Title History
- CAPW United States Light Heavyweight Title defeating Steven Nixon (March 23, 1995);
- HWA tag team titles w Brian Taylor defeating Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk (January 23, 1999);
- NWA OVW Light Heavyweight Title defeating Johnny Spade (August 17, 1999);
- NWA OVW Light Heavyweight Title defeating Scotty Sabre (December 8, 1999);
- NWA OVW Light Heavyweight Title defeating Chris Michaels (March 15, 2000);
- BWCW Heavyweight title defeating Syntrc9 (July 5, 2003);
- BWCW heavyweight title defeating El Diablo (September 24, 2004);
- OCW heavyweight title defeating Jihad (May 5, 2007);
- UCW heavyweight title defeating Chris Michaels (October 20, 2007);
- OCW United States title defeating Kris Kannon (December 13, 2008);
- Vendetta Pro heavyweight title winning a battle royal (July 11, 2009);
- BWCW cruiserweight title winning a 4-way elimination match (September 24, 2016);
- NWA CCW tag team titles w Rob Conway defeating Deputy Dave & Rod Street (October 16, 2016);
- BWCW title defeating Johnny Devine (November 19, 2016):
- BWCW heavyweight title defeating Aldo Rose (December 16, 2017);
- Vendetta Pro International tag team titles w Cody Hawk defeating Billy Blade & Richie Slade (April 30, 2018);
Career Highlights
- Sean Casey is the only other pro wrestler featured in Playgirl Magazine aside from Shawn Michaels in December of 1997..
- December 20, 1993 – CWI: Sean Casey defeated PC Austin by disqualification.
- January 7, 1994 – CWI: Mad Man Pondo defeated Sean Casey.
- January 8, 1994 – MTW: Sean Casey defeated Shinobi.
- January 14, 1994 – CWI: Sean Casey defeated PC Austin by disqualification.
- February 4, 1994 – CWI: Sean Casey defeated Iranian Assassin.
- March 18, 1994 – CWI: Sean Casey defeated Gigolo Jo.
- April 1, 1994 – CWA: Sean Casey defeated Danny Davis.
- April 8, 1994 – CWA: Danny Davis defeated Sean Casey.
- April 22, 1994 – CWA: Sean Casey defeated Danny Davis by disqualification.
- April 29, 1994 – CWA: Sean Casey defeated Judo Master.
- May 13, 20, 1994 – CWA: Doug Vines defeated Sean Casey.
- May 27, 1994 – MTW: Sean Casey defeated Randy Rogers.
- June 10-11, 1994 – MTW: Sean Casey defeated Randy Rogers.
- July 16, 1994 – MTW: Sean Casey defeated Johnny Paradise.
- August 20, 1994 – USWA: Spellbinder defeated Sean Casey.
- October 15, 1994 – SMW TV (Taped): The Gangstas (Mustapha Saed & New Jack) defeated Brian Logan & Sean Casey.
- October 22, 1994 – SMW TV (Taped): Scott Studd vs. Sean Casey ended in a no contest. Studd retains the Beat The Champ Television title.
- November 5, 1994 – SMW TV (Taped): Bryant Anderson defeated Sean Casey to retain the Beat The Champ Television title.
- November 16, 1994 – USWA: Phantom Tragedy defeated Sean Casey.
- November 19, 1994 – MTW: Mike Kelly defeated Sean Casey in a best 2 out of 3 falls match to retain the light heavyweight title.
- December 2, 1994 – SMW: Sean Casey defeated Damien.
- December 19, 1994 – SMW: Sean Casey defeated Brian Taylor.
- January 28, 1995 – CAPW: Sean Casey defeated Randy Rogers.
- February 18, 1995 – MTW: Calavera Cortez defeated Sean Casey.
- March 23, 1995 – CAPW: Sean Casey defeated Steve Nixon to win the vacant United States light heavyweight title.
- March 25, 1995 – MTW: Sean Casey & Steve Nixon defeated Los Rudos (Calavera Cortez & Ricco Rodriguez).
- April 22, 1995 – MTW: Los Rudos (Calavera Cortez & Ricco Rodriguez) defeated Johnny Paradise & Sean Casey.
- May 5, 1995 – NWF: Sean Casey vs. The Spoiler ended in a time limit draw.
- June 24, 1995 – MTW: Sean Casey & Steve Nixon defeated Randy Rogers & Tex Monroe.
- July 29, 1995 – MTW: Los Rudos (Calavera Cortez & Ricco Rodriguez) defeated Sean Casey & Steve Nixon in a tag team elimination match.
- August 26, 1995 – SCW: Sean Casey defeated Frank Stalletto in the 1st round.
