Title History
- PWK tag team titles w Luke Lawson defeating Brutus Dylan & Tank (August 5, 2016);
- IWA Mid-South tag team titles w Zodiak defeating Dale Patricks & Josh Crane (September 7, 2017);
- IWA Mid-South heavyweight title winning a tournament (January 11, 2018);
- IWA Mid-South heavyweight title winning a 3-way elimination match (February 1, 2018);
- Unsanctioned Pro Hardcore title defeating One BLVD Bully (November 30, 2018);
- CZW World heavyweight title defeating Rickey Shane Page (December 9, 2018);
- Bizarro Luchaversal title winning a War Of The Worlds match (July 7, 2019);
- WCW Big Gold title defeating Effy (December 8, 2019);
- AAW heavyweight title defeating Josh Alexander (December 28, 2019);
- RSP title defeating Gregory Iron (January 30, 2021);
- GCW tag team titles w Matthew Justice defeating G-Raver & Jimmy Lloyd (July 24, 2021);
- DEFY tag team titles w Matthew Justice defeating Miles Deville & Sebastian Wolfe (October 29, 2022);
- PWR tag team titles w 1 Called Manders & Matthew Justice defeating Brent Oakley, KC Jacobs & The Pledge (August 3, 2023);
- GCW World title defeating Joey Janela (June 2, 2024);
Career History
- November 1, 2015 – AWE: Dale Patricks and Mance Warner defeated Cole Radrick and Sage Philips.
- December 19, 2015 – SPW: Matt DeWar defeated Mance Warner.
- February 6, 2016 – EMERGE 12: Austin Tyler Morris and Jordan Kage defeated Bobby Black and Mance Warner.
- February 19, 2016 – Rockstar Pro: Team SPF (Clayton Jackson and Darin Dinero) defeated Mance Warner and Sage Philips.
- March 5, 2016 – EMERGE 13: King Crush and Mance Warner defeated Jay Maddix and Luke Lawson in a dark match.
- April 2, 2016 – PWK: The Popular Project (Jimmy Shalwin and Max Morrison) defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner).
- April 22, 2016 – VOW: Dale Patricks defeated Adam Bueller, Chest Flexor and Mance Warner in a 4-way match. Mance Warner was in the brawl match won by Alexander James.
- May 7, 2016 – EMERGE 14: The 8 Bit Punks (Aaron Anarchy and Damian Cole) defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) to retain the tag titles.
- May 21, 2016 – PWK: The Woodward Avenue Hit Squad (Jon’tae Keith and Tony Thunder) defeated Luke Lawson and Mance Warner.
- May 28, 2016 – PWK: KC Huber defeated Mance Warner.
- June 3, 2016 – PWK/RCW/SSW: The New School (Kevin Storm & Noah Walker), KC Huber, Mance Warner and Tank defeated Team Legend-Dairy (Alexander Kirk & Matt O’Hare), Jymmy W, Luke Lawson and Theo Storm.
- June 4, 2016 – EMERGE 15: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated Aaron Williams and Remi Wilkins.
- June 12, 2016 – SPW / FWF: The Mustache Mafia (Alexander S. Kirk and Matt O’Hare) defeated Mance Warner and Sage Philips.
- June 23, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Joey Owens defeated Mance Warner.
- June 30, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated The American Viking.
- July 2, 2016 – PWK: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated Jayden Quick and Jorge Bravo.
- July 7, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Shad O’Satu defeated Mance Warner.
- July 9, 2016 – VOW: The Cogar Brothers (Atticus Cogar and Otis Cogar) defeated Adam Bueller and Mance Warner.
- July 14, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Aaron Anders defeated Mance Warner. Teddy King defeated Aidan Blackhart, Mance Warner and Shad Satu in a 4-way match.
- July 21, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Idol Heinze defeated Mance Warner.
- July 23, 2016 – WRW VI: The Team You’ve Probably Never Heard Of (Adam Bueller and Ryan Epic) defeated Luke Lawson and Mance Warner.
- July 28, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Ram Jam defeated Mance Warner.
- July 30, 2016 – SSW/PWK/RCW: Anthony Toatele & The Police Department (Deputy Dave & Rod Street) & Swoggle defeated Brian Johnson, Jymmy W, Kevin Storm & Mance Warner and Caden Ames, Luke Lawson, Nick Cutler & Theo Storm in a 4-way tag team match.
- August 4, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Aidan Blackhart defeated Mance Warner.
- August 5, 2016 – PWK: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated The Midwest Monsters (Brutus Dylan and Tank) to win the tag titles.
- August 6, 2016 – EMERGE 17: Gregory Iron and Khris Kaliber defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner).
- August 11, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Sage Philips defeated Mance Warner.
- September 8, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Aidan Blackhart defeated Corey Storm and Mance Warner in a 3-way match.
- September 15, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Randi West defeated Mance Warner.
- September 18, 2016 – PCW: Bobby Beverly defeated Mance Warner.
- September 22, 2016 – IWA mid-South: Mance Warner defeated JC Rotten.
- September 24, 2016 – PWK: The Spirit Of Detroit (Cassidy Kieth and Jon’tae Keith) defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner).
- September 29, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Cole Radrick and John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley defeated Mance Warner and Nick Depp and Ray Waddell and Sage Philips and Shad Satu in a gauntlet match.
- September 30, 2017 – WRW 7: Dale Patricks defeated Mance Warner.
- October 1, 2016 – PWK: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) vs. The Brotherhood (Brother Reed and Mickey Muscles) ended in a draw.
- October 6, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: 2 Tuff Tony defeated Mance Warner. Mance Warner was also in the rumble match won by Randi West.
- October 13, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Ray Waddell defeated JC Rotten and Ram Jam.
- October 15, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Mickey Muscles.
- October 16, 2016 – NWA CCW: The Brotherhood (Brother Reed and Mickey Muscles) defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner).
- October 20, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Corey Storm defeated Mance Warner.
- October 21, 2016 – WRW 8: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated The Team You’ve Probably Never Heard Of (Adam Bueller and Ryan Epic) & Main Street Youth (Ryan Page and Tony X) in a 3-way tag team match.
- October 27, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated JC Rotten.
- October 29, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Ian Rotten defeated Mance Warner.
- November 3, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Ray Waddell defeated Joseph Schwartz and Zodiak, Malcolm Monroe III and Shad Satu & Corey Storm and Teddy King in a 4-way tag team match.
- November 4, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley defeated Mance Warner and Ray Waddell.
- November 10, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Nick Depp.
- November 12, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Kongo Kong defeated Mance Warner by disqualification.
- November 17, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: The Brotherhood (Brother Reed and Mickey Muscles) defeated The Player’s Club (Mance Warner and Ray Waddell).
- November 18, 2016 – PWK: The Spirit Of Detroit (Cassidy Kieth and Jon’tae Keith) defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner), Team Legend-Dairy (Alexander Kirk and Matt O’Hare) & The Mohawk Mafia (??? and ???) in a 4-way tag team match to retain the tag titles.
- November 19, 2016 – Olde Wrestling: The Armed And Aggressive Outlaws Of Amarillo (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated Sue Jackson in a handicap match.
- November 24, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Zodiak defeated Mance Warner.
- November 26, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Johnathan Wolf defeated Bret Havoc and Mance Warner in a 3-way match.
- December 1, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Joey Owens, Mance Warner and Mitch Ryder defeated Bret Havoc, Corey Storm and Mike Outlaw.
- December 3, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Zodiak defeated Aidan Blackhart and Mance Warner in a 3-way match.
- December 4, 2016 – PCW: Dale Patricks defeated Mance Warner.
- December 8, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Ray Waddell vs. Zodiak in a handicap match ended in a no contest.
- December 15, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz defeated Mance Warner and Ray Waddell.
- December 22, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jordan James.
