Gage defeated Devon Moore in the 1st round. Nick Gage defeated Prophet in the semi-finals. Danny Havoc defeated Corey Shaddix, Freak Show and Nick Gage in a 4-way elimination match to win the 2008 carnage cup.
- October 11, 2008–CZW: CZW tag team champions Ruckus and Sabian defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred to retain the titles.
- November 8, 2008–CZW: Brain Damage defeated Nick Gage.
- December 5, 2008–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Michael Elgin in the 1st round.
- December 13, 2008–CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Ruckus and Sabian.
2009-2010:
- January 10, 2009–CZW: Brain Damage and Deranged defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred.
- February 14, 2009–CZW: Nick Gage and Nate Hatred defeated Brain Damage and Deranged.
- March 6, 2009–IWA Mid-South: Thumbtack Jack defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- March 7, 2009–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage and Devon Moore won a 7-way team royal rumble match to become #1 contenders for the heavyweight title. IWA Mid-South heavyweight champion Dingo defeated Nick Gage and Devon Moore in a 3-way match to retain the title.
- March 14, 2009–CZW: Nick Gage, Nate Hatred and Mad Man Pondo defeated Brain Damage, Deranged and Toby Klein.
- April 11, 2009–CZW: Nick Gage defeated Deranged in a I Quit match.
- May 9, 2009–CZW: CZW tag team champions TJ Cannon and Bruce Maxwell vs. Nick Gage and Nate Hatred ended in a no contest to retain the titles.
- June 6, 2009–CZW: Nick Gage defeated Deranged in the 1st round. Nick Gage defeated Jon Moxley and Scotty Vortekz in a 3-way semi-finals match. Thumbtack Jack defeated Nick Gage to win the tournament.
- July 11, 2009–CZW: CZW tag team champions TJ Cannon and Bruce Maxwell defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred to retain the titles.
- August 8, 2009–CZW: CZW tag team champions TJ Cannon and Bruce Maxwell defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred to retain the titles.
- September 20, 2009–ALxC: Nick Gage defeated Super Oprah.
- September 26, 2009–IWA Deep South: Nick Gage defeated Freak Show and Insane Lane in a 3-way 1st round match. Thumbtack Jack defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- October 10, 2009–CZW: Nick Gage, Nate Hatred and Jon Moxley defeated DJ Hyde, xOMGX and Scotty Vortekz.
- October 25, 2009–CZW: Nick Gage defeated John Zangig in the 1st round. MASADA defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- November 14, 2009–CZW: Jon Moxley, Nate Hatred and Nick Gage defeated DJ Hyde, Drake Younger and Eddie Kingston in a tag team elimination match.
- November 21, 2009–JAPW: JAPW tag team champions Brodie Lee and Necro Butcher defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred to retain the titles.
- December 12, 2009–CZW: CZW Ultraviolent Underground champion Thumbtack Jack defeated Nick Gage to retain the title in a no ropes, barbed wired match.
- January 23, 2010–JAPW: Havok and Monsta Mack defeated Brodie Lee and Necro Butcher & Nate Hatred and Nick Gage in a 3-way tag match to win the tag titles.
- January 30, 2010–Combat Zone Wrestling: Nick Gage defeated Eddie Kingston after interference from Devon Moore..
- February 13, 2010–Combat Zone Wrestling: Nick Gage won a Battle Royal to earn a shot at the CZW Heavyweight title..
- March 13, 2010–Combat Zone Wrestling: Jon Moxley defeated Nick F’n Gage to retain the CZW Heavyweight title..
- March 20, 2010–Jersey All-Pro Wrestling: Nick F’N Gage defeated Drake Younger | Necro Butcher defeated Chris Dickinson
- ~~~After the end of the night; JAPW champion Dan Maff was attacked by Necro Butcher and the new HWC member Nick Cage!
- March 26, 2010–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated The Dixieland Destroyer.
- March 27, 2010–CZW: Nick Gage defeated DJ Hyde. Nick Gage defeated xOMGx in a barbed wired ropes and barbed wired boards match.
- April 10, 2010–Combat Zone Wrestling: Ego Fantastico defeated Nick Gage in Philadelphia Pennsylvania..
- April 17, 2010–JAPW: JAPW heavyweight champion Dan Maff defeated Nick Gage to retain the title.
- April 24, 2010–NWA DAWG: Chance Prophet beat Ricky Reyes & Nick Gage & Nunzio (4-WAY) to win the NWA DAWG title..
- May 1, 2010–RCW: Nick Gage defeated John Kermon and Rhett Titus in a 3-way match.
- May 4, 2010–BJW: DJ Hyde, Jun Kasai and Nick Gage defeated Isami Kodaka, Jaki Numazawa and Masashi Takeda in a barbed wired, razor blade tag match.
- May 21, 2010–F1: Brodie Lee defeated Nick Gage.