- October 13, 1995 – NWF: Chris Harris & Sean Case vs. Crusher Bones & Tower Of Doom ended in a double count-out. Bones & Tower Of Doom retains the tag titles.
- December 1, 1995 – NWF: Chris Harris & Sean Casey defeated Crusher Bones & Tower Of Doom to retain the tag titles.
- February 10, 1996 – Superstars Of Wrestling In Princeton: Ronnie Vegas defeated Sean Casey.
- March 22, 1996 – NWF: Sean Casey defeated Chris Harris by disqualification.
- April 13, 1996 – NWF: Sean Casey defeated Chris Harris.
- April 26, 1996 – NWF: Chris Harris vs. Sean Casey ended in a no contest.
- June 7, 1996 – NWF: Chris Harris defeated Sean Casey in a steel cage match.
- August 9, 1996 – NWF: Chris Harris defeated Bobby Harmon and Bret Michaels and Chris Justice and Sean Casey and The Tower Of Doom in a 6-way elimination match to become #1 contender for the heavyweight title.
- October 10, 1996 – IWA Mid-South: Harvey Nichols vs. Sean Casey ended in a time limit draw.
- November 28, 1996 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Chris Comet.
- December 2, 1996 – WCW Monday Night NITRO: Kevin Sullivan defeated KC Sunshine.
- December 14, 1996 – WCW Saturday Night: The Giant defeated KC Sunshine.
- August 2, 1997 – IWA Mid-South TV Taping: Blaze defeated Sean Casey. Sean Casey defeated The American Kickboxer.
- August 6, 1997 – Bobby Fulton Presents Big Time Wrestling: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey. Bobby Fulton & Sean Casey defeated Beau James & Chris Michaels.
- August 21, 1997 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Danny Dee.
- August 28, 1997 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey & Chris Michaels defeated American Kickboxer & Shark Boy.
- September 6, 1997 – Shotgun Saturday Night: Jerry Lynn defeated Sean Casey.
- September 11, 1997 – IWA Mid-South: Blaze defeated Sean Casey.
- September 30, 1997 – IWA Mid-South: J.C. Ice defeated Sean Casey.
- January 22, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Steven Dunn defeated Sean Casey.
- February 12, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Chip Fairway. Super Nova defeated Sean Casey.
- February 26, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Wolfie D defeated Sean Casey.
- February 27, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Shark Boy.
- March 12, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Shark Boy.
- April 2, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Rik Matrix.
- April 29, 1998 – 1st Annual Brian Pillman Memorial Show: Chip Fairway & Shark Boy defeated Sean Casey & Tarek The Great.
- June 25, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Chip Fairway.
- July 4, 1998 – Shotgun Saturday Night: Kai En Tai (Mens Teioh & Sho Funaki) defeated Papi Chulo & Sean Casey.
- July 9, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Shark Boy defeated Sean Casey.
- July 16, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Chip Fairway defeated Sean Casey.
- July 23, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Sean Casey defeated Chip Fairway in a 2 Out of 3 Falls Match.
- July 30, 1998 – IWA Mid-South: Shark Boy & Chip Fairway defeated G.Q. Masters III & Sean Casey.
- October 3, 1998 – Shotgun Saturday Night: Too Much (Brian Christopher & Scott Taylor) defeated Don DeSilva & Sean Casey.
- November 7, 1998–HWA: Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk vs. Brian Taylor & Sean Casey ended in a no contest. Fairway & Hawk retains the tag titles.
- November 28, 1998–Shotgun Saturday Night: Sean Casey defeated Johnny Paradise in a dark match.
- January 23, 1999–HWA: Brian Taylor & Sean Casey defeated Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk to win the tag titles.
- February 6, 1999–HWA: Cody Hawk defeated Sean Casey. Chip Fairway, Cody Hawk & Matt Stryker defeated Brian Taylor, GQ Masters & Sean Casey.
- February 27, 1999–HWA: Chip Fairway & Cody Hawk defeated Brian Taylor & Sean Casey to win the tag titles.
- March 1, 1999–RAW is WAR: Lou Marconi defeated Sean Casey in a dark match.
- April 24, 1999–Sunday Night Heat: Kurt Angle defeated Sean Casey in a dark match.
- July 11, 1999–Sunday Night Heat: Kurt Angle defeated Sean Casey in a dark match.
- July 31, 1999–Shotgun Saturday Night: Mideon defeated Sean Casey.
- August 17, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Johnny Spade to win the light heavyweight title.
- August 19, 1999–NWA OVW TV: NWA OVW light heavyweight champion Sean Casey defeated The American Eagle in a non-title match.
- August 26, 1999–NWA OVW TV: Sean Casey defeated Jay Jaillet to retain the light heavyweight title.