- December 29, 2016 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Travis Titan to qualify for the heavyweight title tournament.
- January 5, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: John Wayne Murdoch defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round of the heavyweight title tournament.
- January 11, 2017 – CZW Dojo Wars: Mance Warner defeated Josh Adams.
- January 12, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: OI4K (Dave Crist and Jake Crist) defeated Mance Warner and Ray Waddell.
- January 14, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: John Wayne Murdoch defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- January 15, 2017 – PCW: Ace Perry defeated Mance Warner.
- January 19, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Teddy King.
- January 21, 2017 – CWF Mid-Atlantic: Dirty Daddy defeated Mance Warner.
- January 26, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: The Player’s Club (Mance Warner and Ray Waddell) defeated OI4K (Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz).
- January 28, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Lloyd.
- February 2, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz defeated The Player’s Club (Mance Warner and Ray Waddell) & Corey Storm and Teddy King in a 3-way tag team match.
- February 4, 2017 – PWK/RCW/SSW: Mance Warner won a battle royal. Steven Drochner defeated El Blue Inferno, Mance Warner and The Maltese Tiger in a 4-way match.
- February 9, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Shane Mercer defeated Mance Warner.
- February 11, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Nate Webb.
- February 16, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: OI4K (Dave Crist and Jake Crist) defeated NVD (Hy-Zaya and Shane Mercer), Kongo Kong and Shigehiro Irie & Mance Warner and Ray Waddell in a 4-way tag team match.
- February 18, 2017 – PCW: Mance Warner defeated Aaron Draven.
- February 23, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Marcus Everett.
- February 25, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Red Rocket.
- March 3, 2017 – VOW: Jimmy Lloyd defeated Jimmy Lyon and Mance Warner in a 3-way, fans bring the weapons match.
- March 10, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Anthony Henry.
- March 11, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Eric Ryan in the 1st round. Mance Warner defeated Mitch Ryder in the semi-finals. Nick Depp defeated Mance Warner to win the Prince Of Death Matchs tournament.
- March 18, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Mitch Ryder in a falls count anywhere match.
- March 25, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Brandon Taggart.
- April 1, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Brandon Taggart in a No Count Out No Disqualification Falls Count Anywhere match.
- April 6, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Sugar Dunkerton.
- April 15, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Zodiak defeated Brandon Taggart and Mitch Ryder.
- April 29, 2017 – WRW: Bobby Black, Luke Lawson and Mance Warner defeated Ryan Epic, Sage Philips and Tony X.
- May 6, 2017 – Wrestlers’ Lab: Tyler Matrix defeated Mance Warner.
- May 13, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Brandon Taggart defeated Mance Warner in a dog collar match.
- May 18, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Hot Chocolate (Myron Reed and Sugar Dunkerton) defeated Headbutts And Light Beers (John Wayne Murdoch and Mance Warner) to retain the tag titles.
- May 20, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Devon Moore defeated G-Raver, Jeff King and Mance Warner in a 4-way elimination, 1st round match of the King Of Death Matchs tournament.
- May 25, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Rob Killjoy.
- June 1, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Aidan Blackhart defeated Mance Warner.
- June 3, 2017 – PGP: Mance Warner defeated Everett Connors.
- June 10, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Aidan Blackhart, Brandon Taggart and Justin Storm defeated Ian Rotten, Mance Warner and Reed Bentley.
- June 15, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Ray Waddell defeated Mance Warner.
- June 17, 2017 – PCW: Mance Warner defeated Bruce Grey.
- June 22, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated John Wayne Murdoch.
- June 24, 2017 – MEGA: Derek Direction defeated Mance Warner in a bullrope match.
- June 25, 2017 – Dynamite Cup: Mance Warner defeated Tripp Cassidy in the 1st round. Dale Patricks defeated Ace Perry, Kerry Awful, Mance Warner, Nick Iggy and Percy Davis in a 6-way elimination match to win the Dynamite Cup.
- June 29, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Reed Bentley defeated Brandon Taggart and Ray Waddell & Calvin Tankman and Teddy King in a 3-way tag team match.
- July 1, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Jake Crist defeated Mance Warner.
- July 6, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: OI4K (Jake Crist, JT Davidson and Zachary Wentz) defeated ThReejects (John Wayne Murdoch, Mance Warner and Reed Bentley).
- July 13, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Baron Black.
- July 14, 2017 – NOVA: The Sandwich Squad (Aaron Biggs and Mecha Mercenary) defeated Mance Warner and Reed Bentley.
- July 22, 2017 – PWK/RCW/SSW: Hurricane Helms and Kevin Storm defeated Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner).
- July 25, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Elliott Paul and Pat Monix defeated Mance Warner and Pat Hickey.
- July 27, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Pat Hickey.
- July 29, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Josh Crane.
- August 3, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Zodiak defeated Dem Hickey Boys (James Hickey and Pat Hickey).
- August 5, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Danny Addams.
- August 10, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Dem Hickey Boys (James Hickey and Pat Hickey) defeated Mance Warner and Zodiak.
- August 15, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jonathan Wolf.
- August 18, 2017 – AIW: Joshua Bishop defeated Mance Warner.
- August 24, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Dem Hickey Boys (James Hickey and Pat Hickey) defeated Mance Warner and Zodiak.
- August 30, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated John Wes.
- September 7, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Zodiak defeated Dale Patricks and Josh Crane to win the tag titles.
- September 9, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Dingo defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round.
- September 14, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Space Monkey in the 1st round.
- September 15, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Larry D defeated Mance Warner in the quarter-finals.
- September 16, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated BC Killer.
- September 21, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jonathan Wolf.
- September 23, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Aaron Williams defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- September 28, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Shigehiro Irie defeated Mance Warner.
- September 30, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Tripp Cassidy. Calvin Tankman and Tripp Cassidy defeated JC Rotten and Mance Warner.
- October 5, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Zodiak defeated Calvin Tankman and Shane Mercer to retain the tag titles.
- October 7, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Paul Milton in a chairs match.
- October 12, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Eddie Kingston.
- October 14, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Tre Lamar.
- October 26, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Calvin Tankman defeated Mance Warner. Mance Warner andZodiak defeated Calvin Tankman and Shane Mercer to retain the tag titles.
- October 28, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Toby Farley.
- November 2, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Outlaw Inc. (Eddie Kingston and Homicide) defeated Mance Warner and Zodiak to win the tag titles.
- November 5, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Calvin Tankman defeated Mance Warner.
- November 9, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Calvin Tankman in a I Quit match.
- November 10, 2017 – WTF: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated Police Department (Rod Street and Tank).
- November 11, 2017 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Ken Broadway.
- November 16, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Elliott Paul and Pat Monix defeated Horrorshow (Calvin Tankman and Shane Mercer), Hysteria (Cole Radrick and Sage Philips) & Mance Warner and Zodiak in a 4-way tag team match.
- November 18, 2017 – PGP: Shane Sabre defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round.
- November 23, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner and Zodiak defeated Eric Wayne and Tripp Cassidy.
- November 25, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Toby Farley defeated Mance Warner.
- November 30, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Anthony Henry defeated Mance Warner.
- December 1, 2017 – BLP: Mance Warner defeated Allie Kat, Darin Corbin, Matt Knicks, Nick Cutler, Shane Sabre , Space Monkey and Stevie Fierce in a 8-way match.
- December 7, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated AJ Gray.
- December 9, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Kevin Lee Davidson.
- December 14, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Anthony Henry.
- December 15, 2017 – AIW: Dominic Garrini defeated Mance Warner in a UFC rules match.
- December 16, 2017 – Wrestlers’ Lab/Legacy Wrestling: Mance Warner defeated Mr. Claxton.
- December 21, 2017 – IWA Mid-South: Jake Crist defeated Mance Warner.
- December 29, 2017 – AIW: Mance Warner and Shawn Schultz defeated The Young Studs (Bobby Beverly and Eric Ryan).