- May 22, 2010–JAPW: Nick Gage defeated Egotistico Fantastico, El Generico and Kevin Steen in a 4-way match.
- June 4, 2010–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Necro Butcher in the 1st round.
- June 5, 2010–IWA Mid-South: JC Bailey defeated Nick Gage in the 2nd round of the king of the death match tournament.
- June 12, 2010–Combat Zone Wrestling: Nick Gage defeated CZW Heavyweight champion Jon Moxley in a non-title match
- June 26, 2010–Combat Zone Wrestling: Abdullah Kobayashi defeated Nick Gage in a “Weapons of Mass Destruction” match..
- July 10, 2010–CZW: Jon Moxley beat Nick Gage and Egotistico Fantastico in a 3-WAY to retain the CZW Heavyweight title.. Joel and Jose Maximo defeated Nick Gage and Nate Hatred, Mafia and Monsta Mack & DeVito and Loc in a 4-way tag team match.
- August 7, 2010–CZW: Nick Gage defeated Jon Moxley and Drake Younger in a 3-WAY to capture the CZW Heavyweight title.
- August 14, 2010–CZW: Jon Moxley defeated Nick Gage and Egotistico Fantastico in a 3-WAY to win the CZW Heavyweight title!
- August 20, 2010–F1: Nick Gage vs. Nicky Benz ended in a double count-out.
- September 10, 2010–CZW: CZW Wired TV champion Drew Gulak defeated Nick Gage by disqualification to retain the title.
- September 12, 2010–NWA Vintage: Nick Gage defeated Facade.
- October 9, 2010–CZW: Nick Gage defeated Greg Excellent.
- October 16, 2010–CZW: CZW world heavyweight champion Jon Moxley defeated Nick Gage to retain the title in a no ropes, barbed wire match.
- October 23, 2010–JAPW: Jerry Lynn defeated Nick Gage.
- November 5, 2010–wXw: Nick Gage, Bad Bones and Carnage defeated Anthony Zeus, Tommy End and Volker Leson.
- November 6, 2010–CZW: Drake Younger defeated Nick Gage.
- November 7, 2010–CZW: CZW Nick Gage defeated Adam Polak in the 1st round and to win the CZW Ultraviolent Underground title. CZW Ultraviolent Underground champion Nick Gage defeated Jon Ryan in the semi-finals to retain the title. Ultraviolent Underground champion Nick Gage defeated Masada to win the tournament and to retain the title.
- November 20, 2010–JAPW: Brodie Lee defeated Nick Gage, Azrieal and Dan Maff in a 4-way match to win the JAPW heavyweight title.
- December 4, 2010–RCW: Mark Briscoe vs. Nick Gage ended in a double disqualification.
- December 9, 2010–MBA: Devon Moore, Nick Gage, Sami Callihan and Tyler Veritas defeated Joe Gacy, Jon Moxley, Niles Young and Ryan Slater.
- December 10, 2010–JAPW: Rhino defeated Nick Gage.
- December 11, 2010–JAPW: Necro Butcher and Nick Gage defeated Mafia and Monsta Mack to win the tag team titles.
- December 11, 2010–CZW: Yuko Miyamoto defeated Nick Gage to win the CZW Ultraviolent Underground title.
2015:
- April 10, 2015–JCW: The Beast Squad (Kyle The Beast and Monsta Mack) defeated Lucky tHURTeen and Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- April 26, 2015–Beyond When Satan Rules His World: Chris Dickinson defeated Nick Gage in a anything goes match.
- May 1, 2015–ICW: Nick Gage defeated Danny Demanto.
- May 2, 2015–IWA East Coast: Nick Gage defeated Sid Fabulous in the 1st round. Ron Mathis defeated Nick Gage to win the tournament.
- May 9, 2015–CZW: Drew Gulak defeated Nick Gage.
- May 22, 2015–AIW The JT Lightning Invitational Tournament Night 1: Nick Gage defeated Eric Ryan in the 1st round.
- May 23, 2015–AIW The JT Lightning Invitational Tournament Night 1: Raymond Rowe defeated Nick Gage in the 2nd round.
- May 31, 2015–Beyond The Real Thing: Nick Gage defeated Jaka.
- June 13, 2015–JCW: Devon Storm, Nick Gage & Tommy Dreamer defeated Team Pazuzu (Angel Ortiz, Chris Dickinson, Mike Draztik & Pinkie Sanchez) in a handicap match.
- June 13, 2015–CZW: Conor Claxton defeated DJ Hyde and Nick Gage in a 3-way 1st round match.
- June 21, 2015–OPW: Jeff Cannonball and Nick Gage defeated Devin and Mason Cutter.
- June 26, 2015–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Markus Crane in the 1st round.