- August 31, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Johnny Spade to retain the light heavyweight title.
- September 1, 1999–NWA OVW TV: Sean Casey defeated The American Eagle to retain the light heavyweight title.
- September 7, 15, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Chris Alexander to retain the light heavyweight title.
- September 16, 1999–NWA OVW TV: Scotty Sabre defeated Sean Casey to win the light heavyweight title.
- September 21, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Scotty Sabre defeated Sean Casey by disqualification to retain the light heavyweight title.
- September 28, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Scotty Sabre defeated Sean Casey to retain the light heavyweight title.
- October 6, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Scotty Sabre defeated Sean Casey to retain the light heavyweight title.
- October 7, 1999–NWA OVW TV: Sean Casey defeated Low Rider.
- October 12, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated The Eagle.
- October 13, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Scotty Sabre defeated Sean Casey by disqualification.
- October 20, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Low Rider.
- November 10, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Danica & Scotty Sabre in a handicap match.
- November 17, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Scotty Sabre.
- November 26, 1999–NWA OVW Live Event: Danica & Scotty Sabre defeated Hellena Heavenly & Sean Casey.
- December 8, 1999–NWA OVW: Live Event: Sean Casey defeated Scotty Sabre to win the light heavyweight title.
- December 26, 1999–NWA OVW Christmas Chaos: Sean Casey defeated Wolfie D to retain the light heavyweight title.
- January 6, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Sean Casey defeated Randy Royal.
- January 13, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Damaja defeated Sean Casey.
- January 19, 2000–NWA OVW River City Rumble: Sean Casey defeated Low Rider and Scotty Sabre and The Eagle in a 4-way match to retain the light heavyweight title. Sean Casey was also in the rumble match won by Bull Buchanan.
- January 21, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey to win the light heavyweight title.
- February 10, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Alexander & Sean Casey defeated Chris Michaels & Scotty Sabre.
- February 16, 2000–NWA OVW St. Valentine’s Massacre: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey to retain the light heavyweight title.
- February 24, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey by disqualification to retain the light heavyweight title.
- March 9, 2000–NWA OVW TV: NWA OVW light heavyweight champion Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey in a non-title match.
- March 15, 2000–NWA OVW March Madness: Sean Casey defeated Chris Michaels to win the light heavyweight title.
- March 23, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Randy Royal defeated Sean Casey.
- March 28, 2000–NWA OVW Live Event: Chris Alexander & Sean Casey defeated Low Rider & Randy Royal.
- April 13, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey to win the light heavyweight title.
- April 28, 2000–NWA OVW Live Event: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey to retain the light heavyweight title.
- April 27, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Rico Costantino defeated Sean Casey.
- May 25, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Rico Costantino defeated Jason Lee & Sean Casey.
- June 23, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Sean Casey was in the rumble match won by Jerome Crony.
- July 27, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Damaja & Robbie D defeated Randy Orton & Sean Casey.
- August 10, 2000–NWA OVW TV: David Nelson defeated Sean Casey.
- August 17, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Sean Casey defeated Shelton Benjamin.
- August 31, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels defeated Randy Orton & Sean Casey in a handicap match.
- September 7, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Randy Orton & Shelton Benjamin.
- September 14, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated BJ Payne & Flash.
- September 28, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Russ McCullough & Shelton Benjamin.
- October 12, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Brock Lesnar & Shelton Benjamin defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- October 13, 2000–NWA OVW Night Of The Demon: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Derrick King & Jason Lee. Bad Attitude (David Young & Rick Michaels) defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey to retain the Southern tag team titles.
- October 19, 2000–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Damaja & Nick Dinsmore by disqualification.
- January 26, 2001–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Brian Keck & Ron Waterman.
- January 31, 2001–NWA OVW Christmas Chaos: Derrick King, Jason Lee & Rip Rogers defeated Buddy Landel, Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- April 4, 2001–NWA OVW Bluegrass Brawl: Johnny Spade & Sly Skraper defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- April 25, 2001–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Brian Keck & Ron Waterman.
- May 19, 2001–NWA OVW TV: The Minnesota Stretching Crew (Brock Lesnar & Shelton Benjamin) defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- May 26, 2001–NWA OVW TV: Damaja & Nick Dinsmore defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- June 27, 2001–NWA OVW Last Dance: Brian Keck, Derrick King & Jason Lee defeated Chris Alexander, Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- August 4, 2001–NWA OVW TV: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Bobby Eaton & Randy Orton.
- August 12, 2001–NWA OVW TV: The Disciples Of Synn (Damien & Payne) defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- September 17, 2001–NWA OVW TV: Rico Costantino & The Prototype defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey to retain the Southern tag titles.