- January 4, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: The WorkHorsemen (Anthony Henry and James Drake) defeated Mance Warner and Zodiak.
- January 6, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Joe Gacy.
- January 11, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated JC Rotten in the 1st round. Mance Warner defeated Cole Radrick and Pat Monix in a 3-way semi-finals match. Mance Warner defeated Ace Perry to win the tournament and vacant heavyweight title.
- January 12, 2018 – BLP: Space Monkey defeated Air Wolf, Alex Ohlson, Cousin Gator, Harlem Bravado, Mance Warner, Scott Story and Shane Sabre in a 8-way match.
- January 18, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Jake Crist defeated Mance Warner to win the heavyweight title.
- January 19, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Silas Mason.
- January 25, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Calvin Tankman in a street fight.
- January 27, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated JC Rotten in a death match.
- February 1, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Aaron Williams and Jake Crist in a 3-way elimination match to win the heavyweight title.
- February 10, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Trey Miguel to retain the heavyweight title.
- February 15, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Matt Riddle to retain the heavyweight title.
- February 17, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Tre Lamar to retain the heavyweight title.
- February 22, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jake Crist to retain the heavyweight title.
- February 23, 2018 – AIW: Jock Samson defeated Mance Warner.
- February 24, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner vs. Michael Elgin ended in a 60 minutes time limit draw. Warner retains the heavyweight title.
- February 25, 2018 – SUP: Mance Warner defeated Kerry Awful.
- March 1, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Maxwell Jacob Friedman to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 3, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Michael Elgin to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 8, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Larry D to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 10, 2018 – BLP: AJ Gray and Mance Warner defeated The Carnies (Kerry Awful and Nick Iggy). Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner and Teddy Hart in a 3-way match to retain the GCW heavyweight title.
- March 20, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Cole Radrick to retain the heavyweight title.
- March 23, 2018 – AIW: The Production (Donovan Danhausen and Eddy Only) defeated DukeMoney (Jock Samson and Mance Warner), The Philly And Marino Experience (Marino Tenaglia and Philly Collins) & The Young Studs (Bobby Beverly and Eric Ryan) in a 4-way tag team match.
- March 24, 2018 – PGP: ???, Derek St. Holmes and Mario Crivello defeated Barackus, Dixieland Destroyer and Mance Warner.
- March 25, 2018 – Glory Pro: Aaron Orion, Justin D’Air and Mance Warner defeated Barackus, Leone Mephisto and Roy Lewis.
- March 29, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: IWA Mid-South heavyweight champion Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Jacobs in a non-title match.
- April 5, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Sugar Dunkerton to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 6, 2018 – H20: Mance Warner defeated Brandon Kirk.
- April 12, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Calvin Tankman defeated Mance Warner to win the heavyweight title.
- April 20, 2018 – AIW: Weird World (Alex Kellar and Evan Adams) defeated The Philly Marino Experience (Martino T and Philly C), DukeMoney (Jock Samson and Mance Warner) & The Young Studs (Bobby Beverly and Eric Ryan) in a 4-way tag team match.
- April 21, 2018 – BLP: AJ Gray and Mance Warner vs. No New Friends (Danny Adams and Kevin Lee Davidson) ended in a no contest.
- April 22, 2018 – SUP: Mance Warner defeated Ethan Page and Maxwell Jacob Friedman in a 3-way match.
- April 26, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Dale Patricks defeated Brad Cash and Mance Warner in a 3-way, fans bring the weapons match.
- April 27, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Calvin Tankman defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 28, 2018 – FW: Gringo Loco defeated Alex Ohlson, Calvin Tankman, Kenny Sutra, Kris Chambers, Mance Warner, Mark Wheeler and Space Monkey in a 8-way match.
- May 3, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Chase Holliday.
- May 5, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Dale Patricks.
- May 12, 2018 – CZW: Mance Warner defeated Conor Claxton, Dan O’Hare and Stockade in a 4-way, chairs, doors and ladders match.
- May 17, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: John Wayne Murdoch defeated Larry D, Mance Warner and Reed Bentley in a 4-way elimination match to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 26, 2018 – AIW: DukeMoney (Jock Samson and Mance Warner) defeated The Philly Marino Experience (Marino Tenaglia and Philly Collins) in the semi-finals. Weird World (Alex Kellar and Evan Adams) defeated No Consequences (Chase Oliver and Tre Lamar), DukeMoney (Jock Samson and Mance Warner) & The Production (Danhausen and Eddie Only) in a 4-way tag team elimination match to win the tournament. Colt Cabana defeated Mance Warner.
- May 29, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Kevin Lee Davidson in a best 2 out of 3 falls match.
- June 2, 2018 – EMERGE 33: Guns And Aggression (Luke Lawson and Mance Warner) defeated J-Squared (Jared Kripke and Justin Meyers) to retain the tag titles.
- June 8, 2018 – H20: Matt Tremont defeated Mance Warner in a fans bring the weapons match.
- June 9, 2018 – CZW: Mance Warner defeated Dale Patricks and Josh Crane in a 3-way, 1st round match. Jimmy Lloyd defeated Mance Warner in the semi-finals.
- June 21, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Eddie Kingston in the 1st round. Matt Riddle defeated Mance Warner in the semi-finals.
- June 23, 2018 – Dynamite Cup: Mance Warner defeated Jake Parnell in the 1st round. Sage Philips defeated Angelus Layne, Arik Royal, Cole Radrick, Johnathan Wolf, Kevin Ku and Mance Warner in a 7-way elimination match to win the Dynamite Cup.
- June 30, 2018 – Unsanctioned Pro Don’t Try This At Home: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley) defeated Dale Patricks and Mance Warner.
- July 14, 2018 – BLP: AJ Gray and Mance Warner defeated No New Friends (Danny Adams and Kevin Lee Davidson).
- July 21, 2018 – Glory Pro: Mance Warner defeated Ethan Page.
- July 27, 2018 – AIW: Jock Samson, Mance Warner, Parker Pierce and Twan Tucker defeated Alex Kellar, Evan Adams, Marino Tenaglia and Philly Collins.
- July 28, 2018 – CZW: CPA and Mark Sterling (replacement for Maxwell Jacob Friedman) defeated Mance Warner in a handicap match to retain the World heavyweight title.
- August 3, 2018 – Scenic City: Fred Yehi defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round.
- August 4, 2018 – Scenic City: The Carnies (Kerry Awful and Nick Iggy) defeated Cain Justice and Mance Warner.
- August 5, 2018 – SUP: Kevin Ku defeated Craig Mitchell, Danhausen, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Joey Lynch and Mance Warner in a 7-way match to retain the PWF heavyweight title.
- August 11, 2018 – CZW: The Office (Brandon Kirk and Conor Claxton) defeated Mance Warner and Mitch Vallen in a hardcore rules match.
- August 18, 2018 – BLP: Allie Kat defeated Mance Warner.
- August 25, 2018 – AIW: John Thorne, The Philly Marino Experience (Marino Tenaglia & Philly Collins) & Weird World (Alex Kellar and Evan Adams) defeated #DukeMoney (Jock Samson, Mance Warner, Parker Pierce, The Duke and Twan Tucker) in a handicap, fans brings the weapons match.
- September 8, 2018 – CZW: Mance Warner defeated Conor Claxton in the 1st round.
- September 15, 2018 – PWM: John Tella defeated Mance Warner.
- September 21, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Gary Jay in the 1st round.
- September 22, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jonathan Wolf in the 2nd round. Aaron Williams defeated Mance Warner in the semi-finals.
- October 5, 2018 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated KTB.
- October 6, 2018 – EMERGE 37: Calvin Tankman defeated Mance Warner.
- October 13, 2018 – CZW: Rickey Shane Page defeated Mance Warner to win the tournament and becoming #1 contender for the World heavyweight title.
