Anthony Toatele

Title History

• HLW tag titles w Andrew S. Kirk defeating Jake Omen & Scotty Young (November 29, 2014);
• SPW SmashMouth North American title defeating ?? (Date – ??);
• RCW heavyweight title defeating Jack Thriller (July 22, 2017);
• WTF title defeating Dru Skillz, winning a tournament (September 22, 2018);
• HLW title winning a 5-way match (October 5, 2019);
• HLW Legends title defeating Dru Skillz (April 24, 2021);
• HLW tag team title w Chuckles The Clown defeating Damien Reel & Damon Reel (September 10, 2022);
• NEW All-American title winning a 4-way match (June 17, 2023);
• NEW All-American title defeating Jacob Rose (October 21, 2023);

Career Highlights

• December 6, 2013 – PWK: Brian Defiance and Charles Matthews defeated Anthony Toatele and CJ Mac in a dark match.
• January 18, 2014 – NEW: TKO (Joey Kidd Owens and TJ Kemp) defeated Anthony Toatele and CJ Mac.
• February 15, 2014 – NEW: TKO (Joey Kidd Owens and TJ Kemp) defeated Anthony Toatele and Baron Von Kane.
• March 21, 2014 – SSW: Jynx defeated Anthony Toatele.
• April 25, 2014 – SSW: Alexander Kirk defeated Anthony Toatele, Brian Defiance, Charles Matthews and CJ Mac in a 5-way match.
• June 7, 2014 – SSW: Jack Thriller defeated Anthony Toatele.
• July 5, 2014 – PWK: Anthony Toatele defeated Alexander Kirk and Matt O’Hare in a 3-way match.
• July 8, 2014 – FWF: Anthony Toatele defeated Kharn Alexander by disqualification.
• August 9, 2014 – SSW: Anthony Toatele defeated Kharn Alexander in a looser leaves SSW match.
• August 16, 2014 – FWF: Team Purefection (Alexander S. Kirk and CJ Mac) defeated Anthony Toatele and Lazer Lowman.
• September 13, 2014 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Andrew S. Kirk, Eli McFly and Roderick Street in a 4-way match.
• September 27, 2014 – PWK: Chase Matthews defeated Anthony Toatele, Chris Owens and Russ Jones in a 4-way match.
• October 25, 2014 – PWK: Jymmy W defeated Anthony Toatele, Chris Rains, Chuck Stiles and The Sun Daemon in a 5-way match.
• November 8, 2014 – FWF: Anthony Toatele defeated Alexander S. Kirk.
• November 21, 2014 – SWS: Anthony Toatele defeated Alexander Kirk and Kongo Kong in a handicap match.
• November 29, 2014 – HLW: Andrew S. Kirk and Anthony Toatele defeated Main Street Youth (Jake Omen and Scotty Young) to win the tag titles.
• January 24, 2015 – FWF: Anthony Toatele defeated Jacob Brawn.
• February 7, 2015 – SSW: Anthony Toatele defeated Alexander S. Kirk in a I Quit match.
• March 20, 2015 – SSW: The Soul Shooters (Appollo Starr and Drew Johnson) defeated Ace Perry and Anthony Toatele.
• April 11, 2015 – WFW: Anthony Toatele defeated Cliff Compton.
• July 25, 2015 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Shannon Moore.
• October 10, 2015 – FWF: Scotty Young defeated Anthony Toatele in a submission match.
• January 23, 2016 – FWF: Anthony Toatele defeated Scotty Young in a last man standing match.
• February 6, 2016 – EMERGE 12: Kenneth James defeated Anthony Toatele and Kyle Maverick in a 3-way match.
• February 27, 2016 – SPW / FWF: Jon Hudson defeated Anthony Toatele.
• February 28, 2016 – SPW / FWF: KC Hüber & The Legion (Malice & Nitro) and Brutus Dylan defeated Anthony Toatele & Demolition (Ax & Smash) and LB Johnson in a tag team elimination match.
• March 5, 2016 – EMERGE 13: Jeremy Hadley defeated Anthony Toatele and Malcolm Monroe III in a 3-way 1st round match.
• March 25, 2016 – SSW/PWK/RCW: Caden Ames defeated Anthony Toatele and Colt Cabana in a 3-way match to retain the PWK title.
• March 26, 2016 – HLW: Billy Gunn defeated Anthony Toatele.
• April 23, 2016 – SPW: Anthony Toatele defeated Appollo Starr and Frank Isaac Anderson in a 3-way match. Anthony Taotele defeated Caden Ames.
• May 7, 2016 – EMERGE 13: Anthony Toatele defeated Kyle Maverick to take 1-0 lead in the best of 3 series.