- September 27, 2001–NWA OVW TV: Damaja & Randy Orton defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- October 6, 2001–OVW TV (Taped): Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Damaja & Randy Orton.
- January 19, 2002–OVW TV (Taped): Nick Dinsmore & Rob Conway defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey to retain the Southern tag team titles.
- February 23, 2002–OVW TV (Taped): Redd Dogg & Shelton Benjamin defeated Chris Michaels & Sean Casey.
- March 16, 2002–OVW TV (Taped): Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Redd Dogg & Shelton Benjamin.
- February 8, 2003–RCW: Outlawz (Chris Smith & Jay Vastine) & Jerry Lawler defeated Chad Allegra, Randy Allen & Sean Casey in a tag team elimination match.
- May 31, 2003–BWCW: Buff Bagwell defeated Sean Casey to retain the WWZ title in a best 2 out of 3 falls match.
- July 3, 2003–RCW: Vile defeated Dirk Extreme and Randy Allen and Sean Casey in a 4-way match to win the vacant heavyweight title.
- July 5, 2003–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated Syntrc9 to win the vacant heavyweight title.
- July 31, 2003–BWCW: Julian The Warlock defeated Sean Casey by disqualification. Casey retains the heavyweight title.
- August 8, 2003–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated El Diablo by disqualification to retain the heavyweight title.
- August 17, 2003 – NWA TNA Xplosion: Christopher Daniels & Legend defeated Shawn Daivari & Sean Casey..
- August 22, 2003–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated Germel Quinn to retain the heavyweight title.
- August 31, 2003–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated Anthony Rivera to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 22, 2004–Blue Water Championship Wrestling: Sean Casey defeated Chris Sabin to retain the Heavyweight title..
- July 10, 2004–BWCW: El Diablo defeated Sean Casey to win the heavyweight title.
- September 25, 2004–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated El Diablo to win the heavyweight title.
- January 19, 2005–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated Truth Martini to retain the heavyweight title.
- January 21, 2005–Bad 2 The Bone Wrestling: Sean Casey defeated Billy Maverick..
- February 12, 2005–Bad 2 The Bone Wrestling: K-Lo & Randy Royal beat Sean Casey & Angel by Count Out..
- April 23, 2005–Blue Water Championship Wrestling: “Sexy” Sean Casey beat Shark Boy to retain the Heavyweight Title..
- June 18, 2005–Blue Water Championship Wrestling: Sean Casey beat Tommy Titus in the 2/3 Falls to retain the Heavyweight title..
- June 30, 2005–BWCW: Steve Corino defeated Sean Casey.
- September 17, 2005–Blue Water Championship Wrestling: Sean Casey defeated Chris Sabin in a last man standing match..
- October 15, 2005–UCW: Sean Casey defeated Al Steele.
- November 19, 2005–Blue Water Championship Wrestling: Chris Kanyon defeated Sean Casey by disqualification. Casey retains the heavyweight title.
- January 28, 2006–UCW: Chris Michaels defeated Sexy Sean Casey w/Samantha after a superkick.
- March 25, 2006–BWCW: Xavier defeated Sean Casey to win the heavyweight title.
- June 10, 2006–BWCW: Scott Steiner & Tommy Titus defeated Kevin Baker, Sean Casey & Xavier Justice in a handicap match.
- August 19, 2006–UCW: Buff Bagwell & Shayne Maddox defeated Shaun Maddox & Sean Casey w/Samantha.
- October 7, 2006–OCW: Sean Casey defeated Shane Matthews. Sean Casey defeated CM Sigmon in a ladder match.
- March 6, 2007–HWA: Sean Casey, The Irish Airborne (Dave Crist & Jake Crist), Cody Hawk, Ganger & Jon Moxley defeated BJ Whitmer, Brian Beech, Brian Jennings, Matt Stryker & Tucker Carson.
- March 7, 2007–HWA: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated BJ Whitmer & Matt Stryker by disqualification.
- March 10, 2007–HWA: Sean Casey defeated Brian Beech.
- April 7, 2007–Ohio Championship Wrestling: Jihad defeated “Sexy” Sean Casey.
- April 17, 2007–HWA Adrenaline: Sean Casey defeated Matt Stryker by Count-out.
- May 5, 2007–Ohio Championship Wrestling: “Sexy” Sean Casey defeated Jihad to win the OCW Heavyweight title.
- May 8, 2007–HWA: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) & Jon Moxley defeated Irish Airborne (Dave Crist & Jake Crist) & Matt Stryker.
- May 12, 2007–GWA: Dusty Dillinger & Sean Casey defeated The Jihad (Ala Hussein & Mustafa Saied).
- June 1, 2007–MPW: Sean Casey defeated Lou Roberts.