- June 27, 2015–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Sexxxy Eddy in the quarter-finals. John Wayne Murdoch defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- June 28, 2015–Beyond Life Sucks And Then You Die: Nick Gage defeated Stockade in a no disqualification match.
- July 10, 2015–AIW: Tim Donst defeated Nick Gage in a anything goes match.
- July 11, 2015–CZW: Nick Gage defeated Drew Gulak.
- July 26, 2015–Beyond Americanrana: Team Pazuzu (Angel Ortiz, Chris Dickinson, Jaka, Mike Draztik & Pinkie Sanchez) defeated Da Hit Squad (Mafia & Monsta Mack), Eddie Kingston, Nick Gage & Shynron.
- August 30, 2015–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Scot Summers.
- August 30, 2015–Beyond Battle Of New England Returns: Nick Gage defeated Sugar Dunkerton.
2017-2018:
- June 3, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Jimmy Lloyd in the 1st round. Nick Gage defeated Masashi Takeda in the semi-finals. Nick Gage defeated Matt Tremont to win the Tournament Of Death.
- June 24, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Teddy Hart.
- July 22, 2017–OPW: G-Raver defeated Danny Havoc and Nick Gage in a 3-way match.
- July 28, 2017–HWA: Nick Gage defeated Homicide.
- July 29, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Matt Riddle.
- August 20, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Dysfunction.
- September 2, 2017–VOW: John Wayne Murdoch defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- September 16, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Ciclope in the 1st round. Nick Gage defeated Daisuke Masaoka in the semi-finals. Matt Tremont defeated Nick Gage to retain the GCW world heavyweight title and winning the Nick Gage Invitational tournament.
- September 23, 2017–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Joey Janela.
- October 21, 2017–BLP: Jimmy Lloyd and Nick Gage defeated The Faces Of Fear (Meng and The Barbarian).
- October 28, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Miedo Extremo.
- November 11, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Darby Allin.
- November 19, 2017–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Dominic Garrini.
- November 24, 2017–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Tim Donst in a fans brings the weapons match to win the Absolute title.
- November 25, 2017–Powerbomb.tv Wazzup: Jonathan Gresham defeated Nick Gage by count-out to retain the Powerbomb.tv Independent title.
- November 26, 2017–WWR: David Starr defeated Nick Gage in a no disqualification, dark match.
- December 16, 2017–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Matt Tremont in a 3 layers of hell match to win the heavyweight title.
- December 29, 2017–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Tim Donst to retain the Absolute title.
- December 30, 2017–GCW: The H8 Club (Nate Hatred and Nick Gage) defeated The Storm Of Entrails (Dan O’Hare and SHLAK).
- January 13, 2018–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Scot Summers.
- January 14, 2018–Style Battle: Nick Gage vs. WALTER in the 1st round ended in a no contest.
- January 20, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Violento Jack to retain the heavyweight title.
- January 26, 2018–GCW: GCW heavyweight champion Nick Gage defeated Joe Gacy in a non-title match.
- January 27, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Rickey Shane Page defeated Nick Gage in a death match.
- February 16, 2018–Jimmy Lloyd’s Birthday Bash: Nick Gage defeated Jimmy Lloyd.
- February 17, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Homicide to retain the heavyweight title.
- February 22, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Michael Elgin defeated Nick Gage by disqualification.
- February 23, 2018–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Tracy Williams to retain the Absolute title.
- February 24, 2018—Beyond I Want It All: Nick Gage defeated Joey Janela.
- February 25, 2018–Beyond Abbondanza: Nick Gage defeated Rickey Shane Page in a thumbtacks match to retain the GCW heavyweight title.
- March 10, 2018–BLP: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner and Teddy Hart in a 3-way to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 17, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated John Wayne Murdoch to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 17, 2018–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Tony Deppen.
- March 18, 2018–Beyond Hope: Matt Tremont and Nick Gage defeated The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds and John Silver).
- March 23, 2018–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Matthew Justice to retain the Absolute title.
- March 24, 2018–ICW: Nick Gage defeated EC Negro.
- April 5, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Timothy Thatcher by knockout.
- April 6, 2018–GCW Joey Janela’s Spring Break 2: Nick Gage defeated Penta El Zero M to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 7, 2018–Style Battle: Keith Lee defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- April 20, 2018–AIW: Nick Gage and Tom Lawlor defeated Dominic Garrini and Tracy Williams.
- April 21, 2018–BLP: Tom Lawlor defeated Nick Gage to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 27, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Aaron Williams.
- April 29, 2018–Beyond Welcome Home: Jonathan Gresham and Stokely Hathaway defeated Nick Gage in a handicap, no disqualification match.
- May 5, 2018–OPW: Drew Blood defeated Devon Moore, Nick Gage and Rob Marsh in a 4-way match to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 12, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Markus Crane to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 18, 2018–IWA Mid-South: JC Rotten and Nick Gage defeated Mike Roach in a 3-way, 1st round match of the King Of Death matchs tournament.