• June 3, 2016 – SSW/PWK/RCW: Anthony Toatele and Malcolm Monroe III defeated The Police Department (Deputy Dave and Rod Street).
• June 4, 2016 – EMERGE 14: Anthony Toatele defeated Kyle Maverick to win the best of 3 series.
• June 18, 2016 – SSW/PWK/RCW: Anthony Toatele vs. Kharn Alexander ended in a time limit draw.
• July 30, 2016 – SSW/PWK/RCW: Anthony Toatele & The Police Department (Deputy Dave & Rod Street) & Swoggle defeated Brian Johnson, Jymmy W, Kevin Storm & Mance Warner and Caden Ames, Luke Lawson, Nick Cutler & Theo Storm in a 3-way tag team match.
• October 16, 2016 – NWA CCW: Joseph Schwartz defeated Anthony Toatele to retain the United States title.
• October 22, 2016 – HLW: Team Legend-Dairy (Alexander Kirk and Matt O’Hare) defeated Bobby Fulton and Tracy Smothers & Anthony Toatele and Eli McFly in a 3-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
• December 3, 2016 – MPW: Gavin Quinn defeated Anthony Toatele to retain the Metropolitan title.
• January 7, 2017 – EMERGE 18: Zodiak defeated Anthony Toatele in the 1st round.
• February 4, 2017 – PWK/RCW/SSW: Anthony Toatele defeated Joey Ryan.
• April 7, 2017 – SPW: Anthony Toatele defeated Craig Mitchell to retain the SmashMouth North American title.
• April 9, 2017 – HLW:  Russ Jones and Scotty Young defeated Anthony Toatele and Robbie E.
• May 20, 2017 – WFW: Anthony Toatele defeated Brent Brooks.
• May 23, 2017 – WRW: Kongo Kong defeated Anthony Toatele.
• June 24, 2017 – Stronghold / PWX: Lee Moriarty defeated Anthony Toatele.
• July 22, 2017 – PWK/RCW/SSW: Anthony Toatele defeated Jack Thriller to win the RCW heavyweight title.
• October 20, 2017 – PWK: Adam Bueller defeated Anthony Toatele and The Celtic Nightmare in a 3-way match to win the King Online Michiana title.
• November 11, 2017 – HLW: Kongo Kong defeated Dru Skillz, Anthony Toatele, Hy-Zaya, Lightning Bolt Johnson and Shane Mercer in a 6-way steel cage match to win the HLW heavyweight title.
• December 29, 2017 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Appollo Starr in the 1st round.
• February 2, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Jeremy Hadley in the 2nd round.
• March 23, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Scotty Young in the semi-finals. Dru Skillz defeated Anthony Toatele to win the tournament and vacant WTF title.
• April 21, 2018 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Dylan Bostic.
• May 18, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Papa Bawa.
• June 22, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Papa Dingo.
• July 20, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Kongo Kong.
• August 24, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Kyron to become #1 contender for the WTF title.
• August 25, 2018 – WFW: Alexander Kirk, Anthony Toatele and The Celtic Nightmare defeated Brandon Day, Jacob Brawn and Mark Vandy.
• September 1, 2018 – HLW: Sugar Dunkerton defeated Anthony Toatele to retain the cruiserweight title.
• September 8, 2018 – 4WW: Marshe Rockett defeated Anthony Toatele, Kevin Lee Davidson and Yabo The Clown in a 4-way match to become #1 contender for the 4RWW heavyweight title.
• September 21, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Dru Skillz to win the WTF title.
• October 19, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Dru Skillz to retain the WTF title.
• November 9, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Ace Perry to retain the WTF title.
• December 7, 2018 – WTF: Anthony Toatele vs. Shane Mercer in a ended in a 30 minutes time limit draw. Toatele retains the WTF title.
• January 25, 2019 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Shane Mercer at the 59 minutes mark in a 60 minutes time limit match to retain the WTF title. Calvin Tankman defeated Anthony Toatele to win the WTF title.
• April 12, 2019 – WTF: Calvin Tankman defeated Anthony Toatele by disqualification to retain the WTF title.
• April 20, 2019 – WTF: Anthony Toatele was in the battle royal won by Nick Cutler.
• June 7, 2019 – Destructro Pro: Anthony Toatele defeated Curt Stallion.
• July 5, 2019 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Chuckles the Clown.
• July 6, 2019 – Destructro Pro: Ace Perry defeated Anthony Toatele.
• August 2, 2019 – Destructro Pro: Anthony Toatele defeated Tripp Cassidy in a I Quit match.