- June 2, 2007–MPW: Tommy Chill defeated Aaron Williams and Sean Casey in a 3-way match.
- June 5, 2007–HWA: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated GP Code (Andre Heart & Deja Vu).
- June 12, 2007–HWA: Ala Hussein, Brian Jennings & JT Stahr vs. Dick Rick, Kimera & Sean Casey ended in a no contest.
- June 30, 2007–GWA: Sean Casey defeated Brandon Blaze.
- September 1, 2007—Ohio Championship Wrestling: OCW Heavyweight Champion Sean Casey vs. Jerry Lynn ended in a No Contest..
- October 20, 2007–UCW: Sean Casey defeated Chris Micheals to win the heavyweight title.
- November 3, 2007–OCW: Sean Casey defeated Apocalypse to retain the heavyweight title.
- November 10, 2007–UCW: Sean Casey defeated Damian Adams to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 1, 2007–UCW: Sean Casey defeated Chris Michaels to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 8, 2007–OPW: Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey to win the heavyweight title.
- January 22, 2008–EPW: Onyx defeated Sean Casey.
- February 16, 2008–BWCW: Sean Casey defeated Tommy Titus.
- March 15, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Jeff Jameson.
- April 5, 2008–EPW Pillman 10th Year Anniversary Show: Chris Carnage & GP Code (Andre Heart & Deja Vu) defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) & Chris Michaels.
- May 3, 2008–Global Wrestling Alliance: Cody Hawk & Sean Casey defeated Onyx & Ganger..
- May 10 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Sigmon.
- May 17, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Larry Cooter.
- May 24, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Damian Adams defeated Sean Casey to retain the Television title.
- June 14, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Cassidy Riley.
- June 21, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Chase Stevens defeated Sean Casey.
- June 28, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Chase Stevens.
- July 4, 2008–UCW: Sean Casey defeated The Arabian Assassin #1.
- July 12, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): High Society (Chris Michaels & Sean Casey) defeated Adam Armor & Chase Stevens.
- July 25, 2008–Showtime All-Star Wrestling: Chris Michaels & Sean Casey defeated Chase Stevens & Adam Armor..
- August 16, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): High Society (Chris Michaels & Sean Casey) defeated Adam Armor & Chase Stevens.
- August 30, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): High Society (Chris Michaels & Sean Casey) defeated Drew Haskins & Jesse Emerson.
- September 6, 2008–OCW: Colt Steele and Sean Casey and Sigmon defeated Ryan Dookie and Shane Matthews in a ladder match.
- November 8, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): High Society (Chris Michaels & Sean Casey) defeated The Tribal Nation (Indian Outlaw & Lennox Lightfoot) to win the tag team titles.
- November 15, 2008–SAW TV (Taped): High Society (Chris Michaels & Sean Casey) defeated The Tribal Nation (Indian Outlaw & Lennox Lightfoot) to retain the tag titles.
- December 13, 2008–OCW: Sean Casey defeated Kris Kannon to win the vacant heavyweight title.
- January 10, 2009–OCW: Sean Casey defeated Andy Douglas by disqualification. Casey retains the United State stitle. Douglas retains the heavyweight title.
- January 17, 2009–UCW: Jeff Crowe defeated Sean Casey to retain the Ultimate title.
- January 24, 2009–SAW TV (Taped): High Society (Chris Michaels & Sean Casey) defeated Drew Haskins & LT Falk.
- May 5, 2009–XCW Mid-West: Mitch Ryder defeated Sean Casey.
- June 13, 2009–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Aiden Scott.
- July 11, 2009–Vendetta Pro: U-Gene defeated Sean Casey by disqualification. Sean Casey won a battle royal to win the vacant heavyweight title.
- August 20, 2009–Pro Wrestling Training: Buffalo, Sean Casey & Shark Boy defeated Ben Outlaw, Cody Hawk & Johnny Punch.
- October 3, 2009–OCW: Raul defeated Sean Casey.
- October 10, 2009–Showtime All Star Wrestling: Wolfie D defeated Sean Casey..
- November 7, 2009–OCW: Sean Casey defeated Socio by disqualification.
- November 28, 2009–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Lani Kealoha.
- January 24, 2010–Vendetta Pro: Black Pearl defeated Sean Casey by disqualification. Casey retains the heavyweight title.
- April 11, 2010–Vendetta Pro: Sean Casey defeated Paul London to retain the heavyweight title.
- July 18, 2010–Vendetta Pro: Rik Luxury defeated Sean Casey to win the heavyweight title.
- April 17, 2011–AUW/Vendetta Pro: The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Sean Casey) defeated SuKa (Kadin Anthony & Sunami). Sean Casey was in the heavyweight title battle royal won by Shannon Ballard.