- May 19, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated John Wayne Murdoch and SHLAK in a 3-way, 2nd round match and winning the heavyweight title. Nick Gage defeated Ciclope in the semi-finals and retaining the heavyweight title. Nick Gage defeated Rickey Shane Page to win the tournament of Death and retaining the heavyweight title.
- May 26, 2018–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham to retain the Absolute title.
- June 2, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Takayuki Ueki in the 1st round. Ciclope defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- June 8, 2018–NOVA: PCO defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- June 9, 2018–NOVA: The Carnies (Kerry Awful and Nick Iggy) defeated Nick Gage and Tim Donst in a no disqualification match.
- June 21, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Larry D to retain the heavyweight title.
- June 24, 2018–Beyond Vitality: Nick Gage defeated AR Fox.
- July 6, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated Bryant Woods to retain the heavyweight title.
- July 22, 2018–IP 2: Nick Gage defeated Mr. Grim.
- July 27, 2018–AIW: Tracy Williams defeated Nick Gage to win the Absolute title.
- July 28, 2018–NOVA: Tim Donst defeated Nick Gage in a street fight.
- July 29, 2018–Beyond Americanrana: The Hate Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) defeated The Filthy Bros (Matt Riddle and Tom Lawlor).
- August 3, 2018–Scenic City: Nick Gage defeated Kerry Awful in the 1st round.
- August 4, 2018–Scenic City: Corey Hollis defeated Nick Gage in the semi-finals.
- August 11, 2018–DTU: Nick Gage defeated Crazy King.
- August 12, 2018–DTU: Paranoiko defeated Crazy King and Nick Gage in a 3-way, hardcore rules match.
- August 14, 2018–DTU: Crazy King defeated Jimmy Lloyd and Nick Gage in a 3-way match to retain the World Extreme title.
- August 17, 2018–GCW Joey Janela’s Lost In New York: Nick Gage defeated Sabu to retain the heavyweight title.
- August 24, 2018–NOVA: Homicide and Nick Gage defeated Tim Donst and Wheeler YUTA.
- September 8, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Scotty Vortekz in the semi-finals. Masashi Takeda defeated Isami Kodaka, Nick Gage and Markus Crane in a 4-way match to win the Nick Gage Invitational.
- September 14, 2018–AIW: KTB defeated Matthew Justice, Nick Gage and Tom Lawlor in a 4-way match.
- September 16, 2018–Beyond Somebody’s Farewell, Probably: Nick Gage defeated Maxwell Jacob Friedman.
- September 21, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Rich Swann to retain the heavyweight title.
- September 29, 2018–DSW: Freedom Ramsey and The Red Rocket defeated Mambo Italiano and Nick Gage.
- October 5, 2018–IWA Mid-South: Nick Gage defeated SHLAK in a street fight.
- October 13, 2018–ACW: Nick Gage defeated Twisted Tate.
- October 19, 2018–NOVA: Booty And The Ace (Arik Royal and Faye Jackson) defeated Murder Dino Kill (Nick Gage and Terra Calaway) by disqualification in the 1st round.
- October 31, 2018–Beyond It’s Alive: Nick Gage defeated G-Raver in a thumbtacks match.
- November 2, 2018–ICW: PCO defeated Nick Gage, Matt Tremont and SHLAK in a 4-way match.
- November 9, 2018–PWAD: Nick Gage defeated Joe Gacy in a street fight.
- November 15, 2018–Bar Wrestling 23: Willie Mack defeated Nick Gage.
- November 16, 2018–GCW Joey Janela’s LA Confidential: Nick Gage defeated David Arquette to retain the heavyweight title.
- November 17, 2018–GCW/SFP: Nick Gage defeated Brody King to retain the heavyweight title.
- November 23, 2018–AIW: LA Park defeated Nick Gage.
- November 24, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Jack Evans to retain the heavyweight title.
- November 24, 2018–CHIKARA: Team Beyond (Alex Reynolds, Brian Milonas, Cam Zagami, Chris Dickinson, John Silver, Nick Gage and Ryan Galeone) defeated Team CHIKARA (Boomer Hatfield, Dasher Hatfield, Hallowicked, Icarus, Juan Francisco de Coronado, The Proletariat Boar Of Moldova and UltraMantis Black) in a torneo cibernetico tag team elimination match.
- December 16, 2018–Beyond Extreme Warfare Revenge: Nick Gage defeated Fire Ant.
- December 27, 2018–NOVA: Nick Gage defeated John Kermon.
- December 28, 2018–AIW: Masato Tanaka defeated Nick Gage.
- December 29, 2018–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Chris Dickinson to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 31, 2018–Beyond Heavy Lies The Crown: Josh Briggs defeated Nick Gage in a fans bring the weapons match.