- October 20, 2018 – Unsanctioned Pro: Neil Diamond Cutter defeated Aria Azteca, Casanova Valentine, Dale Patricks, Dan O’Hare, Mance Warner, Satu Jinn and Jake Garvin in a 8-way elimination match to win the vacant Hardcore title.
- November 3, 2018 – AIW: Bob Orton & Twins (PB Smooth and Swoggle) defeated Duke Money (Jock Samson, Mance Warner and The Duke).
- November 9, 2018 – WTF: Duke Money (Jock Samson and Mance Warner) defeated Awesome Odyssey (Chris Copeland and Jack Andrews) in the 1st round.
- November 10, 2018 – AAW: Maxwell Jacob Friedman defeated Mance Warner.
- November 23, 2018 – AIW: Duke Money (Jock Samson and Mance Warner) defeated The Jollyville Fuck Its (Russ Myers and T-Money), The Production (Danhausen and Derek Director) & The Young Studs (Bobby Beverly and Eric Ryan) in a 4-way tag team match.
- November 24, 2018 – AAW: Fred Yehi defeated Mance Warner by referee’s decision.
- November 30, 2018 – No Ring Death Match: Casanova Valentine defeated Mance Warner to retain the Hardcore title. Mance Warner defeated One BLVD Bully to win the Hardcore title.
- December 7, 2018 – WTF: The Zubaz Express (Johnathan Wolf and Shawn Kemp) defeated Duke Money (Jock Samson and Mance Warner) in the 2nd round. Mance Warner was also in the battle royal won by Calvin Tankman.
- December 8, 2018 – AAW: Sami Callihan defeated Mance Warner.
- December 9, 2018 – CZW: Mance Warner defeated Rickey Shane Page to win the vacant World heavyweight title in a cage of death match.
- December 28, 2018 – AIW: Kikutaro, PB Smooth, Space Monkey and Swoggle defeated Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Duke Money (Jock Samson & Mance Warner) and Maxwell Jacob Friedman.
- December 29, 2018 – AAW: Maxwell Jacob Friedman defeated Ace Romero, Colt Cabana, Mance Warner, Stephen Wolf and Trey Miguel in a 6-way match to become #1 contender for the Heritage title.
- January 5, 2019 – Unsanctioned Pro: Mance Warner defeated Matthew Justice in the 1st round and retaining the hardcore title. Dale Patricks defeated Mance Warner to win the hardcore title.
- January 20, 2019 – SUP: CabanaManceDan (Cabana Man Dan and Mance Warner) defeated The Production (Derek Direction and Eddy Only) in the 1st round.
- January 26, 2019 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Josh Briggs.
- February 9, 2019 – CZW: Mance Warner defeated Conor Claxton, Jimmy Lloyd and Officer O’Hare in a 4-way match to retain the World heavyweight title.
- February 15, 2019 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Kongo Kong.
- February 23, 2019 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Jacobs.
- February 23, 2019 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Yuta.
- March 8, 2019 – AIW: The Philly Marino Experience (Marino Tenaglia and Philly Collins) defeated Duke Money (Jock Samson and Mance Warner), The Jollyville Fuck-Its (Russ Myers and T-Money) & The Production (Derek Director and Eddy Only) in a 4-way tag team match.
- March 9, 2019 – REVOLVER: Mance Warner was in the rumble match won by Jake Manning.
- March 16, 2019 – AAW: Jimmy Jacobs defeated Mance Warner.
- March 23, 2019 – MLW (Taped): LA Park defeated Mance Warner in a death match.
- April 4, 2019 – MLW: Mance Warner vs. Sami Callihan ended in a no contest.
- April 4, 2019 – AIW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner.
- April 5, 2019 – MLW: Mance Warner was in the 39 man battle riot won by LA Park.
- April 5, 2019 – Blackcraft: Mance Warner was in the battle royal won by Zicky Dice.
- April 5, 2019 – MLW: Mance Warner and Sami Callihan defeated El Hijo de LA Park and Ricky Martinez in a dark match.
- April 6, 2019 – PWR: Caleb Konley defeated Clayton Gainz and Daga and Ian Maxwell and Jake Manning and Arik Cannon and John Skyler and Kyle The Beast and Lance Anoa’i and Mance Warner and Trey Miguel and Shigehiro Irie to retain the Scramble title.
- April 6, 2019 – CZW vs. WrestlePro: Mance Warner defeated Dan Maff to retain the World heavyweight title.
- April 12, 2019 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Jackson Kelly.
- April 13, 2019 – CZW: Anthony Greene defeated Anthony Gangone, B-Boy and Mance Warner in a 4-way 1st round match and winning the World heavyweight title.
- April 25, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated SHLAK.
- April 26, 2019 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Eddie Kingston.
- April 27, 2019 – Unsanctioned Pro 4: Alex Colon defeated Mance Warner in the semi-finals.
- April 28, 2019 – Bizzaro Lucha 4: Nick Iggy defeated Calvin Tankman, Levi Everett and Mance Warner in a 4-way match to retain the Luchaversal title.
- May 4, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Homicide.
- May 5, 2019 – GCW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 10, 2019 – LW: Ace Romero defeated Chris Dickinson, John Silver and Mance Warner in a 4-way match to qualify for the Vacationland Cup.
- May 11, 2019 – AAW: Maxwell Jacob Friedman defeated Mance Warner to retain the Heritage title.
- May 17, 2019 – AIW: Tom Lawlor defeated Mance Warner in a no disqualification match to retain the Absolute title.
- May 31, 2019 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Eddie Kingston.
- June 7, 2019 – Horror Slam: Malcolm Monroe III defeated Mance Warner.
- June 14, 2019 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham in the 1st round.
- June 15, 2019 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Lee Moriarty, Pat Buck and Savio Vega in a 4-way, semi-finals match. Matthew Justice defeated Mance Warner and Nick Gage in a 3-way elimination match to win the tournament.
- June 15, 2019 – MLW (Taped): Mancr Warner defeated Sami Callihan in a looser leaves MLW, falls count anywhere match.
- June 16, 2019 – Bizarro Lucha: Nick Iggy vs. Mance Warner ended in a no contest. Iggy retains the Luchaversal title.
- June 22, 2019 – CZW: Matt Tremont defeated Mance Warner in a fans bring the weapons match.
- June 28, 2019 – AAW: Jimmy Jacobs defeated Mance Warner in a looser leaves AAW match.
- July 4, 2019 – Bizarro Lucha: Mance Warner defeats Dino Dude and Dreamboy and Dusk and Gravity and Johnathan Wolf and Levi Everett and Loren Armitage and Magmas and Nick Iggy and Oculas and Sage Philips and Scary Awful and Shawn Kemp in a war of the worlds match to win the Luchaversal title.
- July 12, 2019 – AAW: The Masked Good Brother #3 defeated Steve Manders.
- July 14, 2019 – Inspire Pro: Andy Dalton and Moonshine Mantell defeated Mance Warner and Steve O Reno in a no disqualification tag team match.
- July 20, 2019 – GCW: Doug Gilbert defeated Mance Warner in a street fight.
- July 21, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Brett Ison and Matthew Justice in a 3-way match.
- July 26, 2019 – REVOLVER: 1 Called Manders defeated Arik Cannon, John Skyler and Mance Warner in a 4-way match to retain the SCWPro Iowa Wrestling title.
- July 27, 2019 – GCW: Bestia 666 defeated Mance Warner in a Mexican death match.
- August 2, 2019 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Jock Samson in a bunkhouse brawl.
- August 3, 2019 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Matthew Justice.
- August 9, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Kikutaro.
- August 10, 2019 – GCW vs. SFP: Shane Mercer defeated Mance Warner.
- August 15, 2019 – QOC: Thunderkitty and Zane Riley defeated Allie Kat and Mance Warner.
- August 17, 2019 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Ricky Martinez w Salina de la Renta.