- May 31, 2011–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Chris Cane.
- June 28, 2011–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Sean Melton. Chris Michaels defeated Sean Casey.
- July 15, 2011–BTW: Aaron Solo & Shane Kody defeated Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Sean Casey) to retain the tag titles.
- July 16, 2011–Vendetta Pro: SuKa (Kadin Anthony & Sunami) & X-Pac defeated Shannon Ballard & The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Sean Casey).
- August 6, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Davey Richards defeated Sean Casey.
- August 6, 2011–OVW Saturday Night Special: Sean Casey won a #1 contenders battle royal for the Television title.
- August 13, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Paredyse defeated Sean Casey to retain the Television title.
- August 20, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Randy Terrez defeated Sean Casey.
- August 21, 2011–SAW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated JP Magnum.
- August 27, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Randy Terrez.
- September 3, 2011–OVW Saturday Night Special: Randy Terrez defeated Sean Casey.
- September 10, 2011–Vendetta Pro: The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade, Sean Casey & Vega Velocity) defeated The Barroom Saints (DK Murphy & Joshua Dunbar) & The Drunken Irishman.
- September 24, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Randy Terrez.
- September 30, 2011–SAW TV (Taped): Chase Stevens defeated Sean Casey by disqualification.
- October 1, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Randy Terrez defeated Sean Casey.
- October 8, 2011–OVW Saturday Nightt Special: Randy Terrez defeated Sean Casey in a best 2 out of 3 falls match.
- October 15, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Benjamin Bray in a dark match.
- October 15, 2011–Vendetta Pro: Chavo Guerrero Jr., David Hart Smith & Eric Watts defeated Shannon Ballard & The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Sean Casey). The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Sean Casey) defeated David Hart Smith & Eric Watts.
- October 22, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Sean Casey defeated Joe Coleman.
- October 29, 2011–OVW TV (Taped): Jamin Olivencia & Paredyse defeated Nick Dumeyer & Sean Casey in a dark match.
- November 26, 2011–ROH TV (Taped): Michael Elgin defeated Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey in a handicap match.
- January 14, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated Elvis Pridemoore & Jimbo Onno in a dark match.
- January 21, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated Randy Royal & Tony Gunn in a dark match.
- January 22, 2012–Vendetta Pro: The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade, Sean Casey & Vega Velocity) defeated El Mariachi, Ricky Ruffin & Tenchismo. Sean Casey was in the #1 contenders battle royal for the heavyweight title won by Gangrel.
- February 4, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Anarquia & Raul Lamotta defeated Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey in a dark match.
- February 4, 2012–OVW Saturday Night Special: Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated Nick Dumeyer & The Assassin to become #1 contenders for the Southern tag team titles.
- February 11, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Johnny Spade & Shiloh Jonze defeated Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey to retain the Southern tag team titles.
- February 17, 2012–ROH Rise & Above: Rudy Switchblade & Shiloh Jonze defeated Chris Silvio & Sean Casey in the semi-finals of the Rise & Prove tournament.
- February 18, 2012–UCW: Lincoln Moseley defeated Sean Casey and Shayne Maddox in a 3-way match to win the heavyweight title.
- March 4, 2012–OVW Saturday Night Special: CJ Lane, Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated Elvis Pridemoore, Lennox Norris & Taeler Hendrix.
- March 24, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated The Baronis Brothers (Brandon Baronis & Brent Baronis) in a dark match.
- April 7, 2012–OVW Saturday Night Special: Alex Silva, The Baronis Brothers (Brandon Baronis & Brent Baronis), Dylan Bostic & Elvis Pridemoore defeated X2C (Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey), Assassin, Nick Dumeyer & Tony Gunn.
- March 4, 2012–OVW Saturday Night Special: CJ Lane, Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated Elvis Pridemoore, Lennox Norris & Taeler Hendrix.
- March 24, 2012–UCW: Lincoln Moseley defeated Sean Casey to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 24, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey defeated The Baronis Brothers (Brandon Baronis & Brent Baronis) in a dark match.
- March 31, 2012–UCW: Sean Casey defeated Michael Kaiden.
- April 7, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): X2C (Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey) defeated OMG (Johnny Spade & Shiloh Jonze).
- April 16, 2012–Vendetta Pro/TCW: The Freak Squad (Dom Vitalli & Gabriel Gallo) defeated The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Sean Casey).
- April 28, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Alex Silva & Shiloh Jonze defeated X2C (Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey). Mike Mondo defeated Sean Casey by disqualification in a dark match.
- May 5, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Cliff Compton & Mike Mondo defeated X2C (Raphael Constantine & Sean Casey) in a dark match.