2019:
- January 6, 2019–Inspire Pro: Maxwell Jacob Friedman defeated Nick Gage to retain the Pure Prestige title.
- January 10, 2019–No Ring Death Match XXX: Nick Gage defeated Casanova Valentine in a no ring death match.
- January 11, 2019–FW vs. GCW: Nick Gage defeated Darin Corbin.
- January 12, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Eric Ryan in a death match to retain the heavyweight title.
- January 20, 2019–SUP: Brett Ison defeated Nick Gage to retain the Bonestorm title.
- February 8, 2019–PWAD: Nick Gage defeated Brandon Kirk in a street fight.
- February 15, 2019–ICW: Nick Gage defeated Scott Steiner by count-out.
- February 16, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated SHLAK in a death match to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 2, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Alex Colon to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 3, 2019–SFP/GCW: Nick Gage defeated Andy Williams.
- March 8, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated KTB to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 16, 2019–LAL Episode IV: Nick Gage and Teddy Hart defeated Andy Brown and Hammerstone.
- March 17, 2019–FSW: Nick Gage defeated Funny Bone in a death match.
- March 23, 2019–SLA: Nick Gage defeated Gary Jay.
- April 4, 2019–ISW: Matt Tremont defeated Addy Starr, Jeff Cannonball and Nick Gage in a 4-way lego death match to win the Inter Species title.
- April 4, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner.
- April 5, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Shinjiro Otani to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 5, 2019–BLP: Nick Gage defeated Swoggle.
- April 6, 2019–IWS: The Green Phantom defeated Matt Tremont and Nick Gage in a 3-way hardcore rules match.
- April 6, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated UltraMantis Black. Nick Gage was in the clusterfuck battle royal which ended in a no contest.
- April 19, 2019–FU: Craig Mitchell defeated Nick Gage to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 20, 2019–BLP: Nick Gage defeated Jordynne Grace.
- April 25, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Conor Claxton to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 3, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Joey Janela to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 4, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 17, 2019–AIW: Eddie Kingston defeated Nick Gage in a no disqualification match.
- May 18, 2019–ICW: Nick Gage defeated Sami Callihan.
- May 22, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 8: Nick Gage defeated Josh Briggs.
- May 26, 2019–SFP: Nick Gage defeated Darby Allin.
- May 29, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 9: Nick Gage defeated Jay Freddie.
- June 1, 2019–GCW: G-Raver defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- June 9, 2019–ICW: Nick Gage defeated Orin Veindt in a fans bring the weapons match to win the heavyweight title.
- June 14, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated AJ Gray in the 1st round.
- June 15, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Dominic Garrini, Joshua Bishop and Zach Thomas in a 4-way, elimination, semi-finals match. Matthew Justice defeated Mance Warner and Nick Gage in a 3-way elimination match to win the tournament.
- June 20, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Tony Deppen to retain the heavyweight title.
- June 26, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 13: Nick Gage vs. Richard Holliday ended in a no contest.
- July 4, 2019–GCW: Hardass Nick (Nick Gage) defeated The Lord Of The Yard (Dale Patricks).
- July 10, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 15: Nick Gage and Thomas Santell defeated Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts and Randy Summers).
- July 12, 2019–AAA/Promociones EMW: Pagano defeated Joe Lider, Nick Gage and Psicosis in a 4-way match.
- July 14, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Louie Ramos by referee’s decision to retain the heavyweight title. Nick Gage defeated Jimmy Lloyd to retain the heavyweight title.
- July 17, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 16: Nick Gage and Thomas Santell defeated Kenn Doane and Richard Holliday.
- July 20, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Cabana Man Dan.
- July 21, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Marko Stunt to retain the heavyweight title.
- July 24, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 17: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Cam Zagami and Christian Casanova by disqualification.
- July 26, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Orange Cassidy to retain the heavyweight title.
- July 27, 2019–ICW: Dan Maff defeated Nick Gage.
- July 28, 2019–Beyond Americanrana: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Bryan Alvarez and Tom Lawlor.
- July 31, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory: Episode 18: Bear Country (Bear Beefcake and Bear Bronson) vs. Nick Gage and Thomas Santell ended in a no contest.
- August 2, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Zach Thomas in a hardcore rules match.
- August 8, 2019–GCW/FIST: Nick Beasley and Nick Lovin defeated Nick Gage and Ron McDonald in a hardcore rules match.
- August 9, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Jimmy Havoc in a death match to retain the World title.
- August 18, 2019–ICW: Nick Gage defeated Dan O’Hare in the semi-finals and retaining the heavyweight title. Orin Veidt defeated Nick Gage to win the tournament and retaining the Alternative title and winning the heavyweight title.
- August 24, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage and Tom Lawlor defeated The Rip City Shooters (Joshua Bishop and Wes Barkley) in a death match.