- August 24, 2019 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Zach Thomas.
- August 29, 2019 – AAW: Sami Callihan defeated The Masked Good Brother #3 to retain the heavyweight title.
- August 30, 2019 – BLP/GCW: Jerry Lawler defeated Mance Warner.
- September 1, 2019 – Bizarro Lucha: Nick Iggy defeated Calvin Tankman and Mance Warner in a 3-way match to win the Luchaversal title.
- September 20, 2019 – AIW: Matthew Justice defeated Mance Warner in a no disqualification match to retain the Intense title.
- September 21, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Matt Tremont and SHLAK in a 3-way death, semi-finals match. Nick Gage defeated Alex Colon, Mance Warner and Yuko Miyamoto in a 4-way death match to win the Nick Gage Invitational and retaining the World title.
- September 28, 2019 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Havoc in a bunkhouse match.
- September 28, 2019 – AAW: The Masked Good Brother #3 defeated Matthew Justice in a 10,000$ bounty challenge match.
- October 31, 2019 – Beyond Uncharted Territory #2.05: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner in a 100,000 thumbtacks match.
- November 2, 2019 – MLW Saturday Night: Mance Warner defeated Bestia 666 and Jimmy Havoc in a 3-way ladder, stairway to hell match.
- November 6, 2019 – Bar Wrestling 47: Jimmy Lloyd and Mance Warner defeated Watts and Yuma.
- November 7, 2019 – FIST vs. The World: Ron McDonald defeated Mance Warner to retain the FIST title.
- November 8, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Matthew Justice.
- November 23, 2019 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Havoc in a falls count anywhere match.
- November 29, 2019 – AIW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner.
- November 30, 2019 – AAW: The Masked Good Brother #3 defeats Nick Gage in a 10,000$ bounty challenge match.
- December 7, 2019 – GCW: Mike Jackson and Tommy Rich defeated 1 Called Manders and Mance Warner to win the WOMBAT tag team titles.
- December 8, 2019 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Effy to win the vacant Big Gold title.
- December 21, 2019 – Glory Pro: AJ Gray defeated Mance Warner in a death match.
- December 21, 2019 – MLW (Taped): Jimmy Havoc defeated Mance Warner in a prince of darkness match.
- December 27, 2019 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Eric Ryan.
- December 28, 2019 – AAW: The Masked Good Brother #3 defeated Jimmy Jacobs in a dog collar match. Mance Warner defeated Josh Alexander to win the heavyweight title.
- January 4, 2020 – ICW: Dan Maff defeated Mance Warner.
- January 18, 2020 – GCW: Rickey Shane Page defeated Mance Warner.
- January 19, 2020 – Inspire Pro: Shag Nasty (Andy Dalton and Moonshine Mantell) defeated Mance Warner and Nate Webb.
- January 23, 2020 – Bar Wrestling 53: Andy Brown, Dom Kubrick, Heather Monroe and Ray Rosas defeated Gringo Loco, Jimmy Lloyd, Mance Warner and Nick Gage.
- January 24, 2020 – GCW: Tony Deppen defeated Mance Warner.
- January 25, 2020 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Jimmy Havoc in a no ropes, barbed wire match.
- January 31, 2020 – Main Event Wrestling: Mance Warner defeated El Reverso and Michael Elgin in a 3-way match to become #1 contender for the MEW title.
- February 7, 2020 – AIW: Joshua Bishop defeated Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Erick Stevens, Mance Warner, Nick Gage and Wheeler YUTA in a 6-way match to become #1 contender for the Absolute title.
- February 9, 2020 – Bizarro Lucha: Mance Warner defeated Levi Everett.
- February 15, 2020 – GCW: Allie Kat defeated Mance Warner.
- February 20, 2020 – NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling: Swoggle defeated Mance Warner.
- February 21, 2020 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Sami Callihan to retain the heavyweight title.
- February 22, 2020 – AIW: Erick Stevens defeated Mance Warner.
- February 28, 2020 – PPW: Myron Reed defeated Mance Warner.
- March 6, 2020 – New South: Mance Warner defeated Adam Priest in the 1st round.
- March 7, 2020 – New South: Derek Neal defeated Mance Warner in the semi-finals.
- March 13, 2020 – MLW vs AAA: Mortiz and Pagano defeated Mance Warner and Savio Vega.
- March 15, 2020 – Bizarro Lucha: Mance Warner defeated Atticus Cogar to retain the AAW heavyweight title.
- June 19, 2020 – IWA Mid-South: Gary Jay defeated Mance Warner.
- June 20, 2020 – GCW: 44OH! (Atticus Cogar and Rickey Shane Page) defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice).
- July 25, 2020 – GCW: Chris Dickinson defeated Mance Warner.
- July 26, 2020 – Beyond Two Weeks Notice: Chris Dickinson, Nick Gage and Tony Deppen defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice).
- July 26, 2020 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Effy, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Benjamin Carter, Facade, Logan Stunt and Sanchez.
- August 8, 2020 – ICW: Mance Warner defeated Tony Deppen.
- August 8, 2020 – ICW: Mance Warner defeated Casanova Valentine by referee’s decision.
- February 15, 2020 – GCW: Allie Kat defeatThe Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Rip City Shooters (Joshua Bishop, Mr. Brickster and Wes Barkley) in a street fight.
- September 6, 2020 – GCW: AJ Gray defeated Mance Warner by referee’s decision.
- September 20, 2020 – New South: Cabana Man Dan defeated Mance Warner.
- September 26, 2020 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Jason Kincaid.
- October 1, 2020 – AAW Alive #1: Mance Warner defeated Jake Crist to retain the heavyweight title.
- October 3, 2020 – NPU: Matthew Justice defeated Mance Warner in a no ring, death match.
- October 9, 2020 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Mr. Brickster.
- October 10, 2020 – GCW: Mance Warner was in the clusterfuck battle royal won by Nate Webb.
- October 10, 2020 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner, Matthew Justice) and Levi Everett defeated Billy Dixon, Joshua Wavra, MV Young and O’Shay Edwards.
- October 24, 2020 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Kevin Giza.
- October 29, 2020 – AAW Alive #2: Hakim Zane and Karam defeated Jake Something and Mance Warner.
- October 30, 2020 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Prima Donny.
- November 7, 2020 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Lowlife Louie in the 1st round. Mance Warner defeated Alex Colon in the semi-finals. Mance Warner defeated MASADA to win the tournament.
- November 12, 2020 – AAW Alive #3: Mance Warner defeated Hakim Zane to retain the heavyweight title.
- November 21, 2020 – IWA Mid-South: Jake Crist defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 5, 2020 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Atticus Cogar.
- December 19, 2020 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Toby Farley.
- December 31, 2020 – GCW: Chris Dickinson defeated Allie Kat, Blake Christian, Cole Radrick, Effy and Mance Warner in a 6-way match.
- January 1, 2021 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Calvin Tankman.
- January 16, 2021 – NPU: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Rejects (Akira, John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley).
- January 30, 2021 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Gregory Iron to win the RSP title.
- February 27, 2021 – VxS: JTG defeated Mance Warner.
- March 6, 2021 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Charles Mason.
- March 12, 2021 – PWT: Mance Warner defeated AKIRA in a anything goes match.
- March 13, 2021 – IWA Mid-South: Rickey Shane Page defeated Mance Warner in a death match.
- April 3, 2021 – AAW Alive #4: Mance Warner defeated Manders to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 10, 2021 – NPU: Mance Warner defeated Connor Claxton.
- April 10, 2021 – GCW: Effy, Mance Warner and Nate Webb defeated 44OH! (Atticus Cogar, Bobby Beverly and Gregory Iron).
- April 23, 2021 – IWA Mid-South: Kevin Giza defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round.
- April 24, 2021 – AAW Alive #8: Mance Warner defeated ACH to retain the heavyweight title.