- May 13, 2012–UCW: Lincoln Moseley & The Maddox Brothers (Shaun Maddox & Shayne Maddox) defeated Chris Michaels, Derek Neal & Sean Casey.
- May 19, 2012–OVW TV (Taped): Mohammed Ali Vaez defeated Sean Casey to retain the Television title.
- September 1, 2012–Rockstar Pro: Punk Rock Rebellion (CW Scott & Gee Gee) defeated The Creed (Sean Casey & TKO).
- October 13, 2012–ASWA: JJ Deville defeated Sean Casey to retain the Universal title.
- October 27, 2012–VPW: Chris Mordetzky defeated Chavo Guerrero Jr, Rik Luxury and Sean Casey in a 4-way elimination match to win the heavyweight title.
- April 21, 2013–NWA CIW: Sean Casey defeated Andrew Lee.
- May 19, 2013–NWA CIW: Sean Casey defeated Andrew Lee. D-Ray 3000 & Will Stud defeated Andy Chene & Sean Casey.
- June 23, 2013–NWA CIW: Sean Casey defeated Andrew Lee. Sebastian Rose defeated Andy Chene, D-Ray 3000 and Sean Casey in a 4-way unification match of the NWA Midwest Heavyweight Title / CIW Heavyweight Title / PCW Heavyweight Title.
- July 21, 2013–NWA CIW: Team Bobo Brazil Jr. (Benjamin Boone, D-Ray 3000, N8 Mattson, Sean Casey & Sebastian Rose) defeated Team TK Parker (Andy Chene, Austin Manix, Kris Korvis, Malice, Nitro) in a tag team elimination match.
- September 15, 2013–NWA CIW: The Lords Of Kaos (Damien Wayne & Lance Erikson) defeated D-Ray 3000 & Sean Casey in the 1st round.
- November 13, 2013–Rockstar Pro: OI4K (Jake Crist & Ron Mathis) & Andrew Stryker defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk, Josh Rafferty & Sean Casey).
- November 17, 2013–NWA CIW: D-Ray 3000, Kevin Gutierrez & Sean Casey vs. Mustafa Muhammad, Terror Khan & The Beast ended in a double disqualification.
- February 12, 2014–Rockstar Pro: Sean Casey defeated Andrew Stryker.
- February 19, 2014–Rockstar Pro: Bruce Grey & Jon Murray defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey).
- March 1, 2014–Vendetta Pro: Bo Cooper, Sinn Bodhi & Techno Destructo defeated The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade, Sean Casey & Vega Velocity).
- March 7, 2014–Rockstar Pro: Andrew Stryker & Matt Stryker defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey).
- March 25, 2014–NWA CIW: Sean Casey won a battle royal.
- June 1, 2014–Vendetta Pro: Sean Casey won a battle royal.
- June 2, 2014–Vendetta Pro: Sean Casey defeated Bobby Sharp.
- April 2, 2016–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated Buff Bagwell.
- April 10, 2016–Vendetta Pro: The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade, Richie Slade & Sean Casey) defeated The Von Dooms (Cyanide & The Vintage Dragon) & Bobby Sharp.
- May 28, 2016–BWCW/XBW: Alex Weir & Marty Jannetty defeated Michael Barnes & Sean Casey.
- July 31, 2016–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated N8 Mattson.
- September 24, 2016–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated Shark Boy, Cody Hawk and N8 Mattson in a 4-way elimination match to win the BWCW cruiserweight title.
- October 16, 2016–NWA CCW: Rob Conway & Sean Casey defeated The Police Department (Deputy Dave & Rod Street) to win the tag titles.
- October 23, 2016–BCW: Sean Casey defeated Sinn Bodhi.
- November 19, 2016–BWCW/XBW: Cody Hawk defeated Sean Casey to win the BWCW cruiserweight title. Sean Casey defeated Johnny Devine to win the BWCW heavyweight title.
- December 16, 2016–BWCW/XBW: Slim Trimmons defeated Sean Casey.
- January 28, 2017–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated Atlas Hytower to retain the BWCW heavyweight title.
- February 18, 2017–BOTB: Jackston Sone defeated Sean Casey.
- March 18, 2017–BWCW/XBW: 5MW (Cody Hawk, Michael Barnes & Sean Casey) defeated Atlas Hytower, Chris Harris & Slim Trimmins.
- May 1, 2017–Vendetta Pro: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated The Classic Connection (Buddy Royal & Levi Shapiro).
- May 13, 2017–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated Bobby Fulton to retain the BWCW heavyweight title.
- July 8, 2017–BWCW/XBW: Justin Mane defeated BWCW heavyweight champion Sean Casey in a non-title match.