- August 30, 2019–GCW/BLP: Nick Gage defeated Effy to retain the World title.
- September 7, 2019–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Kit Osbourne in a 1st blood match the OPW title.
- September 13, 2019–SLA: Nick Gage defeated Warhorse.
- September 14, 2019–GCW: Killer Kross defeated Nick Gage by referee’s decision.
- September 20, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Wes Barkley in a fans bring the weapons match.
- September 21, 2019–BLP: Jake Something defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- September 21, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Kody Rice and Matthew Justice in a 3-way, semi-finals match and retaining the World title. Nick Gage defeated Alex Colon, Mance Warner and Yuko Miyamoto in a 4-way match to win the tournament and retaining the World title.
- September 22, 2019–Beyond All Hands On Deck: Nick Gage and Thomas Santell defeated The Creatures Of The Deep (Cajun Crawdad and Merlok).
- September 30, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Matt Tremont, Orin Veidt and SHLAK in a 4-way death match to retain the World title.
- October 3, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.01: Nick Gage defeated Kris Statlander.
- October 4, 2019–CHIKARA: Team Pump (Jordynne Grace, Petey Williams and Scott Steiner) defeated NDK (Kris Statlander, Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) in the 1st round of the King Of Trios tournament.
- October 6, 2019–H20: Nick Gage defeated Kit Osbourne.
- October 10, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.02: Nick Gage defeated John Silver.
- October 11, 2019–WrestlePro: Bobby Wayward defeated Nick Gage in the 1st round.
- October 12, 2019–Beyond Sodom And Gomorrah: Nick Gage defeated Addy Starr to retain the World title.
- October 12, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Matthew Justice to retain the World title.
- October 17, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.03: Nick Gage defeated Kenn Doane by disqualification.
- October 18, 2019–Horror Slam: Nick Gage defeated Breyer Wellington.
- October 19, 2019–MPCW: Nick Gage defeated Mikey Zeroe.
- October 24, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.04: Nick Gage defeated Maria Manic.
- October 25, 2019–ICW: Matt Tremont and Nick Gage vs. The Powers Of Pain (The Barbarian and The Warlord) ended in a no contest.
- October 28, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage vs. Ruckus ended in a no contest. Gage retains the World title.
- October 31, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.05: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner in a 100,000 thumbtacks match.
- November 2, 2019–AIW: Joshua Bishop defeated Nick Gage.
- November 6, 2019–Bar Wrestling 47: Nick Gage defeated Kikutaro.
- November 7, 2019–FIST vs. The World: The Wolf Zaddies (Che Cabrera and Tito Escondido) defeated Jimmy Lloyd and Nick Gage to retain the tag team titles.
- November 8, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Jake Atlas to retain the World title.
- November 14, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.07: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Alex Reynolds and VSK.
- November 15, 2019–REVOLVER: Nick Gage defeated Curt Stallion.
- November 21, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.08: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Team Tremendous (Bill Carr and Dan Barry).
- November 27, 2019–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Atticus Cogar to retain the World title.
- November 28, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.09: IWTV All Stars (1 Called Manders, Dominic Garrini, Kevin Ku, Matthew Justice and Warhorse) defeated Team Beyond (Bear Boulder, Bear Bronson, Kris Statlander, Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) in a tag team elimination match.
- November 29, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner.
- November 30, 2019–AAW: The Masked Good Brother #3 defeated Nick Gage in a 10,000$ bounty challenge.
- December 5, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.10: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Danhausen and Pinkie Sanchez.
- December 6, 2019–West Coast Pro: Hammerstone defeated Nick Gage to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 7, 2019–GCW: Team GCW (AJ Gray, Brett Ison, KTB and Nick Gage) defeated Team WOMBAT (Gian Carlos, Jaden Newman, Kyle Francis and Spank Michaels) in a tag team elimination match.
- December 8, 2019–GCW: AJ Gray defeated Nick Gage to win the World title.
- December 12, 2019–Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.11: Nerder Death Kill (Nick Gage and Thomas Santell) defeated Eddie Kingston and John Silver.
- December 14, 2019–TID The Season: Faye Jackson and Nick Gage defeated Jody Threat and Rickey Shane Page.
- December 26, 2019–GCW: H8 Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) defeated Jeff King and SHLAK.
- December 27, 2019–AIW: Nick Gage defeated 1 Called Manders.
- December 31, 2019–Beyond Heavy Lies The Crown: Nick Gage defeated Slade in a no disqualification match.
2020:
- January 4, 2020–BCP: Nick Gage defeated Jessicka Havok.
- January 4, 2020–ICW: Tessa Blanchard defeated Nick Gage.
- January 10, 2020–SLA: Jeremy Wyatt defeated Nick Gage to retain the Gateway Heritage title.