- April 29, 2021 – AIW: Joshua Bishop defeated Mance Warner to retain the AIW Absolute Title / AIW Intense title.
- April 30, 2021 – AIW: The Philly Marino Experience (Marino Tenaglia & Philly Collins), Mance Warner and Tommy Rich defeated The Bitcoin Boyz (Eric Taylor & Mikey Montgomery), Ethan Wright and The Duke in a anything goes match.
- May 1, 2021 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Nolan Edwards.
- May 7, 2021 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Fred Yehi to retain the heavyweight title.
- May 15, 2021 – Jamie Iovine Presents Ante Up: A Wrestling Experience: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The RockNES Monsters (BHK and Yuma).
- May 15, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Eli Everfly & The Unguided (Damian Drake and Matt Vandagriff).
- May 16, 2021 – IWA Mid-South: Bobby Beverly defeated Eric Ryan and Mance Warner in a 3-way, 1st round match.
- May 22, 2021 – AAW Alive #11: Mance Warner defeated Thomas Shire to retain the heavyweight title.
- June 4, 2021 – Hybrid: Mance Warner defeated 1 Called Manders.
- June 6, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) & Levi Everett defeated BUSSY (Allie Kat & Effy) and Everett Connors.
- June 11, 2021 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Jake Something to retain the heavyweight title.
- June 12, 2021 – IWC: Bill Collier defeated Mance Warner and Matthew Justice in a 3-way match to retain the Super Indy title.
- June 19, 2021 – GCW: Nick Gage defeated Mance Warner in a bunkhouse brawl match to retain the World title.
- June 27, 2021 – NGW: Calvin Tankman defeated Mance Warner.
- July 9, 2021 – AAW: Fred Yehi defeated Mance Warner in a steel cage match to win the heavyweight title.
- July 10, 2021 – GCW: AJ Gray defeated 1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice in a 4-way match.
- July 24, 2021 – GCW Homecoming: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated G-Raver and Jimmy Lloyd to win the tag team titles.
- July 25, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Dante Leon and Ninja Mack to retain the tag team titles.
- July 30, 2021 – IWA Mid-South: Mance Warner defeated Bobby Beverly in a 1st round, Texas bullrope death match.
- July 31, 2021 – IWA Mid-South: MASADA defeated Mance Warner and SHLAK in a 3-way semi-finals, death match of the King Of Death matchs tournament.
- August 7, 2021 – GCW No Signals In The Hills: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated BUSSY (Allie Katch and Effy) to retain the tag team titles.
- August 20, 2021 – GCW: 44OH! (Atticus Cogar, Eric Ryan and Rickey Shane Page) defeated MDK Gang (Mance Warner, Matthew Justice and Nick Gage) in a death match.
- August 21, 2021 – FSW vs. GCW: Team GCW (Jimmy Lloyd, Juicy Finau, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Team FSW (Graves, Gregory Sharpe, Jakob Austin Young and Toa Liona).
- August 27, 2021 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Kaplan.
- August 28, 2021 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Levi Everett.
- August 29, 2021 – NGW: Mance Warner defeated Stallion Rogers.
- September 1, 2021 – GCW/Horror Slam: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Death Threat Army (Aaron Orion and Jack Price), oVe (Jake Crist and Madman Fulton) & Nate Bock and Rhino in a 4-way tag team street fight to retain the GCW tag team titles and winning the Horror Slam tag team titles.
- September 2, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated 44OH! (Atticus Cogar and Eric Ryan) to retain the tag team titles.
- September 3, 2021 – GCW/BLP 3: Nick Gage & The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) vs. The Powers Of Pain (The Barbarian & The Warlord) & Warhausen (Danhausen and Warhorse) ended in a no contest.
- September 4, 2021 – GCW: Team MDK (AJ Gray, Alex Colon, Effy, Mance Warner, Matthew Justice and Nick Gage) defeated 44OH! (Atticus Cogar, Bobby Beverly, Eddy Only, Eric Ryan, Gregory Iron and Rickey Shane Page) in a war games rules match.
- September 5, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Billy Dixon and MV Young.
- September 10, 2021 – AIW: Tom Lawlor defeated Mance Warner.
- September 11, 2021 – IWA Mid-South: Fred Yehi defeated Mance Warner.
- September 17, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Lucas Riley, Nick Wayne and Starboy Charlie.
- September 18, 2021 – GCW vs. FIST: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Doomfly (Delilah Doom and Eli Everfly).
- September 24, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Chris Dickinson and Starboy Charlie to retain the tag team titles.
- October 1, 2021 – AAW: InFAMy (Joeasa and Robin Steele) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) in a dog collar, chain match.
- October 8, 2021 – Hybrid: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) defeated The Cogar Brothers (Atticus Cogar and Otis Cogar).
- October 9, 2021 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated AKIRA, Alex Colon and G-Raver.
- October 23, 2021 – GCW: The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe and Mark Briscoe) defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) to win the tag team titles.
- October 28, 2021 – MLW: Mance Warner has been released from MLW.
- October 29, 2021 – AAW: Josh Alexander defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round.
- October 30, 2021 – AAW: Dante Leon and Jake Something defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) to retain the tag team titles.
- March 12, 2022–GCW: The H8 Club (Matt Tremont and Nick Gage) vs. The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a death match ended in a double pin. The H8 Club retains the tag team titles.
- March 31, 2022–GCW Joey Janela’s Spring Break 6 Part 1: The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe and Mark Briscoe) defeated Nick Gage and SLADE [Replacement for Matt Tremont] & The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a 3-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- April 1, 2022–GCW Joey Janela’s Spring Break 6 Part 2: The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner & Matthew Justice) won the clusterfuck battle royal.
- April 10, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The South Pacific Savages (Journey Fatu & Juicy Finau) and D-Rogue.
- April 22, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Big Starkz Brand (Billie Starkz, Calvin Tankman and Cole Radrick) in a handicap match.
- April 23, 2022–GCW: The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe and Mark Briscoe) vs. The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) ended in a draw.
- April 30, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated BUSSY 420 (Allie Katch, Effy and Grim Reefer).
- May 28, 2022–GCW: Allie Katch, Billie Starkz and Sandra Moone defeated The Second Gear Crew (AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice).
- June 5, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Ironbeast (KTB and Shane Mercer).
- June 18, 2022–GCW: Jimmy Lloyd & Los Mazisos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice).
- June 19, 2022–GCW: Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) defeated Waves And Curls (Jaylen Brandyn and Traevon Jordan).
- June 30, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Team Horror Slam (Breyer Wellington, Malcolm Monroe III and Tommy Vendetta).
- July 1, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Jimmy Lloyd & Los Mazisos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo).
- July 3, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Bloodfighters (AKIRA, Alex Colon and Dale Patricks).
- July 9, 2022–REVOLVER: Jake Crist defeated Mance Warner in a bunkhouse brawl match.
- July 15, 2022–GCW: BUSSY (Allie Katch and Effy) defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a death match to retain the tag team titles.
- July 29, 2022–GCW: Los Mazisos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo) defeated BUSSY (Allie Katch and Effy) & The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a 3-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- July 31, 2022–JCP Ric Flair‘s Last Match: Mance Warner won the preshow battle royal.
- August 4, 2022–AEW Dark Elevation Special: Mance Warner defeated Serpentico.
- August 7, 2022–AEW Rampage #53: Jon Moxley defeated Mance Warner by referee’s decision in a World title eliminator match.
- August 14, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Blake Christian, Jordan Oliver and Nick Wayne.
- August 19, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Revolt! (Caleb Konley and Zane Riley).
- August 20, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Charli Evans and Everett Connors.
- September 3, 2022–GCW: Alex Colon & John Wayne Murdoch defeated BUSSY (Allie Katch & Effy), Los Mazisos (Ciclope & Miedo Extremo), The Briscoes (Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe) and The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner & Matthew Justice) in a 5-way tag team war games rules match to win the tag team titles.