- August 12, 2017–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated Gideon Malice to retain the heavyweight title.
- September 9, 2017–BWCW/XBW: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated The Bite Club (DRH & Gideon Malice).
- December 16, 2017–BWCW/XBW: Sean Casey defeated Aldo Rose to win the BWCW heavyweight title.
- January 13, 2018–WCPBTW: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated Jay Maynard & Raven.
- February 3, 2018–BWCW/XBW: Brian Pillman Jr. defeated Sean Casey in the 1st round. Mr. Fitness & Rob Clooney defeated Michael Barnes & Sean Casey by disqualification.
- February 17, 2018–WCPBTW: The 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated Bob Orton Jr. & Luis Casanova.
- March 3, 2018–WCPBTW: Bobby Fulton defeated Sean Casey by disqualification.
- March 24, 2018–WCPBTW: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated Fargo Fulton & Kevin Sullivan by disqualification.
- April 21, 2018–WCPBTW: The Fantastics (Bobby Fulton & Fargo Fulton) defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey).
- April 30, 2018–BVW/GRPW/Vendetta Pro: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated The Midnight Delight (Billy Blade & Richie Slade) to win the International tag team titles.
- May 26, 2018–WCPBTW: The FBI (Tommy Rich & Tracy Smothers) defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey).
- August 4, 2018–BWCW/XBW: Justin Mane defeated Sean Casey to win the BWCW heavyweight title.
- August 8, 2018–WCPBTW: Generation Next (Brian Pillman Jr. & Fargo Fulton) defeated The Simply Irresistible Superstars (Robby Starr & Sean Casey).
- August 17, 2018–WCPBTW: Bobby Fulton & Bob Orton Jr. defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey).
- August 18, 2018–WCPBTW: Tito Santana defeated Sean Casey by disqualification.
- September 8, 2018–BWCW/XBW: Buddy Hanlon vs. Sean Casey ended in a no contest.
- September 22, 2018–BOTB: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated The Village (PapaBawa & Papa Dingo) by disqualification in the 1st round.
- October 20, 2018–BWCW/XBW: Cody Hawk & Sean Casey defeated Kongo Kong & The Devil’s Right Hand.
- October 27, 2018–HLW: Human Tornado defeated Sean Casey.
- November 24, 2018–BWCW//MPW/XBW: Justin Mane defeated Sean Casey to retain the BWCW heavyweight title.
- November 30, 2018–WCPBTW: The Boogeyman defeated Sean Casey.
- December 22, 2018–BOTB: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) defeated Leo Kruger & Rory McAllister.
- December 29, 2018–BWCW/XBW: N8 Mattson defeated Sean Casey to retain the BWCW cruiserweight title.
- March 16, 2019–WCPBTW: The Honky Tonk Man & War Eagle defeated The Simply Irresistible Superstars (Robby Starr & Sean Casey).
- April 29, 2019–Casino Royale: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk, Sean Casey & Shawna Reed) defeated The Ballard Brothers (Shane Ballard & Shannon Ballard) & Jessie Belle Smothers.
- June 27, 2019–XMCW: Deget Bundlez defeated Brandon Idle and Dain Bramage and Sean Casey and The Cuban Commando and The Cuban Mercenary in a countdown match to retain the AIWF Television title.
- August 7, 2019–WCPBTW: Sean Casey defeated Bobby Fulton.
- September 21, 2019–BOTB: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) vs. The International House Of Pain (??? & Rory McAllister) ended in a double disqualification.
- October 26, 2019–BOTB Vs. FGW: Rory McAllister defeated Sean Casey by disqualification.
- December 13, 2019–BOTB: Sean Casey defeated Kalam in a dark match.
- December 14, 2019–BOTB: The Highlanders (Robbie McAllister & Rory McAllister) defeated 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) to win the vacant tag team titles.
- February 22, 2020–BOTB: 5 Most Wanted (Cody Hawk & Sean Casey) & Ricky Morton defeated Army Of Destiny (Crosshairs Kelly, Pat The Bruiser & Sgt. Ledbetter).
- March 12, 2022–WCPBTW: Sean Casey defeated Josh Benson.
- April 9, 2022–WCPBTW: Sean Casey defeated Gangrel.
- April 23, 2022–NWCW: N8 Mattson defeated Sean Casey.
- May 27, 2022–Cincy Wrestling: Carson Drake defeated Sean Casey by disqualification.
- August 10, 2022–WCPBTW: Sean Casey defeated James Runyon.
- October 15, 2022–WCPBTW: Sean Casey defeated James Runyon.
- March 11, 2023–WCPBTW: Sean Casey defeated Iron Russian #1 to retain the WCPBTW title.