- January 11, 2020–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Killer Kross.
- January 18, 2020–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Allie Kat in a death match.
- January 19, 2020–Inspire Pro: J Serious defeated Nick Gage.
- January 23, 2020–Bar Wrestling 52: Andy Brown, Dom Kubrick, Heather Monroe and Ray Rosas defeated Gringo Loco, Jimmy Lloyd, Mance Warner and Nick Gage.
- January 24, 2020–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Matthew Justice.
- January 25, 2020–SFP: Nick Gage defeated Chris Bey.
- January 31, 2020– VIPX: Shane Taylor defeated Nick Gage in a hardcore rules match.
- February 7, 2020–AIW: Joshua Bishop defeated Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Erick Stevens, Mance Warner, Nick Gage and Wheeler YUTA in a 7-way match to become #1 contender for the Absolute title.
- February 14, 2020–REVOLVER: Nick Gage defeated Ace Romero in a fans bring the weapons match.
- February 15, 2020–GCW: Rickey Shane Page defeated Nick Gage in a death match to retain the World title.
- February 21, 2020–AAW: Nick Gage defeated Matthew Justice.
- February 22, 2020–OPW: Nick Gage defeated Reed Bentley in a death match to retain the OPW title.
- March 1, 2020–Glory Pro: Kevin Lee Davidson defeated Nick Gage in a falls count anywhere match.
- March 12, 2020–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Ophidian.
- March 19, 2020–GCW: Nick Gage defeated 1 Called Manders in the 1st round.
- March 20, 2020–GCW: Jordan Oliver defeated Nick Gage in the quarter-finals. Nick Gage defeated 1 Called Manders and Atticus Cogar and Benjamin Carter and Cole Radrick and Dilf Boi Dalton and Ellis Taylor and Jimmy Lloyd and John Cena and Lucky 13 and Pitbull’s Corpse and Sanchez and Stauffer to win the battle royal.
- June 13, 2020–FIST: Slice Boogie defeated Nate Webb to retain the FIST title.
- June 20, 2020–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Nate Webb.
- June 27, 2020–ICW: Nick Gage defeated Casanova Valentine.
- July 4, 2020–ICW: John Wayne Murdoch defeated Nick Gage.
- July 4, 2020–GCW: Yard Legends (Hardass Nick (Nick Gage), Lucky The Leprechaun (Lucky 13), Matt Demorest and Psycho Joe) defeated New School Yarders (Kid Grapple (Blake Christian), Emanon (Jimmy Lloyd), Jordan Oliver and Mayday Jack (Cole Radrick)) in a tag team elimination match.
- July 11, 2020–CCW: Logan Stunt, Marko Stunt and Nick Gage defeated JJ Walker, Kevin Lee Davidson and Mike Outlaw in a hardcore rules match.
- July 25, 2020–GCW: SHLAK defeated Nick Gage.
- July 26, 2020–GCW: AJ Gray, Alex Colon, Nick Gage and SHLAK defeated 44OH! (Atticus Cogar, Eddy Only, Eric Ryan, Gregory Iron and Rickey Shane Page) in a handicap match.
- July 26, 2020–Beyond Two Weeks Notice: Chris Dickinson, Nick Gage and Tony Deppen defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice). Nick Gage suffered a injury in this match and will be out of action for a unknown amount of time.
- April 9, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Rickey Shane Page in a death match to win the World title.
- May 1, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Jordan Oliver to retain the World title.
- May 15, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage defeated AJ Gray in a death match to retain the World title.
- June 6, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage vs. Jimmy Lloyd ended in a no contest. Gage retains the World title.
- June 19, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner in a bunkhouse brawl match to retain the World title.
- July 9, 2021–GCW/Loko: Nick Gage defeated Sadika to retain the World title.
- July 24, 2021–GCW Homecoming Weekend: Matt Cardona defeated Nick Gage in a death match to win the World title.
- July 21, 2021–AEW Dynamite #95: MJF revealed that Nick Gage will be Chris Jericho‘s opponent for next week.
- July 28, 2021–AEW Dynamite #96 – Fight For The Fallen: Chris Jericho defeated Nick Gage in a no rules match.
- August 7, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Dark Sheik in a death match.
- August 20, 2021–GCW: 44OH! (Atticus Cogar, Eric Ryan and Rickey Shane Page) defeated MDK Gang (Mance Warner, Matthew Justice and Nick Gage) in a death match.
- August 21, 2021–FSW vs. GCW: AJ Gray and Nick Gage defeated Cut Throat Cody and Funny Bone.
- September 1, 2021–Horror Slam vs. GCW: BUSSY (Allie Katch & Effy) and Nick Gage defeated Alex Weir, Jody Threat and Malcolm Monroe III.
- September 2, 2021–GCW: Gregory Iron defeated Nick Gage in a death match.