- September 10, 2022–JCW: SLADE vs. Mance Warner in a barbed wire death match ended in a no contest.
- September 23, 2022–GCW: Mance Warner defeated Hunter Freeman.
- September 26, 2022–GCW: Rina Yamashita defeated Mance Warner in a death match to retain the Ultraviolent title.
- September 27, 2022–GCW: Abdullah Kobayashi and Ryuji Ito defeated Cole Radrick and Mance Warner.
- September 29, 2022–BJW: Jaki Numazawa, Masaya Takahashi and Ryuji Ito defeated Alex Colon, Effy and Mance Warner in a death match.
- October 9, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Jimmy Lloyd & Wasted Youth (Dyln McKay and Marcus Mathers).
- October 15, 2022–Greektown: Channing Decker defeated Mance Warner in a hardcore rules match to retain the Greektown Wrestling title.
- October 16, 2022–Destiny: TARIK defeated Mance Warner and Shane Sabre in a 3-way match.
- October 21, 2022–C4: Joshua Bishop defeated LuFisto, Mance Warner and Marcus Mathers in a 4-way match no disqualification, no count-out match to retain the Underground title.
- October 22, 2022–GCW: Los Mazisos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo) defeated Mega Bastards (Alex Colon and John Wayne Murdoch) & The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a 3-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- October 23, 2022–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Effy, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Team Unsanctioned Pro (Aaron Williams, Jeffrey John and Lord Crewe).
- October 29, 2022–DEFY: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated State Of Emergency (Miles Deville and Sebastian Wolfe) in a street fight to win the tag team titles.
- October 30, 2022–MLW Fightland: nZo defeated Mance Warner in a hardcore rules match.
- November 12, 2022–REVOLVER: Steve Maclin defeated 1 Called Manders, Crash Jaxon and Mance Warner in a 4-way match.
- November 13, 2022–GCW: John Wayne Murdoch defeated Mance Warner in a Taipei death match.
- November 19, 2022–JCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, AJ Gray, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Good Ol Boys (Chris Hamrick, Crowbar, Doug Gilbert and Tommy Rich) in a tag team elimination match.
- November 20, 2022–GCW: Cole Radrick, Dark Sheik and Sawyer Wreck defeated The Second Gear Crew (Effy, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice).
- November 25, 2022–AAW: Silas Young defeated Matthew Justice.
- November 26, 2022–DEFY: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Bollywood Boyz (Gurv Sihra and Harv Sihra) to retain the tag team titles.
- December 3, 2022–GCW: Los Mazisos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo) defeated 2 Cold Scorpio and The Sandman & The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a 3-way tag team match to retain the tag team titles.
- December 22, 2022–MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Mads Krügger.
- December 30, 2022–AAW: Jake Something defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 31, 2022–GCW: Cole Radrick, Dark Sheik & The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) defeated Axton Ray, Rob Shit, Sam Stackhouse and Shane Mercer.
- January 1, 2023–GCW: Mance Warner was in the due or die rumble match won by Masha Slamovich.
- January 7, 2023–MLW Blood & Thunder: Rickey Shane Page defeated Mance Warner in a hardcore rules match.
- January 20, 2023–GCW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Bojack and Lucky Ali, Revolt! (Caleb Konley and Zane Riley) & The Rejects (George South and John Wayne Murdoch) in a 4-way tag team match.
- February 2, 2023–REVOLVER: The Rascalz (Myron Reed, Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a street fight.
- February 11, 2023–DEFY: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Midnight Heat (Eddie Pearl and Ricky Gibson) to retain the tag team titles.
- February 17, 2023 – AAW: Jake Something and Joey Janela defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Manders).
- February 18, 2023 – GCW: Jordan Oliver defeated Mance Warner to retain the JCW title.
- March 4, 2023 – REVOLVER: The Rascalz (Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz) defeated BULLET CLUB (Ace Austin and Chris Bey) & The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a 3-way tag team match to win the tag team titles.
- March 5, 2023 – GCW: Bang Bros (August Matthews and Davey Bang) vs. The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) vs. Wasted Youth (Dyln McKay and Marcus Mathers) vs. Young Dumb N Broke (Charlie Tiger and Ellis Taylor) in a 4-way tag team match ended in a no contest.
- March 11, 2023 – IWS vs. GCW: Mance Warner, Nick Gage and Rina Yamashita defeated Green Phantom, PCP Crazy F’N Manny and Sexxxy Eddy in a fans bring the weapons match.
- March 14, 2023 – MLW (Taped): Rickey Shane Page defeated Mance Warner in a hardcore rules match.
- March 17, 2023 – GCW: BUSSY (Allie Katch and Effy) defeated The Mane Event (Jay Lyon and Midas Black), The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) & Wasted Youth (Dyln McKay and Marcus Mathers) in a 4-way tag team match.
- March 18, 2023 – ESW: Starboy Charlie & To Infinity And Beyond (Cheech and Colin Delaney) defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner, Manders and Matthew Justice).
- March 19, 2023 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Cole Radrick.
- March 24, 2023 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Silas Mason.
- March 25, 2023 – BLP: Joshua Bishop defeated Mance Warner to retain the Midwest title.
- March 31, 2023 – GCW vs. DDT: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Chris Brookes, Mizuki Watase and Shunma Katsumata.
- April 11, 2023 – MLW (Taped): Real1 defeated Mance Warner, Matthew Justice and Microman in a 4-way, casket match.
- April 14, 2023 – AAW: Mance Warner vs. Robert Anthony ended in a no contest.
- April 15, 2023 – MidwestTerritory.com Pawcade 4: The Final Chapter: Hardway Heeter defeated Cole Radrick, Kerry Awful, Kevin Giza, Mad Dog Connelly and Mance Warner in a 6-way, 1st round match.
- April 15, 2023 – GCW: Thrussy (Allie Katch, Dark Sheik and Effy) defeated Jimmy Lloyd & The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner).
- April 16, 2023 – GCW: Dark Sheik & The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) defeated Billie Starkz, Billy Roc and Cole Radrick in a hardcore rules match.
- April 18, 2023 – MLW (Taped): The Calling (AKIRA, Delirious, Doctor Cornwallis and Rickey Shane Page) defeated Alex Hammerstone & The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a war games rules match.
- April 22, 2023 – DREAMWAVE: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Manders) defeated Hartenbower and Mike Bennett in a unsanctioned rules match.
- April 25, 2023 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner was in the 40 man battle riot won by Alex Kane.
- May 13, 2023 – DEFY: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Sinner And Saint (Judas Icarus and Travis Williams) to retain the tag team titles.
- May 20, 2023 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Tommy Vendetta in a death match.
- May 21, 2023 – GCW: Masha Slamovich defeated Mance Warner to retain the World title.
- May 26, 2023 – GCW: BUSSY (Allie Katch & Effy) & Mance Warner defeated Los Macizos (Ciclope & Miedo Extremo) & John Wayne Murdoch and Jack Cartwheel, Starboy Charlie & Titus Alexander in a 3-way tag team match.
- June 3, 2023 – BLP: Mance Warner defeated Steph De Lander in a hardcore rules match.
- June 17, 2023 – REVOLVER: Jon Moxley & The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Rickey Shane Page & The Rascalz (Myron Reed, Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz).
- June 23, 2023 – AIW: Dominic Garrini defeated Mance Warner.
- June 24, 2023 – DEFY: The Bollywood Boyz (Gurv Sihra and Harv Sihra) defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) in a Mumbai street fight to win the tag team titles.
- June 30, 2023 – WrestleMax: Dan The Dad defeated Mance Warner.
- July 1, 2023 – REVOLVER: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Rascalz (Myron Reed, Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz) in a caged of horror match to win the PWR tag team titles.