• October 5, 2019 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Kongo Kong, Nick Cutler, Rod Street and Russ Jones in a 5-way match to win the HLW title.
• October 11, 2019 – WTF: Austin Manix defeated Anthony Toatele and Brian Pillman Jr. in a 3-way 1st round match.
• November 8, 2019 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeats Chuckles The Clown in a Chuckles playhouse match.
• November 9, 2019 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Kongo Kong to retain the HLW title.
• December 6, 2019 – WTF: Anthony Toatele was in the rumble match won by Jeremy Hadley.
• January 11, 2020 – FWF: Anthony Toatele defeated Dru Skillz by disqualification. Skillz retains the heavyweight title.
• February 1, 2020 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Scotty Young in the 1st round. Anthony Toatele defeated Nick Cutler in the semi-finals. Anthony Toatele defeated Russ Jones to win the tournament.
• April 24, 2021 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Dru Skillz to win the Legends title and retaining the heavyweight title in a title unification match.
• September 11, 2021 – WTF: Anthony Toatele defeated Chuckles The Clown, Dex Royal, Eli Perez and Sage Philips in a steel cage elimination match.
• October 2, 2021 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Elijah Burke to retain the HLW title.
• October 9, 2021 – WTF: Scotty Young defeated Anthony Toatele to win the vacant United States title.
• November 13, 2021 – WTF: Scotty Young defeated Anthony Toatele by disqualification to retain the United States title.
• December 11, 2021 – WTF: Scotty Young defeated Anthony Toatele in a 3 stages of glory match to retain the United States title. Anthony Toatele was also in the blizzard rumble match won by Paragon.
• March 12, 2022 – WTF: Anthony Toatele vs. Dylan Cole ended in a no contest.
• April 23, 2022 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Sean Morley to retain the Legends & heavyweight title.
• May 14, 2022 – WTF: Anthony Toatele and Chuckles The Clown defeated Dylan Cole & The Highlight Reel (Damien Reel and Damon Reel) in a handicap match.
• July 9, 2022 – HLW: Chase Stevens defeated Anthony Toatele to win the vacant Smoky Mountain title.
• September 10, 2022 – WTF: Anthony Toatele and Chuckles The Clown defeated The Highlight Reel (Damien Reel and Damon Reel) in a lumberjack match to win the tag team titles.
• October 29, 2022 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Russ Jones to retain the HLW title.
• November 12, 2022 – WTF: Appollo Starr defeated Anthony Toatele and Bret Havoc and Chuckles The Clown and Dru Skillz and Jake Carter and Jeremy Hadley and Sage Philips and Tony Dynamite in a gauntlet match to win the vacant WTF title.
• December 10, 2022 – WTF: Anthony Toatale was in the rumble match won by Jake Carter.
• January 21, 2023 – NEW: Hillbilly Jed defeated Anthony Toatele to retain the heavyweight title.
• February 18, 2023 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Jeremy Hadley.
• March 18, 2023 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Don’t Die Miles, Roger Malcolm and Shawn Kemp in a 4-way match.
• April 15, 2023 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Dylan Cole.
• May 13, 2023 – HLW: Anthony Toatale defeated AJ Cazana to retain the Legends title and the HLW title. Andrew Anderson defeated Anthony Toatele to win the Legends title.
• June 17, 2023 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Brayden Lee, Jeremy Hadley and Kevin Noire in a 4-way match to win the All-American title. Jacob Rose defeated Anthony Toatele to win the All-American title.
• July 8, 2023 – Super Shogun Wrestling: Jacob Braun defeated Anthony Toatele.
• July 15, 2023 – NEW: Jacob Rose vs. Anthony Toatele ended in a double count-out. Rose retains the All-American title.
• August 26, 2023 – HLW: Anthony Toatele defeated Eric Fallen to retain the HLW title.
• September 8, 2023 – WTF: War Hoss (Crosshairs Kelly and Pat The Bruiser) defeated Anthony Toatele and Chuckles The Clown to retain the tag team titles.
• September 16, 2023 – NEW: Jacob Rose defeated Anthony Toatele by disqualification to retain the All-American title.
• October 21, 2023 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Jacob Rose in a last man standing match to win the All-American title.
• November 18, 2023 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Count Noctis to retain the All-American title.
• January 20, 2024 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Kevin Noire to retain the All-American title.
• February 10, 2024 – Super Showgun Wrestling: Anthony Toatele defeated Kung Fu Kirk.
• February 17, 2024 – NEW: Anthony Toatele defeated Jordan Dye to retain the All-American title.
• March 9, 2024 – Super Shogun Wrestling: Ric Caurdiea defeated Anthony Toatele by disqualification.