- September 3, 2021–Freelance/FU: Danhausen and Nick Gage defeated Frank The Clown and GPA.
- September 3, 2021–GCW/BLP 3: Nick Gage & The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) vs. The Powers Of Pain (The Barbarian & The Warlord) & Warhausen (Danhausen and Warhorse) ended in a no contest.
- September 4, 2021–GCW: Team MDK (AJ Gray, Alex Colon, Effy, Mance Warner, Matthew Justice and Nick Gage) defeated 44OH! (Atticus Cogar, Bobby Beverly, Eddy Only, Eric Ryan, Gregory Iron and Rickey Shane Page) in a war games rules match.
- September 18, 2021–GCW vs. FIST: Nick Gage defeated Ron McDonald.
- September 24, 2021–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Grim Reefer.
- October 9, 2021–GCW: Jon Moxley defeated Nick Gage in a death match to retain the World title.
- October 23, 2021–GCW: Minoru Suzuki defeated Nick Gage.
- January 23, 2022–GCW: The H8 Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) defeated The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe and Mark Briscoe) to win the World tag team titles.
- February 20, 2022–GCW: The H8 Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) defeated The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley) in a death match to retain the World tag team titles.
- March 12, 2022–GCW: The H8 Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) vs. The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a death match ended in a double pin. The H8 Club retains the tag team titles.
- March 31, 2022–GCW: The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe and Mark Briscoe) defeated Nick Gage and SLADE [Replacement for Matt Tremont] & The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a 3-way tag team match to win the World tag team titles.
- May 15, 2022–FWF Live 3!: Nick Gage defeated JGeorge.
- October 8, 2022–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Jon Moxley in a title vs career death match to win the World title.
- October 29, 2022–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Lio Rush to retain the World title.
- November 27, 2022–AML: Nick Gage defeated George South to retain the GCW World title.
- December 3, 2022–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Cole Radrick in a death match to retain the World title.
- December 16, 2022–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Tony Deppen to retain the World title.
- January 7, 2023–GCW: The H8 Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) defeated The East West Express (Jordan Oliver and Nick Wayne).
- February 18, 2023–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Mike Bailey to retain the World title.
- March 11, 2023–IWS vs. GCW: Mance Warner, Nick Gage and Rina Yamashita defeated Green Phantom, PCP Crazy F’N Manny and Sexxxy Eddy in a fans bring the weapons match.
- March 17, 2023–GCW: Masha Slamovich defeated Nick Gage to win the World title.
- March 31, 2023–GCW Joey Janela’s Spring Break 7: Maki Death Kill (Maki Itoh and Nick Gage) defeated BUSSY (Allie Katch and Effy).
- May 13, 2023–DEFY: Nick Gage defeated Artemis Spencer.
- June 17, 2023–GCW: Zack Sabre Jr .defeated Nick Gage.
- June 24, 2023–GCW: Young Middle Aged Senior Average IQ With A Pension Death Kill (Jordan Oliver, Mike Jackson and Nick Gage) defeated Jimmy Lloyd & Los Macizos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo).
- July 8, 2023–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Psycho Clown.
- August 11, 2023–GCW: Johnny Game Changer (John Hennigan) defeated Nick Gage.
- August 19, 2023–GCW: Maki Death Kill (Maki Itoh and Nick Gage) defeated Deathmatch Royalty (Matt Cardona and Steph De Lander).
- September 1, 2023–GCW: El Hijo del Vikingo defeated Nick Gage.
- September 22, 2023 – GCW: Nick Gage defeated Joey Janela.
- October 7, 2023–GCW: Team GCW (Ciclope, John Wayne Murdoch, Miedo Extremo, Nick Gage and Rina Yamashita) defeated Team FREEDOMS (Jun Kasai, Masashi Takeda, Takashi Sasaki, Toru Sugiura and Violento Jack) in a war games rules match.
- November 18, 2023–DEFY: Sovereign (Evan Rivers, Judas Icarus and Travis Williams) defeated Artemis Spencer, Mike Bailey and Nick Gage.
- December 9, 2023–GCW: Johnny Game Changer (John Hennigan) and Taya Valkyrie defeated Maki Death Kill (Maki Itoh and Nick Gage).
- December 31, 2023–GCW: Jun Kasai defeated Nick Gage in a death match.
- March 1, 2024–GCW: Maki Death Kill (Maki Itoh and Nick Gage) defeated Los Macizos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo) in a hardcore rules match.
- March 2, 2024–GCW: Maki Death Kill (Maki Itoh and Nick Gage) defeated The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley).
- March 9, 2024–GCW: Nick Gage defeated Ryuji Ito in a death match.
- March 10, 2024–GCW: Maki Death Kill Club (Maki Itoh, Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) vs. Thrussy (Allie Katch, Dark Sheik and Effy) ended in a no contest.