- July 8, 2023 – MLW: Mance Warner defeated Sam Adonis in a country whipping match.
- July 14, 2023 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated George South.
- July 15, 2023 – AAW: Robert Anthony defeated Mance Warner.
- July 29, 2023 – AIW: Kaplan defeated Mance Warner in the 1st round.
- August 3, 2023 – REVOLVER: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated Alpha Sigma Sigma (Brent Oakley, KC Jacobs and The Pledge) to retain the PWR tag team titles.
- August 4, 2023 – GCW: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch and Reed Bentley) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) in a death match.
- August 11, 2023 – GCW: Gringo Loco defeated Mance Warner.
- August 19, 2023 – Destiny: The Calling (AKIRA and Rickey Shane Page) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) in a street fight.
- August 25, 2023 – WrestleMax: Davey Vega defeated Mance Warner and Mike Outlaw in a 3-way match to win the vacant River City title.
- August 31, 2023 – AAW: Robert Anthony defeated Mance Warner in a no ropes, barbed wire match.
- September 1, 2023 – GCW: Mike Bailey defeated Mance Warner.
- September 2, 2023 – GCW: The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated TNA Originals (Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin and Eric Young) to retain the PWR tag team titles.
- September 3, 2023 – MLW: Matt Cardona defeated Mance Warner in a kiss my foot match.
- September 10, 2023 – GCW: Jacob Fatu defeated Mance Warner.
- September 15, 2023 – AIW: Mance Warner defeated Katie Arquette in the 1st round.
- September 16, 2023 – AIW: Eric Taylor defeated Chavo Guerrero Jr., Magnum CK and Mance Warner in a 4-way, semi-finals match.
- September 22, 2023 – wXw: Astronauts (Fuminori Abe and Takuya Nomura) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) in the 1st round of the World tag league.
- September 22, 2023 – GCW Germany: BUSSY (Allie Katch and Effy) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner).
- September 23, 2023 – wXw: Norman Harras defeated Mance Warner in a country whipping match.
- September 23, 2023 – GCW vs. The World (Germany): Amboss (Icarus, Laurance Roman and Robert Dreissker) defeated SGCunt (1 Called Manders, Dark Sheik and Mance Warner).
- September 24, 2023 – wXw: Mance Warner defeated Alex Duke in the preshow.
- September 29, 2023 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Ren Jones.
- October 7, 2023 – GCW: SGSuperCunt (1 Called Manders, Allie Katch, Effy, Mance Warner and Sawyer Wreck) defeated A Bunch Of Guys (Brayden Toon, Cole Radrick, Dyln McKay, Marcus Mathers and Shane Mercer).
- October 8, 2023 – GCW: Masashi Takeda defeated Mance Warner in a death match.
- October 14, 2023 – MLW: The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) defeated The Calling (Cannonball and Talon) in a chamber of horrors match.
- October 28, 2023 – PCW ULTRA: Warbeast (Jacob Fatu and Josef) defeated The Second Gear Crew (Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) to retain the ULTRA tag team titles.
- November 2, 2023 – MLW (Taped): Mance Warner defeated Talon.
- November 3, 2023 – GCW: Jimmy Lloyd & Los Macizos (Ciclope and Miedo Extremo) defeated The Second Gear Rejects (1 Called Manders, John Wayne Murdoch and Mance Warner).
- November 4, 2023 – GCW: BULLET CLUB War Dogs (Alex Coughlin and Gabe Kidd) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner).
- November 17, 2023 – GCW: Violence Is Forever (Dominic Garrini and Kevin Ku) defeated Jimmy Lloyd and Sawyer Wreck, The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) & The Bollywood Boyz (Gurv Sihra and Harv Sihra) in a 4-way tag team match to retain the tag team titles.
- November 18, 2023 – MLW Fightland: Matt Cardona w Saint Laurent defeated Mance Warner in a looser leaves MLW match.
- November 24, 2023 – GCW at WrestleCade: Joey Janela defeated Mance Warner in a hardcore rules match.
- December 1, 2023 – AAW: Mance Warner defeated Silas Young, Solomon Tupu and Xavier Walker in a 4-way, 1st round match. Mance Warner defeated 1 Called Manders, Gnarls Garvin and Robert Anthony in a 4-way match to win the tournament.
- December 2, 2023 – REVOLVER: RED (Alex Colon, Rickey Shane Page and Steve Maclin) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner and Matthew Justice) to retain the PWR tag team titles.
- December 3, 2023 – GCW: BUSSY (Allie Katch & Effy) & The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Mance Warner) defeated Wasted Youth (Dyln McKay & Marcus Mathers), Alec Price and Cole Radrick.
- December 7, 2023 – MLW Holiday Rush: Bomaye Fight Club (Alex Kane and Mr. Thomas) defeated The Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders and Good Brother #3) by disqualification. The Second Gear Crew retains the tag team titles.
- December 9, 2023 – GCW: The South Pacific Savages (Jacob Fatu and Juicy Finau) defeated Effy and Mance Warner.
- December 14, 2023 – MLW (Taped): Good Brother #3 was in the battle royal won by Josh Bishop.
- December 15, 2023 – WrestleMax: Davey Vega defeated Mance Warner to retain the River City title.
- December 30, 2023 – AAW: Davey Vega defeated Mance Warner to retain the heavyweight title.
- December 31, 2023 – GCW: Mance Warner won the do or die rumble match.
- January 6, 2024 – MLW Reload: Good Brother #3 defeated Steph De Lander.
- January 12, 2024 – GCW: Dan the Dad vs. Mance Warner ended in a no contest.
- January 25, 2024 – REVOLVER: Steve Maclin defeated Mance Warner.
- January 26, 2024 – GCW: Effy vs. Mance Warner ended in a no contest.
- February 4, 2024 – GCW: Bodhi Young Prodigy vs. Mance Warner ended in a no contest.
- February 23, 2024 – GCW: Allie Katch vs. Mance Warner in a Texas Bullrope match ended in a no contest.
- March 1, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated 1 Called Manders in a street fight.
- March 2, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Nate Webb.
- March 9, 2024 – GCW: Effy defeated Mance Warner in a Atlantic City strap match.
- March 16, 2024 – REVOLVER: RED (Alex Colon, Killer Kelly, Rickey Shane Page and Steve Maclin) defeated Second Gear Crew (1 Called Manders, Mance Warner & Matthew Justice) and Masha Slamovich in a war games rules match.
- March 21, 2024 – Demand Lucha: Seraphis defeated Mance Warner.
- March 24, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner vs. Microman ended in a no contest.
- March 28, 2024 – REVOLVER: 1 Called Manders defeated Mance Warner.
- March 29, 2024 – BLP: Elijah defeated Mance Warner.
- March 30, 2024 – SCX: Mance Warner was in the Prime title battle royal won by Ben Bishop.
- April 5, 2024 – GCW Joey Janela’s Spring Break: Mance Warner defeated Effy in a I Quit match.
- April 13, 2024 – OPW: Josh Alexander defeated Mance Warner in a ballarat brawl match.
- April 20, 2024 – Unsanctioned Pro #UP42: Mance Warner defeated Matthew Justice to retain the hardcore title.
- April 20, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Dark Sheik.
- April 21, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Colt.
- May 3, 2024 – GCW: Effy vs. Mance Warner ended in a no contest.
- May 17, 2024 – REVOLVER: 1 Called Manders vs. Mance Warner vs. Matthew Justice in a 3-way street fight ended in a no contest.
- May 18, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Marcus Mathers.
- May 25, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Cole Radrick.
- May 26, 2024 – GCW: Alec Price vs. Mance Warner ended in a no contest.
- June 2, 2024 – GCW: Effy defeated Mance Warner in a cage of survival match. Mance Warner defeated Joey Janela to win the World title.
- June 14, 2024 – GCW: Mance Warner defeated Jordan Oliver to retain the World title.